Transitions towards Sustainable and Resilient Rural Areas in Revitalising India

[Full title: Transitions towards Sustainable and Resilient Rural Areas in Revitalising India: A Framework for Localising SDGs at Gram Panchayat Level]

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Stage, Natural, Rapid, Change, South, New, Resources, Doi, India, Human, Gain, Level, Piotr, Basel, Local, Prus, Key, Road, Urban, Prisma, Planet, Long, Sameer, Development, Peri, Tailor, Ever, Areas, Under, Century, Gram, Architecture, State, Open, Progress, Arc, Smart, Due, April, Study, Strong, Pathak, Tree, Tel, March, Location, Focus]

Citation: Pathak, V.; Deshkar, S Transitions towards Sustainable and Resilient Rural Areas in Revitalising India: A Framework for Localising SDGs at Gram Panchayat Level Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536. https:// doi.org/10.3390/su 15097536 Academic Editor: Piotr Prus Received: 20 March 2023 Revised: 27 April 2023 Accepted: 28 April 2023 Published: 4 May 2023 Copyright: © 2023 by the authors Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/) sustainability Article Transitions towards Sustainable and Resilient Rural Areas in Revitalising India: A Framework for Localising SDGs at Gram Panchayat Level Vaidehi Pathak * and Sameer Deshkar Department of Architecture and Planning, Visvesvaraya National Institute of Technology, South Ambazari Road, Nagpur 440010, India; smdeshkar@arc.vnit.ac.in * Correspondence: vaidehi.pathak@students.vnit.ac.in; Tel.: +91-94-2026-1915 Abstract: Twenty-first century rural development (RD) demands a new paradigm of sustainability capable of addressing the difficulties and leveraging on the possibilities, such as climate change, demographic shift, international competitiveness, and rapid technological progress. Amidst these challenges, it is necessary to have a guiding framework from a long-term perspective that aids the integration of current RD policies while allowing space for location and community-specific innovations for implementing sustainable and resilient development strategies. India has witnessed several schemes and programmes for RD with exclusive objectives, varied focus areas, and separate domains, resulting in compartmentalisation in policy frameworks and disjointed implementation. Such initiatives were also often ideated from an urban perspective when it came to peri-urban rural areas or offered a generalist rural perspective (when referring to other rural regions, including those nested in ecological zones, thereby disregarding their local relevance). Accordingly, this study proposes a synchronised SMART village framework to tailor existing RD approaches for sustainable transformations aligned with the sustainable development goals and with a possibility of scaling its applicability in the local context. We initially conducted a bibliometric analysis to gain a comprehensive understanding of the emerging transformative approaches to RD, such as smart village (SV). Though in its nascent stage, the SV initiatives in India primarily envision information and communication technology enabled transformations in rural areas, often forcing villages to establish the relevance of such interventions. The study recognises key challenges to RD in India by using the problem tree analysis and further defines a SMART village framework that can be catalytic in transforming rural areas towards a sustainable and resilient state Keywords: smart village; sustainable rural development; rural vulnerability; SMART village framework; PRISMA analysis; problem tree analysis 1. Introduction Over the centuries, varying social, economic, and ecological forces have catalysed numerous transformations in how human settlements are shaped and operated [ 1 ]. The ever-exacerbating human actions have impacted the earth’s natural resources and outpaced the planet’s carrying capacity [ 2 ]. The resultant global challenges such as climate change, resource depletion, environmental degradation, and their local ramifications, such as conflicting resource sharing between regions, differentiated developments of urban and rural areas, unemployment, malnourishment, and poverty [ 3 ], make it imperative to search for holistic approaches for the development planning of underdeveloped regions Rural regions, particularly in the Global South, are inherently vulnerable due to their persisting poverty traps, social stratifications, population decline, predominant naturebased livelihoods, administrative incompetence, weak planning, and geographic isolation [ 4 ]. Addressing these endogenic vulnerabilities becomes imperative and calls for an alternative development framework to ensure rural sustainability under rapidly changing Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536. https://doi.org/10.3390/su 15097536 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/sustainability

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Shyama, Mission, Aim, Start, Better, Delivery, Standard, Life, Ready, Risk, Itu, Agreement, Paris, Safe, Central, Basic, Large, Novel, Future, Far, Year, Manner, Energy, Living, Home, Green, Knowledge, Seek, Past, Goal, Prasad, Line, Quality, Need]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 2 of 23 risk landscapes. Various platforms have long advocated a need for synergetic frameworks emphasising natural resource conservation and well-being to achieve sustainable development. In the year 2015, the global community adopted three ground-breaking agreements, namely the ‘2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development’ [ 5 ], the ‘Paris Climate Change Agreement’ [ 6 ], and the ‘Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030’ [ 7 , 8 ], to promote the assimilation of sustainable development principles into policy. Although efforts are being made, the far-distanced goal of localising these frameworks and converting them into actionable plans for rural areas remains challenging [ 9 ]. In addition, there is a need to promote a consistent approach to the three global agendas’ planning, execution, and reporting that will allow for more efficient use of resources, improved planning, and enhanced impacts of various initiatives. It will also assist in reducing future conflicts and ineffective execution of policies, allowing for the more efficient and productive achievement of shared agenda goals Against this backdrop and in line with sustainability and resilience, this research aims to define a framework for the future-ready development of rural regions, particularly at the Gram Panchayat level, which is a basic governing institution in Indian villages. This is in response to the country’s rapidly transforming economy and the sustainability challenges faced by rural settlements. India’s large and expanding economy, expected to become the third largest in the world by 2030 [ 10 ], is based on government economic reforms over the past three decades that promoted growth through liberalization, privatization, and deregulation [ 11 ]. Additionally, India has a thriving start-up environment with innovations and technology and is home to some of the world’s most pioneering and dynamic companies in the IT, pharma, and renewable energy sectors. Thus, science and technology (S&T) and information and communication technology (ICT) has helped transform the country’s economy from a traditional agrarian-based economy to a knowledge-based one. These efforts are also touching the transformations in rural sectors through government policies leveraging S&T innovations for safe and alternative livelihood, better service delivery, and improved quality of life for the rural populace Over the years, the Indian government’s objectives for RD have changed from survival to safety and in recent times are focused towards sustainable development [ 12 ] across multiple sectors, including agriculture, infrastructure, microfinance, community, and environmental conservation. Resultantly, to bring the vision of sustainable RD to reality, the government of India recently suggested many policies, schemes, and programme initiatives [ 13 ]. The smart villages (SV) approach is one of them. According to different institutions and organizations, such as the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), International Telecommunication Union (ITU), and European Union, the SV concept primarily relates to the use of S&T and ICT along with essential local assets to improve the provision of rural amenities in a highly effective manner [ 14 ]. For instance, Digital India, 2015 and the Shyama Prasad Mukherji Rurban Mission (SPMRM), 2016 are two initiatives that seek to promote sustainable RD by leveraging ICT and S&T. These initiatives aim to enhance economic, social, infrastructure, and environmental dimensions in rural areas, while also striving towards achieving the SDGs [ 15 ]. Along with the central government’s initiatives, several state governments have indicated an interest in SVs, as further elaborated in Section 2.4 , and are working to make them a reality through public-private partnerships [ 16 ]. The notion of SV has evolved into a globally accepted approach for enhancing the rural quality of life and addressing growing developmental concerns [ 17 ]. While SV is not a novel concept, it lacks a widely acknowledged definition. However, the concept of SV states that “local resources and technology should function as drivers for development [ 18 ], allowing education and local business possibilities, increasing health and welfare, promoting democratic involvement, and boosting the standard of living for people of rural villages” [ 19 ]. Accordingly, the innovative aspects of development are often correlated with other elements, such as the SDGs [ 20 ].These address, individually, sustainability, well-being, access to green energy, education, management of water resources, women’s

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Four, Work, Diet, Multi, Lines, Size, Sense, Point, Area, Aid, Role, Light, Self, Jobs, Spin, Nation, Core, Srd]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 3 of 23 and girls’ empowerment, sustainable economic growth, dignified employment, ensuring resilient infrastructures, supporting innovation, and reducing inequities [ 21 ]. Thus, at its core, SV intentionally increases participatory democracy, security, and gender equality while providing clean water, sanitation facilities, a nutritional diet, and establishing efficient jobs [ 14 ]. However, applying scientific and technological instruments to transforming rural regions in India poses several challenges towards its implementation and sustenance. Several studies have expressed concern for the urbanization of rural regions as a spin-off effect of the intrinsic benefits of improved infrastructures [ 22 , 23 ], drawing rural populations to metropolitan areas for better jobs, and infrastructure [ 24 ], thereby straining urban resources [ 25 ] and employment opportunities [ 26 ]. The current approach to SV solely emphasizes the application of technological solutions for rural infrastructure development and fails to address all aspects of rural life comprehensively. A more holistic approach that encompasses all dimensions of rural development, such as agriculture, environment, economy, social welfare, infrastructure, and governance, is necessary; thus, intending to prevent rural-urban migration and bring rural communities toward self-sufficiency, eventually This study postulates a SMART village (SMART-V) framework that encompasses various dimensions such as sustainable environment, manageable economy, adaptive society, responsive governance, and technological infrastructure. The SMART-V thus provides a multi-dimensional evaluation framework for establishing the local relevance of sustainable development strategies and one that can provide a basis for enhancing the performance and capacities of the local governing units at rural scale India is a culturally diverse and geographically expansive nation; centralised planning could only work up to a point with its one-size-fits-all approach [ 27 ]. Thus, it is required to understand what ‘SMART development’ is in the local community context. This research contributes to the sense perceptions of the SV by positioning it within broader conceptual experiences in sustainability and illustrating its practical implementation across several Indian villages. Subsequently, this study addresses the following research questions (RQ): RQ 1: Why is there a need for a synchronised framework to address sustainable rural development (SRD)?; RQ 2: What are the challenges and their implications for SRD?; RQ 3: How does the SMART-V approach aid in achieving SRD? Accordingly, the key objectives of this study are (1) to provide a guiding framework that supports the synchronization of current policies while exploring new possibilities based on local characteristics, (2) to overview the thrust area of existing RD initiatives, and (3) to highlight the role of SV in addressing the emerging challenges for SRD in developing countries such as India. By contextualizing SV within the broader conceptual framework of sustainability research, this study significantly contributes to existing knowledge on the subject. The study involves a literature survey based on a systematic review depending on the scope and objectives of the study. Along these lines, the paper is organised as follows: Section 2 sheds light on the need for innovative approaches to RD and provides an overview of the SV paradigm in the context of India’s RD mission. It also explains the methodology used for literature analysis and uses problem tree analysis to explore the significance of sustainability in resolving growing challenges for RD. Section 3 proposes the synchronised SMART-V framework for achieving sustainability through objective analysis and discusses the results and recommendations in Section 4 . Substantially, Section 5 summarises the key conclusions and research limitations. Finally, the paper concludes with acknowledgements and references 2. Materials and Methods This section outlines the methods and overview of existing literature on RD. In this section, there are four subdivisions. The first section explains how the PRISMA analysis method conducted the literature review. The second section reviews the literature on emerging concerns in SRD and the necessity for new RD paradigms. Furthermore, the concept of SV in the context of global and Indian initiatives is discussed. Likewise, in the

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Step, Map, Grey, Broad, Wos, Peer, Fields, Set, Field, Crafts, High, Few, Success, Web, Last, Table, Rate, Manual, Ssa, Case, Meta, Author, Rising, Flow, Liberati]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 4 of 23 last subdivision, problem tree analysis (also known as situational analysis) has helped map out the drivers of causes and their effects on rural issues 2.1. Literature Analysis Although overview papers in the domain of smart SRD are few, there are papers from allied disciplines that review the literature in their fields. In this study, referring to RQs, a systematic review was conducted using the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA) method guidelines proposed by Liberati et al. (2009) [ 28 ]. Following the PRISMA guidelines, the study primarily executed search queries in the Web of Science (WOS) database, and additional high-quality online sources such as books and conference proceedings. The results of the WOS basic search are depicted in Figure 1 . In this case, two independent searches were conducted in the “ALL” category using the keywords “Rural Development” and “Smart Villages”. Using our set search keywords, we initially retrieved 128,276 (Rural Development: RD) and 419 (Smart Villages: SV) papers from WOS. In the context of RD, the study then modified the documents focusing on SV to filter out the search question to ‘RD + SV’, through which we identified 88 research documents. Secondly, to identify research studies focusing on framework formulation in the context of SV, the study applied another search query with the keywords ‘SV + Framework’, which identified 74 research documents. After the manual screening, the study extracted the literature database titles, and the relevant literature was determined, regardless of the field of study, year of publication, type of document, etc. Furthermore, in the next step of shortlisting research documents, the study selected 67 documents for assessment. In addition to the WOS database search, the study considered 27 other research materials and grey literature-like reports, conference papers, working papers, books, and websites for this study Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 5 of 24 Figure 1. Prisma flow application (Source: Author, based on [28,29]). 2.2. Paradigm Changes in Rural Development RD refers to the comprehensive development of rural regions to enhance the quality of life of rural populations [30]. In this respect, it is a broad and multidimensional notion that includes the growth of agricultural and related activities, traditional crafts, cottage industries, community services and amenities, socioeconomic infrastructure, and, most importantly, human resources in rural regions [9]. Conventionally, India ’ s policies were centred on improving the economic and social conditions of agrarian society ’ s vulnerable groups [31], particularly emphasising agricultural productivity [32]. However, the most recent and significant RD paradigm emphasises the multifunctional structure of rural regions and the need to ensure the sustainability of their growth [33]. Even though there are many government efforts at all levels — central, state, and local — the growth rate has not kept up with the rising requirements [34]. Separate flagship initiatives focused on various sectors, such as health (NRHM) [35], education (SSA) [36], and livelihood (NREGA, NRLM) [37,38], have already been established but have had limited success as highlighted in Table 1. If conventional rural development initiatives had been more effective, rural poverty would have been significantly reduced [39]. Perhaps, one of the rationales for the RD initiative ’ s inadequacy has been an absence of a comprehensive emphasis on the village as a unit. Thus, conventional approaches must be redefined, and new perspectives for RD strategies must be established. The concepts and methods for assessing and managing rural change need to shift from theoretical, managerial, and centralised approaches to more constructionist, participatory, and decentralised rural change perspectives [40]. Figure 1. Prisma flow application (Source: Author, based on [ 28 , 29 ]).

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Prior]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 5 of 23 2.2. Paradigm Changes in Rural Development RD refers to the comprehensive development of rural regions to enhance the quality of life of rural populations [ 30 ]. In this respect, it is a broad and multidimensional notion that includes the growth of agricultural and related activities, traditional crafts, cottage industries, community services and amenities, socioeconomic infrastructure, and, most importantly, human resources in rural regions [ 9 ]. Conventionally, India’s policies were centred on improving the economic and social conditions of agrarian society’s vulnerable groups [ 31 ], particularly emphasising agricultural productivity [ 32 ]. However, the most recent and significant RD paradigm emphasises the multifunctional structure of rural regions and the need to ensure the sustainability of their growth [ 33 ]. Even though there are many government efforts at all levels—central, state, and local—the growth rate has not kept up with the rising requirements [ 34 ]. Separate flagship initiatives focused on various sectors, such as health (NRHM) [ 35 ], education (SSA) [ 36 ], and livelihood (NREGA, NRLM) [ 37 , 38 ], have already been established but have had limited success as highlighted in Table 1 . If conventional rural development initiatives had been more effective, rural poverty would have been significantly reduced [ 39 ]. Perhaps, one of the rationales for the RD initiative’s inadequacy has been an absence of a comprehensive emphasis on the village as a unit. Thus, conventional approaches must be redefined, and new perspectives for RD strategies must be established. The concepts and methods for assessing and managing rural change need to shift from theoretical, managerial, and centralised approaches to more constructionist, participatory, and decentralised rural change perspectives [ 40 ]. Table 1. Urban-rural divide in development sectors Sector Parameters Urban Rural Expenditure poverty % People below poverty line (2011–2012) (Tendulkar estimates) 14% 26% % People below poverty line (2011–2012) (Rangarajan estimates) 27.2% 31.3% Education Literacy Rate–2011 85% 68.9% Avg. years of school education of working population 8.42 4.72 Health Infant Mortality Rate–2017 23% 37% Life Expectancy at birth–2012–2016 72.2% 67.4% Source: Census India 2011 [ 41 ], National Health Profile (NHP) of India-2019: Ministry of Health and Family Welfare 2016 [ 42 , 43 ]. Accordingly, several researchers, agencies, and international organizations have developed effective frameworks for reducing rural poverty, human slavery, and inequality, besides achieving sustainability [ 32 ]. Table 2 summarizes the progression of rural development thinking and techniques, highlighting the old paradigms based on prior policies and schemes [ 31 ], further emphasizes some of the new challenges and opportunities, and outlines some of the core characteristics of the new rural development approach for emerging villages [ 44 ].

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Humanity, Vital, Tourism, Main, Play, Grid, Civil, Non, Target, Able]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 6 of 23 Table 2. The paradigm shift: transformation to a new rural development Old Paradigm New Context New Paradigm Principles Focus on rural areas only Widening inequalities between rural and urban Rural areas inextricably linked to cities, regions and national context Growth will follow agricultural and industrial development Climate change Women critical for RD Rapid population growth in many developing countries Governance capacity is key Information revolution Key target Sector Agriculture Agriculture unable to provide sustainable livelihoods for growing populations Multi-sectoral: all economic sectors that can contribute to productive growth: agriculture, rural industry, services, tourism, ICT, biofuels Rural communities Urban areas not able to productively absorb large inflows of rural migrants Main approach Project-based Sustainable Development Goals Tailored to the specific context (natural, economic, social, and institutional) Agricultural Technology Multi-dimensional poverty assessment and Multi-dimensional Country Review Prioritized and realistic Green Revolution Community-driven development Well-sequenced to maximize synergies Key actors Agricultural ministries, agricultural research and extension, donors, local governments, and farmers Greater participation by non-state actors including the private sector, rural communities, Civil Society Organization (CSOs) and NGOs Multi-agent: participation and collaboration of broad set of stakeholders across public and private sectors and from national to local Source: OECD, 2016 [ 44 ]. Considering this, a 21 st-century village in India needs to incorporate specific vital themes and approaches such as sustainability, resilience, or smart village, which would be essential for its success. The new paradigm for RD must accelerate the appropriate changes required to bring us closer to the SDG goals, the fulfilment of which will be strongly intertwined with boosting rural communities’ capacities, opportunities, and levels of wellbeing. The altered paradigm emphasizes the importance of context-specific approaches that maximize synergies between different domains of RD. Accordingly, a SV is built on the grounds of science, technology, engineering, regulations, and management to build next-generation sustainable villages [ 45 ]. A subsequent portion of the study will go into further detail about the SV Approach 2.3. Global Interpretations on SV S&T and ICT have demonstrated substantial opportunities for humanity’s benefit in various disciplines, such as food security, livelihood potentials, energy, and capacity building, with the potential to address and serve the developing needs of locals [ 46 ]. Research in various developing countries worldwide has emphasised the potential of these technologies for RD through the SV approach, thus they will play an essential role in achieving rapid and sustainable RD in the subsequent years. For instance, the primary goal of the IEEE Smart Village: Empowering Off-Grid Communities [ 47 ] program, started in 2010, aims to adopt more comprehensive and inclusive approaches to delivering access to energy in rural areas, with the key consideration being how renewable energy sources

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: America, Thailand, Plan, Vary, Low, West, Mexico, East, Power, Keep, Asia, Part, Person, Middle, Track, Cost, Given, Names, Lower, Africa, Socio, Solar, Common]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 7 of 23 are integrated with ICT [ 48 ]. In addition to promoting their sustainability and scalability, this initiative also educates communities on constructing and designing off-grid solar power panels. South Asia, South-East Asia, East Africa, West Africa, South America, Central America, the Caribbean, and Mexico are regions where the initiative’s activities are ongoing [ 49 ]. Similarly, the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) programme on Climate Change, Agriculture, and Food Security (CCAFS), 2011 [ 50 ], is one of the most propulsive global initiatives. They strive to reduce the climatic footprint of expanding agricultural operations while maintaining their benefits to the community while considering innovative technology and services developed in conjunction with local communities [ 51 ]. The climate-smart village is being developed and implemented within this framework in many regions, with over 30 climate-smart villages, as in New Zealand, Australia, and Thailand [ 45 ]. Likewise, the comprehensive scheme of the European Union’s Smart Village Plan (2014–2020) [ 52 ] highlighted that SVs are not only for the construction of new infrastructures but also for social innovation and the building capacity of locals [ 53 ]. Additionally, since the thrust of the current study is on developing countries, experiments from South Asian countries notable from low and lower-middle-income countries (LLMIC) such as India [ 46 ], where a majority of the population lives in rural regions, the SV approach also needs to be studied 2.4. SV Initiatives in India Initiated with the “Digital India” Programme in 2015, the digital transformation played a vital role in improving transparent, efficient, and cost-effective rural governance [ 54 ]. The government of India and several public and private, non-governmental organizations are working on developing digital technology for rural areas [ 16 ] by providing broadband connectivity, digital literacy, and e-governance services. For instance, the availability of cashless electronic transactions aids in generating new business [ 55 ]. Similarly, India’s S&T field has made a substantial contribution to the advancement of the nation’s growth [ 56 ] by supporting high-level basic research and the development of novel technologies inclusive of addressing the technical needs of the average person by developing relevant skills and technology. Appropriate rural technology utilizes local or regional competence to manage local demands without relying on external influences [ 57 ]. It comprises common and affordable technologies to benefit ordinary people and their communities. However, due to the number of challenges, these digital initiatives have had minimal influence on rural people’s lifestyles. There is widespread illiteracy, irregular electrical supply, substantial bandwidth concerns, financial concerns in developing ICT infrastructure, a significant shortage of skilled project leaders, and so on [ 58 ]. Different states have given other names to the SV initiatives. While the programmes’ goals are similar, the initiatives’ focus areas differ [ 59 ]. However, there is no compilation of how many SV have evolved or mainstreamed in India; instead, various fragmented lists and web portals are dedicated to specific villages, making it challenging to keep track of the numbers [ 45 ]. Table 3 provides further details on the different SV approaches implemented by various communities throughout India in recognised domains of RD and with their objectives. Furthermore, as rural areas vary considerably in terms of geographic location and socio-cultural diversity, effective smart interventions will necessitate a strategy tailored to the specific location [ 60 ]. Accordingly, by studying selected villages from India taking part in the government programme on SV development, the possibilities for replication or upscaling of such initiatives for other villages are contemplated. Even though no village under this approach in India has incorporated all of the components envisioned in the SMART-V, the cumulative knowledge gathered from these villagers’ efforts may pave the way for gaining smartness in their particular development sectors.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Trees, Mori, Own, Punjab, Links, Rivers, Bazar, Wood, Move, Skill, Tamil, Base, Ups, Kerala, Siddhi, Dams, Data, Rain, Patient, Burden, Run, Farmer, Bet, Betul, Wind, Bihar, Towns, Cook, Nadu, Nano, Rajasthan, Schools]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 8 of 23 Table 3. Various approaches and their objectives under different domains of SV in India Domain of Development Approaches Objectives Examples (Villages) Smart Environment Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 of 24 It comprises common and affordable technologies to benefit ordinary people and their communities. However, due to the number of challenges, these digital initiatives have had minimal influence on rural people ’ s lifestyles. There is widespread illiteracy, irregular electrical supply, substantial bandwidth concerns, financial concerns in developing ICT infrastructure, a significant shortage of skilled project leaders, and so on [58]. Different states have given other names to the SV initiatives. While the programmes ’ goals are similar, the initiatives ’ focus areas differ [59]. However, there is no compilation of how many SV have evolved or mainstreamed in India; instead, various fragmented lists and web portals are dedicated to specific villages, making it challenging to keep track of the numbers [45]. Table 3 provides further details on the different SV approaches implemented by various communities throughout India in recognised domains of RD and with their objectives. Furthermore, as rural areas vary considerably in terms of geographic location and socio-cultural diversity, effective smart interventions will necessitate a strategy tailored to the specific location [60]. Accordingly, by studying selected villages from India taking part in the government programme on SV development, the possibilities for replication or upscaling of such initiatives for other villages are contemplated. Even though no village under this approach in India has incorporated all of the components envisioned in the SMART-V, the cumulative knowledge gathered from these villagers ’ efforts may pave the way for gaining smartness in their particular development sectors. Table 3. Various approaches and their objectives under different domains of SV in India. Domain of Development Approaches Objectives Examples (Villages) Smart Environment Planting native trees, Afforestation Managing the built and natural environment to improve livability Betul, Madhya Pradesh Reuse and Recycling of waste materials Payvihir, Melghat, Maharashtra Use efficient cook stoves to reduce deforestation caused by traditional biomass energy sources such as charcoal/ wood The reduction of waste production, monitoring and managing pollution, emission reduction, achieving energy efficiency, and accelerating the local energy transition Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Acting as regional ecotourism hubs Smart Energy Provision of clean and sustainable energy To reduce resource depletion the use of fossil fuels needs to be reduced Chhotkei, Odisha Implementation of Smart Nano grid Need for efficient use of renewable energy sources Odanthurai, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu Use of Renewable sources of energy such as solar, wind and hydro power Dharni, Jehanabad, Bihar Smart Water Management Rain Water Harvesting To improve ground water level Ralegaon Siddhi, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Water percolation tanks Dams constructed by waste Materials To monitor, control and regulate the usage and quality of water resources as well as maintain the associated equipment Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Rejuvenate rivers Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Maharashtra Drinking RO water in schools Planting native trees, Afforestation Managing the built and natural environment to improve livability Betul, Madhya Pradesh Reuse and Recycling of waste materials Payvihir, Melghat, Maharashtra Use efficient cook stoves to reduce deforestation caused by traditional biomass energy sources such as charcoal/ wood The reduction of waste production, monitoring and managing pollution, emission reduction, achieving energy efficiency, and accelerating the local energy transition Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Acting as regional ecotourism hubs Smart Energy Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 of 24 It comprises common and affordable technologies to benefit ordinary people and their communities. However, due to the number of challenges, these digital initiatives have had minimal influence on rural people ’ s lifestyles. There is widespread illiteracy, irregular electrical supply, substantial bandwidth concerns, financial concerns in developing ICT infrastructure, a significant shortage of skilled project leaders, and so on [58]. Different states have given other names to the SV initiatives. While the programmes ’ goals are similar, the initiatives ’ focus areas differ [59]. However, there is no compilation of how many SV have evolved or mainstreamed in India; instead, various fragmented lists and web portals are dedicated to specific villages, making it challenging to keep track of the numbers [45]. Table 3 provides further details on the different SV approaches implemented by various communities throughout India in recognised domains of RD and with their objectives. Furthermore, as rural areas vary considerably in terms of geographic location and socio-cultural diversity, effective smart interventions will necessitate a strategy tailored to the specific location [60]. Accordingly, by studying selected villages from India taking part in the government programme on SV development, the possibilities for replication or upscaling of such initiatives for other villages are contemplated. Even though no village under this approach in India has incorporated all of the components envisioned in the SMART-V, the cumulative knowledge gathered from these villagers ’ efforts may pave the way for gaining smartness in their particular development sectors. Table 3. Various approaches and their objectives under different domains of SV in India. Domain of Development Approaches Objectives Examples (Villages) Smart Environment Planting native trees, Afforestation Managing the built and natural environment to improve livability Betul, Madhya Pradesh Reuse and Recycling of waste materials Payvihir, Melghat, Maharashtra Use efficient cook stoves to reduce deforestation caused by traditional biomass energy sources such as charcoal/ wood The reduction of waste production, monitoring and managing pollution, emission reduction, achieving energy efficiency, and accelerating the local energy transition Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Acting as regional ecotourism hubs Smart Energy Provision of clean and sustainable energy To reduce resource depletion the use of fossil fuels needs to be reduced Chhotkei, Odisha Implementation of Smart Nano grid Need for efficient use of renewable energy sources Odanthurai, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu Use of Renewable sources of energy such as solar, wind and hydro power Dharni, Jehanabad, Bihar Smart Water Management Rain Water Harvesting To improve ground water level Ralegaon Siddhi, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Water percolation tanks Dams constructed by waste Materials To monitor, control and regulate the usage and quality of water resources as well as maintain the associated equipment Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Rejuvenate rivers Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Maharashtra Drinking RO water in schools Provision of clean and sustainable energy To reduce resource depletion the use of fossil fuels needs to be reduced Chhotkei, Odisha Implementation of Smart Nano grid Need for efficient use of renewable energy sources Odanthurai, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu Use of Renewable sources of energy such as solar, wind and hydro power Dharni, Jehanabad, Bihar Smart Water Management Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 8 of 24 It comprises common and affordable technologies to benefit ordinary people and their communities. However, due to the number of challenges, these digital initiatives have had minimal influence on rural people ’ s lifestyles. There is widespread illiteracy, irregular electrical supply, substantial bandwidth concerns, financial concerns in developing ICT infrastructure, a significant shortage of skilled project leaders, and so on [58]. Different states have given other names to the SV initiatives. While the programmes ’ goals are similar, the initiatives ’ focus areas differ [59]. However, there is no compilation of how many SV have evolved or mainstreamed in India; instead, various fragmented lists and web portals are dedicated to specific villages, making it challenging to keep track of the numbers [45]. Table 3 provides further details on the different SV approaches implemented by various communities throughout India in recognised domains of RD and with their objectives. Furthermore, as rural areas vary considerably in terms of geographic location and socio-cultural diversity, effective smart interventions will necessitate a strategy tailored to the specific location [60]. Accordingly, by studying selected villages from India taking part in the government programme on SV development, the possibilities for replication or upscaling of such initiatives for other villages are contemplated. Even though no village under this approach in India has incorporated all of the components envisioned in the SMART-V, the cumulative knowledge gathered from these villagers ’ efforts may pave the way for gaining smartness in their particular development sectors. Table 3. Various approaches and their objectives under different domains of SV in India. Domain of Development Approaches Objectives Examples (Villages) Smart Environment Planting native trees, Afforestation Managing the built and natural environment to improve livability Betul, Madhya Pradesh Reuse and Recycling of waste materials Payvihir, Melghat, Maharashtra Use efficient cook stoves to reduce deforestation caused by traditional biomass energy sources such as charcoal/ wood The reduction of waste production, monitoring and managing pollution, emission reduction, achieving energy efficiency, and accelerating the local energy transition Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Acting as regional ecotourism hubs Smart Energy Provision of clean and sustainable energy To reduce resource depletion the use of fossil fuels needs to be reduced Chhotkei, Odisha Implementation of Smart Nano grid Need for efficient use of renewable energy sources Odanthurai, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu Use of Renewable sources of energy such as solar, wind and hydro power Dharni, Jehanabad, Bihar Smart Water Management Rain Water Harvesting To improve ground water level Ralegaon Siddhi, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Water percolation tanks Dams constructed by waste Materials To monitor, control and regulate the usage and quality of water resources as well as maintain the associated equipment Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Rejuvenate rivers Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Maharashtra Drinking RO water in schools Rain Water Harvesting To improve ground water level Ralegaon Siddhi, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Water percolation tanks Dams constructed by waste Materials To monitor, control and regulate the usage and quality of water resources as well as maintain the associated equipment Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Rejuvenate rivers Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Maharashtra Drinking RO water in schools Water purification Plants To reduce water wastage Dhanora, Dholpur Rajasthan Soil and water conservation Smart Sanitation Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 24 Water purification Plants To reduce water wastage Dhanora, Dholpur Rajasthan Soil and water conservation Smart Sanitation Individual toilets Reducing the burden of disease Ramchandrapur, Telangana Recycle and Reuse of waste water To create environments that enhance dignity, self-esteem, and safety particularly for women and girls Monitoring quality of potable water Smart Connectivity Integrate ICT solutions, applications, and services into smart technology solutions for various domains, such as agriculture, water management, education, and healthcare Application for environmental monitoring Mori Village, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh To allow rural communities to become more aware of their social, economic and political rights, engage in governance processes at all levels Involving rural communities is expected to lead to better awareness, engagement, and knowledge about their own development. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh Forming base for many entrepreneurs and start-ups within social innovation. Smart Agriculture/Horticulture Infusion of technology for agriculture Practices To gather data from the environment to monitor weather conditions Climate SV Noorpur Bet, Punjab Improving capacity building of farmer To provide benefit of allowing farmers to use a precarious resource such as water carefully. Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Improvisation in farming practices such as irrigation and crop cultivation Eraviperoor, Kerala Smart Health Assisting mobile health diagnostic solutions which required relatively low levels of local medical skill Application of health services to remote areas such as remote patient monitoring, remote medical assistance, simultaneous monitoring and reporting, notifications and alert management Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Smart Education By introducing skill development centres run by village residents who have links with the nearby city and a reasonable degree of organizing capability To increase students’ engagement and enable teachers to adapt to students’ skills, interests and learning preferences. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh By generating distance and adaptive learning which reduces the need to move to towns or cities to achieve higher levels of education. To establish innovations centres for students/ youth Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Source: Author, based on [59,61]. Individual toilets Reducing the burden of disease Ramchandrapur, Telangana Recycle and Reuse of waste water To create environments that enhance dignity, self-esteem, and safety particularly for women and girls Monitoring quality of potable water

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Cont]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 9 of 23 Table 3. Cont Domain of Development Approaches Objectives Examples (Villages) Smart Connectivity Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 24 Water purification Plants To reduce water wastage Dhanora, Dholpur Rajasthan Soil and water conservation Smart Sanitation Individual toilets Reducing the burden of disease Ramchandrapur, Telangana Recycle and Reuse of waste water To create environments that enhance dignity, self-esteem, and safety particularly for women and girls Monitoring quality of potable water Smart Connectivity Integrate ICT solutions, applications, and services into smart technology solutions for various domains, such as agriculture, water management, education, and healthcare Application for environmental monitoring Mori Village, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh To allow rural communities to become more aware of their social, economic and political rights, engage in governance processes at all levels Involving rural communities is expected to lead to better awareness, engagement, and knowledge about their own development. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh Forming base for many entrepreneurs and start-ups within social innovation. Smart Agriculture/Horticulture Infusion of technology for agriculture Practices To gather data from the environment to monitor weather conditions Climate SV Noorpur Bet, Punjab Improving capacity building of farmer To provide benefit of allowing farmers to use a precarious resource such as water carefully. Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Improvisation in farming practices such as irrigation and crop cultivation Eraviperoor, Kerala Smart Health Assisting mobile health diagnostic solutions which required relatively low levels of local medical skill Application of health services to remote areas such as remote patient monitoring, remote medical assistance, simultaneous monitoring and reporting, notifications and alert management Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Smart Education By introducing skill development centres run by village residents who have links with the nearby city and a reasonable degree of organizing capability To increase students’ engagement and enable teachers to adapt to students’ skills, interests and learning preferences. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh By generating distance and adaptive learning which reduces the need to move to towns or cities to achieve higher levels of education. To establish innovations centres for students/ youth Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Source: Author, based on [59,61]. Integrate ICT solutions, applications, and services into smart technology solutions for various domains, such as agriculture, water management, education, and healthcare Application for environmental monitoring Mori Village, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh To allow rural communities to become more aware of their social, economic and political rights, engage in governance processes at all levels Involving rural communities is expected to lead to better awareness, engagement, and knowledge about their own development Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh Forming base for many entrepreneurs and start-ups within social innovation Smart Agriculture/Horticulture Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 24 Water purification Plants To reduce water wastage Dhanora, Dholpur Rajasthan Soil and water conservation Smart Sanitation Individual toilets Reducing the burden of disease Ramchandrapur, Telangana Recycle and Reuse of waste water To create environments that enhance dignity, self-esteem, and safety particularly for women and girls Monitoring quality of potable water Smart Connectivity Integrate ICT solutions, applications, and services into smart technology solutions for various domains, such as agriculture, water management, education, and healthcare Application for environmental monitoring Mori Village, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh To allow rural communities to become more aware of their social, economic and political rights, engage in governance processes at all levels Involving rural communities is expected to lead to better awareness, engagement, and knowledge about their own development. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh Forming base for many entrepreneurs and start-ups within social innovation. Smart Agriculture/Horticulture Infusion of technology for agriculture Practices To gather data from the environment to monitor weather conditions Climate SV Noorpur Bet, Punjab Improving capacity building of farmer To provide benefit of allowing farmers to use a precarious resource such as water carefully. Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Improvisation in farming practices such as irrigation and crop cultivation Eraviperoor, Kerala Smart Health Assisting mobile health diagnostic solutions which required relatively low levels of local medical skill Application of health services to remote areas such as remote patient monitoring, remote medical assistance, simultaneous monitoring and reporting, notifications and alert management Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Smart Education By introducing skill development centres run by village residents who have links with the nearby city and a reasonable degree of organizing capability To increase students’ engagement and enable teachers to adapt to students’ skills, interests and learning preferences. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh By generating distance and adaptive learning which reduces the need to move to towns or cities to achieve higher levels of education. To establish innovations centres for students/ youth Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Source: Author, based on [59,61]. Infusion of technology for agriculture Practices To gather data from the environment to monitor weather conditions Climate SV Noorpur Bet, Punjab Improving capacity building of farmer To provide benefit of allowing farmers to use a precarious resource such as water carefully Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Improvisation in farming practices such as irrigation and crop cultivation Eraviperoor, Kerala Smart Health Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 24 Water purification Plants To reduce water wastage Dhanora, Dholpur Rajasthan Soil and water conservation Smart Sanitation Individual toilets Reducing the burden of disease Ramchandrapur, Telangana Recycle and Reuse of waste water To create environments that enhance dignity, self-esteem, and safety particularly for women and girls Monitoring quality of potable water Smart Connectivity Integrate ICT solutions, applications, and services into smart technology solutions for various domains, such as agriculture, water management, education, and healthcare Application for environmental monitoring Mori Village, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh To allow rural communities to become more aware of their social, economic and political rights, engage in governance processes at all levels Involving rural communities is expected to lead to better awareness, engagement, and knowledge about their own development. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh Forming base for many entrepreneurs and start-ups within social innovation. Smart Agriculture/Horticulture Infusion of technology for agriculture Practices To gather data from the environment to monitor weather conditions Climate SV Noorpur Bet, Punjab Improving capacity building of farmer To provide benefit of allowing farmers to use a precarious resource such as water carefully. Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Improvisation in farming practices such as irrigation and crop cultivation Eraviperoor, Kerala Smart Health Assisting mobile health diagnostic solutions which required relatively low levels of local medical skill Application of health services to remote areas such as remote patient monitoring, remote medical assistance, simultaneous monitoring and reporting, notifications and alert management Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Smart Education By introducing skill development centres run by village residents who have links with the nearby city and a reasonable degree of organizing capability To increase students’ engagement and enable teachers to adapt to students’ skills, interests and learning preferences. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh By generating distance and adaptive learning which reduces the need to move to towns or cities to achieve higher levels of education. To establish innovations centres for students/ youth Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Source: Author, based on [59,61]. Assisting mobile health diagnostic solutions which required relatively low levels of local medical skill Application of health services to remote areas such as remote patient monitoring, remote medical assistance, simultaneous monitoring and reporting, notifications and alert management Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Smart Education Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 9 of 24 Water purification Plants To reduce water wastage Dhanora, Dholpur Rajasthan Soil and water conservation Smart Sanitation Individual toilets Reducing the burden of disease Ramchandrapur, Telangana Recycle and Reuse of waste water To create environments that enhance dignity, self-esteem, and safety particularly for women and girls Monitoring quality of potable water Smart Connectivity Integrate ICT solutions, applications, and services into smart technology solutions for various domains, such as agriculture, water management, education, and healthcare Application for environmental monitoring Mori Village, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh To allow rural communities to become more aware of their social, economic and political rights, engage in governance processes at all levels Involving rural communities is expected to lead to better awareness, engagement, and knowledge about their own development. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh Forming base for many entrepreneurs and start-ups within social innovation. Smart Agriculture/Horticulture Infusion of technology for agriculture Practices To gather data from the environment to monitor weather conditions Climate SV Noorpur Bet, Punjab Improving capacity building of farmer To provide benefit of allowing farmers to use a precarious resource such as water carefully. Hiware Bazar, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra Improvisation in farming practices such as irrigation and crop cultivation Eraviperoor, Kerala Smart Health Assisting mobile health diagnostic solutions which required relatively low levels of local medical skill Application of health services to remote areas such as remote patient monitoring, remote medical assistance, simultaneous monitoring and reporting, notifications and alert management Anadwan, Hemalkasa, Gadchiroli, Maharashtra Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Smart Education By introducing skill development centres run by village residents who have links with the nearby city and a reasonable degree of organizing capability To increase students’ engagement and enable teachers to adapt to students’ skills, interests and learning preferences. Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh By generating distance and adaptive learning which reduces the need to move to towns or cities to achieve higher levels of education. To establish innovations centres for students/ youth Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Source: Author, based on [59,61]. By introducing skill development centres run by village residents who have links with the nearby city and a reasonable degree of organizing capability To increase students’ engagement and enable teachers to adapt to students’ skills, interests and learning preferences Paniyara, Uttar Pradesh By generating distance and adaptive learning which reduces the need to move to towns or cities to achieve higher levels of education To establish innovations centres for students/youth Nandangram, Dinajpur, West Bengal Source: Author, based on [ 59 , 61 ].

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Act, Harms, Crime, Tool, Harm]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 10 of 23 2.5. Problem Tree Analysis (PTA) Referring to RQ 2, this section focuses on the socioeconomic and environmental challenges that rural communities worldwide face. In the current context, rural populations are more vulnerable to extreme poverty, starvation, social marginalization, environmental harm, etc. [ 62 ]. The emergence of these challenges and barriers harms the person’s living conditions and creates obstacles to their advancement. Accordingly, by adopting problem tree analysis [ 63 ], a structural analysis tool, the subsequent study will address some of the inevitable problems for RD and their negative consequence in Stage 1. However, Stage 2, Section 3.2 will further describe how SMART interventions can act as catalysts to overcome the challenges for the same and how further SMART-V will lead to sustainability by achieving SDGs PTA: Stage 1: Problem Analysis Poverty, illiteracy, unemployment, social conflicts, homelessness, crime, and violence all lead to insecurity and threaten RD. Thus, by identifying the primary causes and their most significant impacts, PTA assists in developing a realistic perspective and knowledge of the situation [ 63 ]. Thereupon, Figure 2 illustrates Stage 1: Problem Analysis, which provides a brief of causes and their negative consequences on RD under five key development domains, namely environment, economy, social, governance, and infrastructure. It also generates a summary of the current unfavourable conditions for RD.

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 11 of 23 Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 11 of 24 Figure 2. Stage 1-Problem Analysis — (identifying negative aspects) defines the focal problem, its immediate and direct causes, and its effects, (Source: Author, based on [63,64]). Figure 2. Stage 1-Problem Analysis—(identifying negative aspects) defines the focal problem, its immediate and direct causes, and its effects, (Source: Author, based on [ 63 , 64 ]).

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Modern, Care, Farm, Nexus, Single, Poor, Loss, Carbon, Ability, Lack, Sales, Goods]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 12 of 23 For instance, under the infrastructure as development dimension, through the airwater-soil nexus [ 65 ], the shortage of, or inadequate attention to, public services in rural areas promotes environmental degradation [ 66 ] leading to health issues, too. Furthermore, the control of water supply, sewage, and stormwater drainage has traditionally been assigned to different agencies. Due to the lack of a comprehensive strategy to manage these closely interrelated activities, opportunities are lost for recycling and establishing a circular economy around water, energy, and materials. Similarly, limited roads or poor access to roads increase transportation costs, limit the availability of high-quality inputs, and confine the use of local markets for sales of farm products, purchases of consumer goods, and options for off-farm jobs, resulting in a lack of ability to scaleup their business. Poor road access has also restricted rural people’s access to essential social infrastructures such as education and health care [ 67 ] leading to rural–urban migration 3. Results 3.1. Strengthening the Concept of SMART Villages (SMART-V) Referring to Section 2.5 , it is evident that rural communities face complex and interrelated challenges that a single sector cannot effectively address. Adopted by this study, Figure 3 depicts the core concept of the “SMART” approach, which uses an abbreviation instead of a prefix for the word “Village”. The figure showcases how the SMART approach will address the five dimensions of rural development: environment, economy, social, governance, and infrastructure. The SMART approach is sustainable, measurable, adaptable, responsible, and technological and will promote holistic development. This new approach justifies the need for more SDGs because it recognizes the interconnectedness of the various aspects of sustainable development in a coordinated manner. As mentioned above, the SMART abbreviation stands for: Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 12 of 24 For instance, under the infrastructure as development dimension, through the airwater-soil nexus [65], the shortage of, or inadequate attention to, public services in rural areas promotes environmental degradation [66] leading to health issues, too. Furthermore, the control of water supply, sewage, and stormwater drainage has traditionally been assigned to different agencies. Due to the lack of a comprehensive strategy to manage these closely interrelated activities, opportunities are lost for recycling and establishing a circular economy around water, energy, and materials. Similarly, limited roads or poor access to roads increase transportation costs, limit the availability of high-quality inputs, and confine the use of local markets for sales of farm products, purchases of consumer goods, and options for off-farm jobs, resulting in a lack of ability to scaleup their business. Poor road access has also restricted rural people ’ s access to essential social infrastructures such as education and health care [67] leading to rural – urban migration. 3. Results 3.1. Strengthening the Concept of SMART Villages (SMART-V) Referring to Section 2.5, it is evident that rural communities face complex and interrelated challenges that a single sector cannot effectively address. Adopted by this study, Figure 3 depicts the core concept of the “ SMART ” approach, which uses an abbreviation instead of a prefix for the word “ Village ” . The figure showcases how the SMART approach will address the five dimensions of rural development: environment, economy, social, governance, and infrastructure. The SMART approach is sustainable, measurable, adaptable, responsible, and technological and will promote holistic development. This new approach justifies the need for more SDGs because it recognizes the interconnectedness of the various aspects of sustainable development in a coordinated manner. As mentioned above, the SMART abbreviation stands for: Figure 3. The fundamental concept of SMART is applied across various dimensions of RD (Source: Author, based on [68,69]). • Sustainable Environment: Environmental sustainability should be included in RD initiatives because rural communities rely heavily on natural resources for livelihoods and growth, and because of their susceptibility to climate change and risks from energy, water scarcity, and food [70]. Likewise, increased concern about climate change and growing recognition of the necessity for low-carbon development paths should emphasize boosting access to modern energy services through renewable energy technologies [71]. • Manageable Economy: Linear economy models result in the loss of natural resources, excessive pollution, and socioeconomic inequalities [72]. Thus, integrating a circular economy may convey RD, which involves a concept or system that preserves as much of a product ’ s added value as possible while eliminating waste. Similarly, in many Figure 3. The fundamental concept of SMART is applied across various dimensions of RD (Source: Author, based on [ 68 , 69 ]). • Sustainable Environment: Environmental sustainability should be included in RD initiatives because rural communities rely heavily on natural resources for livelihoods and growth, and because of their susceptibility to climate change and risks from energy, water scarcity, and food [ 70 ]. Likewise, increased concern about climate change and growing recognition of the necessity for low-carbon development paths should emphasize boosting access to modern energy services through renewable energy technologies [ 71 ]. • Manageable Economy: Linear economy models result in the loss of natural resources, excessive pollution, and socioeconomic inequalities [ 72 ]. Thus, integrating a circular economy may convey RD, which involves a concept or system that preserves as much of a product’s added value as possible while eliminating waste. Similarly, in many rural economies, low density and declining local markets are critical barriers to

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Faster, Present, Root, Positive, Good]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 13 of 23 long-term stability [ 73 ]. Digitalization, for example, can provide new development prospects and potential for better and more diverse occupations in rural areas [ 74 ]. Studies anticipate that new technologies will enable rural goods and services to reach more distant markets faster and at a lower cost. Likewise, enhancing opportunities at the village level, the role of self-help groups (SHGs), women entrepreneurship that generates services and jobs, and local skill development programmes for youths will enhance the economic rate [ 75 ]. • Adaptive Society: Positive outcomes are encouraged by the ability to adapt to a quickly changing environment [ 76 ]. Globalization and digitalization are forcing society to become more complicated [ 77 ], demanding more novel solutions to problems such as natural catastrophes, communication issues, migration, inequality, and social injustice. Such losses can be avoided by including climate risks and adaption strategies in programme planning, design, and execution to minimize distress. As a result, there is a need to comprehend, address, and adapt to changes affecting people, groups, and societies • Responsible Governance: If implementation capacity is inadequate, a consistent and comprehensive plan will not work [ 78 ]. Building governance capacity and transparency at all levels are thus essential for an effective method. Governments that showcase responsibility and responsiveness to their population, and integrity in their reporting on the use and distribution of public resources and decision-making are identifiable as having good and responsible governance [ 79 ]. A responsible government fosters community involvement in policy and service delivery • Technology and Infrastructure: The infrastructure of the country is its backbone. It contributes significantly to national economic growth [ 80 ] by lowering transaction costs, boosting rural-urban links, and developing capacity, all of which are essential components of any developing nation’s strategy. According to many studies, rural development depends on electricity, irrigation, water, sanitation, and road infrastructure, which may enhance productivity, savings, income, and tourism, resulting in better employment prospects and health conditions for rural people [ 81 ]. Likewise, due to technological advancements, some of the energy sources introduced in rural areas include the development of practical uses of renewable sources such as solar, wind, and waterpower, as well as the introduction of smokeless stoves. Furthermore, the study considers the health sector as one of the areas that have efficiently utilized technology, including providing clean drinking water, improving sanitation and health services, and offering low-cost balanced diets 3.2. Achieving Sustainability through SMART Interventions PTA: Stage 2: Objective Analysis From Stage 1: Problem Analysis, as described in Section 2.5 , the study reframed each identified problem into a desirable positive result. Accordingly, as Figure 4 discusses, an objective tree representing future SMART solutions, referring to Section 3.2 , to the issues These SMART interventions transform root causes and effects into root solutions and identify influencing entry points [ 63 ]. Thus, leveraging SMART interventions can help to address the challenges facing rural communities and promote sustainable development by achieving desired SDGs that can benefit both present and future generations.

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 14 of 23 Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 14 of 24 Figure 4. Stage 2-Objective Analysis (achieving SDGs through SMART interventions). (Source: Author). Figure 4. Stage 2-Objective Analysis (achieving SDGs through SMART interventions). (Source: Author).

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Unique, Land, Six, Early]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 15 of 23 For instance, the environmental dimension identifies unconventional fossil fuel use as the cause in Stage 1, leading to negative impacts such as natural resource depletion and health issues. Replacing this with the SMART intervention in stage 2 using renewable energy sources such as solar or wind can lead to zero carbon emissions, lowering pollution and paving the way towards a healthy environment. This endeavour caters to SDGs 7: Affordable and Clean Energy, 9: Industry Innovation and Infrastructure, 12: Responsive Consumption and Production, 13: Climate Action, and 15: Life on Land. Likewise, as outlined in Stage 1, ineffective connectedness between stakeholders or inadequate participatory governance leads to policy implementation delays or lack of clarity in defining work responsibilities, resulting in insecurity and inequality. In Stage 2, establishing community care units with a committee of people of various ethnicities, religions, and genders will enable the authorities to provide adequate services per local requirements [ 82 ]. 3.3. Proposed SMART-V Framework (SMART-VF) As mentioned in Section 2.2 , there is a need for a synchronized framework to address SRD because rural areas face unique challenges and opportunities that require tailored solutions. Additionally, RD initiatives often involve multiple stakeholders, each with their priorities and goals, resulting in fragmented efforts and a lack of coherence. A synchronized framework can help to align these diverse efforts and ensure a more integrated approach to SRD. It can also help to avoid gaps, identify synergies, and promote a more holistic understanding of sustainability, leading to more effective and impactful outcomes Regarding the notion of SMART-V stated in Section 3.1 , we have formulated the theoretical framework for SMART-V. Considering the sustainable aspects of the economic, environmental, and social dimensions, the proposed framework may build around six key structuring elements: agriculture, governance, village services, resource management, employment, and life quality. As elaborated in Figure 5 , this framework may accelerate the establishment of next-generation SMART-V by focusing on three key pivots: (a) Information and Communication Technology (ICT), (b) Science and Technology (S&T), and (c) Regulations and Management (R&M) 3.3.1. Science and Technology (S&T) The application of S&T in rural areas has the potential to play a significant role in bringing about agricultural productivity and reinforcing resource management [ 83 ], and resolving the conflict between significant food demands and limited farmland [ 84 ]. Meanwhile, agriculture is vulnerable to natural hazards because of several unforeseeable natural calamities. Thus, relying on technology through early warning systems is essential to avoid this risk. Likewise, technological interventions in the agriculture sector, such as farm management software, precision farming, wireless sensors, climate-smart agriculture, resilient crops, and agricultural machinery [ 85 ], contribute to fulfilling the expanding population’s food demand [ 86 ]. Similarly, energy is also required to achieve rural industrialization [ 87 ]. Thus, SMART- V focuses on creating and exploring alternative renewable energy sources, including hydro, solar, and wind, for electricity generation. In addition, water is one of the essential resources for any region’s development. Thus, SMART-V may endeavour to enhance potable water supply in rural areas by developing and implementing S&T methods for water collection, conservation, and recycling [ 20 ]. For instance, under rainwater harvesting, improving surface runoff capacity, land surface catchment methods, borewell groundwater recharge, and percolation tanks can be used [ 88 ]. Likewise, waste management does not execute appropriately and endangers the environment and human health [ 89 ]. People in rural regions usually need more awareness and methods to properly manage solid waste, leading to harmful behaviours such as open burning or rubbish dumping [ 90 ]. Thus, implementing new S&T practices such as biowaste management techniques such as biogas, vermicomposting, anaerobic digestion, composting bins at the household level, and plastic and paper recycling plants at Gram Panchayat levels will make it so local conditions may

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Connect, Ways, Range, Cutting, Raise, Beyond, Mobiles, Era, Edge, Pre]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 16 of 23 improve from social, environmental, and health perspectives. Analogously, these S&T initiatives call for community involvement, transfer of technology knowledge, assessment and review of existing rural systems, the use of solar energy for electrification, and so on. Furthermore, innovative and appropriate construction techniques that use local skills, materials, and resources will all help rural communities. As a result, in the dynamic SMART-VF, the technology pivot was placed as one of the critical ways of facilitating SMART initiatives Sustainability 2023 , 15 , x FOR PEER REVIEW 16 of 24 Figure 5. A theoretical framework for smart village, (Source: Author) 3.3.1. Science and Technology (S&T) The application of S&T in rural areas has the potential to play a significant role in bringing about agricultural productivity and reinforcing resource management [83], and resolving the conflict between significant food demands and limited farmland [84]. Meanwhile, agriculture is vulnerable to natural hazards because of several unforeseeable natural calamities. Thus, relying on technology through early warning systems is essential to avoid this risk. Likewise, technological interventions in the agriculture sector, such as farm management software, precision farming, wireless sensors, climate-smart agriculture, resilient crops, and agricultural machinery [85], contribute to fulfilling the expanding population ’ s food demand [86]. Similarly, energy is also required to achieve rural industrialization [87]. Thus, SMART-V focuses on creating and exploring alternative renewable energy sources, including hydro, solar, and wind, for electricity generation. In addition, water is one of the essential resources for any region ’ s development. Thus, SMART-V may endeavour to enhance potable water supply in rural areas by developing and implementing S&T methods for water collection, conservation, and recycling [20]. For instance, under rainwater harvesting, improving surface runoff capacity, land surface catchment methods, borewell groundwater recharge, and percolation tanks can be used [88]. Likewise, waste management does not execute appropriately and endangers the environment and human health [89]. People in rural regions usually need more awareness and methods to properly manage solid waste, leading to harmful behaviours such as open burning or rubbish dumping [90]. Thus, implementing new S&T practices such as biowaste management techniques such as biogas, vermicomposting, anaerobic digestion, composting bins at the household Figure 5. A theoretical framework for smart village, (Source: Author) 3.3.2. Information and Communication Technology (ICT) Meanwhile, S&T refers to a collection of techniques, skills, or methods in producing services or accomplishing objectives. In contrast, ICT is used as terminology for devices, mobiles, services, networks, and applications that range from pre-existing aids such as landlines, TVs, radios, and satellites to cutting-edge internet-era technology and sensors. ICTs serve as one of the functional pivots for the SMART-VF, accelerating economic and social growth in rural regions. People in rural areas can effectively connect with the local, regional, and national economies by using ICTs. For example, they can use banking services and access many career opportunities that would otherwise be beyond reach. ICTs can raise knowledge among the rural populace about new agricultural technology, allowing them to contribute to the country’s GDP. Additionally, the numerous ICTs can help to expand education among many of the rural population and connect them effectively with their urban centres. It has aided in bridging gaps and giving access to clinical information, specialised

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Gap, Meet, Creation, Makes, Raj, Enough, Time, Hour, Age, Bridge, Job, Ideas, Still, Legal, Short]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 17 of 23 expertise, and health services, saving time, money, and lives [ 91 ]. Thus, narrowing the digital divide not only helps to bridge the infrastructure gap but will also bring the rural people to the mainstream for the nation’s development [ 92 ]. Furthermore, access through internet ICTs can improve rural people’s awareness of livelihood opportunities provided by government services [ 93 ]. As a result, ICT may enhance people’s quality of life by improving their living conditions in remote and rural locations and delivering significant commercial, social, and educational advantages 3.3.3. Regulation and Management (R&M) Furthermore, there is a growing demand for SMART rural development administrators who can think strategically, make decisions based on prior findings, efficiently manage rural areas’ resources, and enhance the possibility for regions’ growth. Rural communities and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) are more courageous and accepting initiatives and attempt to promote social innovations. However, they need help making decisions about the area’s development, failure to implement their ideas, and various risks associated with a short-term investment [ 94 ]. Thus, the third pivot, R&M, by local governance (Panchayat Raj) includes community involvement, transparency, enforced legal standards, majority opinion, concern and stakeholder engagement, equality for all, accountability, effectiveness and efficiency, and strategic vision. Hence, R&M can aid with this by (1) offering awareness, (2) enhancing processing efficiency, and (3) making proceedings easier Similarly, the necessity of the hour is a practical and thorough ICT application in e-governance that gives consolidated solutions for the rural community. SMART organisational and decision-making systems would help governments and their partners to provide better rural services equitably and inclusively, eventually enhancing the quality of life [ 95 ]. Accordingly, the SMART-VF will establish what makes a village SMART: affordable green energy, enough housing, water conservation, safe drinking water, early warning systems for extreme weather, and a probable schedule for public transportation and local physicians 4. Discussion 4.1. Justification for the Need for SMART-V Conventionally, above other sectors, agricultural production and resource allocation have been emphasised as the primary drivers of rural growth. While agriculture is undeniably essential in RD, the growth of non-farm industries and services can retard rural-urban migration, relieving stressors on urban centres and contributing to a more equitable allocation of resources. Thus, regarding Section 2.2 , traditional practices of RD still need to address some of the most critical issues in rural regions. However, SMART-V will design to be sustainable, inclusive, and resilient, focusing on improving the quality of life for rural residents through technology and innovation. There are several fundamental reasons why SMART-V are needed: • Closing the Digital Divide: SMART-V aims to address the digital divide between urban and rural areas by providing access to technology and digital services to rural communities. This access helps to ensure that rural residents are included in the digital age and can participate fully in the digital economy • Promoting Sustainable Development: SMART-V promotes sustainable development by using technology and innovation to address rural communities’ challenges, such as poverty, unemployment, and environmental degradation. This SMART-V initiative helps to ensure that rural areas can meet their community’s needs while preserving their natural resources for future generations • Improving the quality of life: SMART-V aims to improve rural residents’ quality of life by providing access to essential services, such as healthcare, education, and energy and creating opportunities for economic growth and job creation • Enhancing resilience: SMART-V must be resilient, ensuring that rural communities can adapt to changing circumstances and recover quickly from shocks and stressors

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Forest, Europe, Forward, Take, Cope, Small, Ones]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 18 of 23 such as climate change or political instability. The SMART-V resilience helps to ensure that rural residents can better cope with the challenges of a rapidly changing world Moreover, as stated in Section 2.3 , SV activities in developing and underdeveloped countries primarily focus on rejuvenating rural communities through the agriculture sector or addressing inadequate resource management, basic infrastructure, and services (e.g., food, energy, education, water, and employment). In contrast to developed regions such as Europe, these efforts address the need for knowledge innovation, improved productivity, and specialisation in areas with basic infrastructure. Hence, SMART-V is a fluid concept with varying priorities rooted in existing scenarios, and the key aim is to encourage rural regions’ endogenous development potential However, regarding Sections 3.3.1 and 3.3.2 , implementing S&T and ICT would call for innovations in making them affordable and cost-effective for socio-economically weaker rural societies. Innovations in financial mechanisms could also lead to effective implementation of technology and sustainability of framework. For instance, one possible approach is to develop microfinance models tailored to the specific needs of rural communities, such as group-based lending programs that provide small loans to individuals or communities for income-generating activities. Another strategy could be to leverage mobile banking and digital payment systems to improve financial access and inclusion in remote areas where traditional banking services are lacking Regarding sustainable development, policies, and infrastructure investments, including decision-makers, academics, and professionals, are required to provide rural regions with the same attention and opportunity as urban ones. Furthermore, there needs to be more clarity in development initiatives due to inadequate categorization of rural areas Take, for example, the fact that a forest community needs accessibility before it requires food security. As a result, SMART-V development strategies for forest regions will consider different factors than those for other settlements. Thus, the findings suggest that the altered paradigm emphasises the importance of context-specific approaches that maximize synergies between different domains of RD. This approach also empowers communities to take charge of their development and creates a sense of ownership and accountability 4.2. A Way Forward: Identifying Entry Points to Achieve a Sustainable SMART-V By addressing the entry points, it is possible to create a sustainable SV that is inclusive, resilient, and able to promote economic and social development in rural areas, to mention a few: • Access to Technology and Digital Services: Providing access to technology and digital services is a crucial entry point for achieving a sustainable SMART-V. This access includes the installation of infrastructure, such as broadband internet, and the development of digital services and applications that can improve the delivery of essential services, such as healthcare, education, and energy • Skill Development: This includes training programs for rural youths in areas such as digital literacy, entrepreneurship, and innovation, as well as the development of technical skills related to technology and digital services • Entrepreneurship and Innovation: For sustainability, the SMART-V approach supports the development of new businesses and the commercialization of new technologies, and encourages the development of new approaches for addressing the challenges faced by rural communities • Community Engagement: It is another critical entry point which includes the involvement of rural residents in the planning and implementation of SMART-V projects, and ensuring that the benefits of these projects are shared equitably among all community members • Partnership and Collaboration: Partnerships are essential for effectively implementing the framework, including developing partnerships between the government, the private sector, civil society organizations, local NGOs, and collaboration between

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Just, Board, Read, Great, Gone]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 19 of 23 community stakeholders. The Gram Panchayat can play an essential part in fostering these collaborations Moreover, implementation of SMART-VF for localizing SDGs at the Gram Panchayat level will require adopting a holistic approach considering the priorities of local communities, availability of resources and their mobilization, mechanisms for stakeholder engagements, capacity building for local governing units, that is, Gram Panchayat and tool for review and upgradation of various evaluation parameters. Similarly, exploring the avenues and opportunities for stakeholder engagements would assume great significance since it can evolve innovative mechanisms for policy development, implementation, and sustainability of the initiatives, including innovative financing mechanisms through partnerships. The research identifies these essential aspects that could strengthen the framework to transform rural India 5. Conclusions This study has gone some way toward enhancing our understanding of the SV approach. The literature review of this study indicates that over the past decades, RD programmes have seen significant changes in scope and substance, ranging from addressing food security issues to a more integrated approach to RD that includes community empowerment and natural resource preservation and management. Furthermore, this study contributes to existing knowledge of SV by providing the strategies under SMART-VF, which is a multi-dimensional approach and emphasises not just one axis of development but also all the sustainable dimensions of RD, such as environment, social, and economy, in parallel. Moreover, the formation of the SMART-V framework guides the integration of well-established concepts in sustainable development, such as green energy, circular economy, livelihood diversification, and regulating e-governance, among others. However, conventional individual approaches to RD tend to focus on specific aspects of RD, which results in ignoring their inextricable linkages. Furthermore, the research has highlighted the need for many questions of further investigations, such as identifying key entry points for the establishment of SMART-V Regarding Sections 2.2 and 3.1 , considering dynamic circumstances such as changing rural landscape, technological advancement, climate change and environmental concerns, and demographic shifts, a reframing of the SV concept is necessary to ensure that it remains relevant and effective in addressing the challenges of RD in the 21 st century. Similarly, concerning Section 3.2 , SMART interventions can play a crucial role in achieving sustainability for RD by addressing challenges and promoting innovative solutions that can lead to long-term, sustainable outcomes. The SMART-V includes improving resource efficiency, promoting renewable energy, strengthening disaster resilience, enhancing access to information and services, and enhancing agricultural practices The research framework proposed in this paper offers the foundation for examining different research domains’ knowledge bases. However, the study would like to highlight certain limitations. For instance, one such limitation is the potential challenge of implementing the framework in rural communities with limited resources and technological expertise. Future studies should use different analysis techniques to broaden this investigation and validate the results. Thus, this study will become an essential reference, allowing academicians and practitioners to comprehensively understand the concept of SV Author Contributions: All authors contributed to the conceptualization, visualization, investigation, methodology, and writing process, as well as to the review and editing of the manuscript. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript Funding: This research received no external funding Institutional Review Board Statement: Not applicable Informed Consent Statement: Not applicable Data Availability Statement: Not applicable.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: De Vries, De Wit, Zhang, Cornell, Richardson, Singapore, Press, Bennett, Portal, Mcphillips, June, Saka, Kos, Mihai, Kong, North, Byers, Emerald, Delhi, Sweden, Greve, Int, Adv, Sci, Burek, Panel, Gov, Zaro, Inf, Carpenter, Havlik, October, December, Leclere, Londhe, Niti, China, Gleeson, Rez, Grimm, Cham, Kashmir, Stanny, Chan, Mord, Rosi, Nic, Cross, Jammu, Komorowski, Steffen, Lett, Kim, Johnston, Lentini, Vries, Biggs, Evolution, Dev, Ebi, Hong, Chester, Chang, Geneva, Macmillan, Carolina, Friedman, Chapel, Negi, Serv, Mishra, Bowen, Bank, Washington, Wit, Hill, Egger, Mora, Springer, Futur]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 20 of 23 Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest References 1 Bowen, W.M.; Gleeson, R.E The Evolution of Human Settlements ; Palgrave Macmillan: Cham, Switzerland, 2019. [ CrossRef ] 2 Steffen, W.; Richardson, K.; Rockström, J.; Cornell, S.E.; Fetzer, I.; Bennett, E.M.; Biggs, R.; Carpenter, S.R.; De Vries, W.; De Wit, C.A.; et al. Planetary boundaries: Guiding human development on a changing planet Science 2015 , 347 , 1259855 [ CrossRef ] [ PubMed ] 3 Byers, E.; Gidden, M.; Leclere, D.; Balkovic, J.; Burek, P.; Ebi, K.; Greve, P.; Grey, D.; Havlik, P.; Hillers, A.; et al. Global exposure and vulnerability to multi-sector development and climate change hotspots Environ. Res. Lett 2018 , 13 , 055012. [ CrossRef ] 4 DISD. Understanding Rural Vulnerability to Natural Hazards: Mitigation Plans, Planning Process and Outcomes—University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. 2013. Available online: https://portal.nifa.usda.gov/web/crisprojectpages/0222809- understanding-rural-vulnerability-to-natural-hazards-mitigation-plans-planning-process-and-outcomes.html (accessed on 28 June 2022) 5 Johnston, R.B. Arsenic and the 2030 Agenda for sustainable development. In Arsenic Research and Global Sustainability-Proceedings of the 6 th International Congress on Arsenic in the Environment, AS 2016, Stockholm, Sweden, 19–23 June 2016 ; CRC Press/Balkema: Leiden, The Netherlands; pp. 12–14 6 Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Summary for Policymakers. In Climate Change 2021: The Physical Science Basis Contribution of Working Group I to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ; Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change: Geneva, Switzerland, 2021; ISBN 9789291691586 7 UNDRR Disaster Risk Reduction in India: Status Report 2020. United Nations Off. Disaster Risk Reduct. 2020. Available online: https://www.undrr.org/publication/disaster-risk-reduction-india-status-report-2020 (accessed on 20 March 2022) 8 McPhillips, L.E.; Chang, H.; Chester, M.V.; Depietri, Y.; Friedman, E.; Grimm, N.B.; Kominoski, J.S.; McPhearson, T.; M é ndez- L á zaro, P.; Rosi, E.J.; et al. Defining Extreme Events: A Cross-Disciplinary Review Earth’s Future 2018 , 6 , 441–455. [ CrossRef ] 9 Government of India Rural Area Development Plan Formulation and Implementation (RADPFI) Guidelines. 2016; pp. 1–192 Available online: https://panchayat.gov.in/documents/20126/0/RADPFI+Guidelines.pdf/4 cc 61805-4 e 48-d 15 f-26 f 6-98128 d 1 716 d 9?t=1610617777201 (accessed on 3 May 2022) 10 World Bank Ending Poverty, Investing in Opportunity ; World Bank: Washington, DC, USA, 2018 11 Kim, K.; Panchanatham, N Reform and Privatization of State-Owned Enterprises in India ; Springer: Singapore, 2021; pp. 157–168 [ CrossRef ] 12 NITI Aayog Strategy for New India @ 75 ; NITI Aayog: New Delhi, India, 2018 13 MoRD, G. Schemes/Programmes|Ministry of Rural Development|Government of India. 2021. Available online: https://rural. nic.in/en/scheme-websites (accessed on 28 June 2022) 14 Ranade, P.; Londhe, S.; Mishra, A. Smart Villages through Information Technology—Need of Emerging India Int. J. Inf. Technol 2015 , 3 , 1–6 15 Kulashri, S.; Negi, S.K. Rural India and National Rurban Mission J. Environ. Nanotechnol 2017 , 6 , 55–58. [ CrossRef ] 16 Jayasena, N.S.; Chan, D.W.M.; Kumaraswamy, M.M.; Saka, A.B. Applicability of public-private partnerships in smart infrastructure development: The case of Hong Kong Int. J. Constr. Manag 2022 , 1–13. [ CrossRef ] 17 Zhang, X.; Zhang, Z. How do smart villages become a way to achieve sustainable development in rural areas? Smart village planning and practices in China Sustainability 2020 , 12 , 10510. [ CrossRef ] 18 Komorowski, Ł.; Stanny, M. Smart villages: Where can they happen? Land 2020 , 9 , 151. [ CrossRef ] 19 Stojanova, S.; Lentini, G.; Niederer, P.; Egger, T.; Cvar, N.; Kos, A.; Duh, E.S. Smart villages policies: Past, present and future Sustainability 2021 , 13 , 1663. [ CrossRef ] 20 Mihai, F.-C.; Iatu, C. Sustainable Rural Development under Agenda 2030. In Sustainability Assessment at the 21 st Century ; InTechOpen: Rijeka, Croatia, 2020. [ CrossRef ] 21 P é rez-delHoyo, R.; Mora, H. Toward a New Sustainable Development Model for Smart Villages. In Smart Villages in EU and Beyond ; Emerald Publishing Limited: Bingley, UK, 2019; pp. 49–62. [ CrossRef ] 22 Deshkar, S.; Hayashia, Y.; Mori, Y. An alternative approach for planning the resilient cities in developing countries Int. J. Urban Sci 2011 , 15 , 1–14. [ CrossRef ] 23 Afradi, K.; Nourian, F Understanding ICT’s Impacts on Urban Spaces: A Qualitative Content Analysis of Literature ; Springer: Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 2022; Volume 87, pp. 701–731 24 Road, M.A.; Jammu, S.; Kashmir, I. Bridging digital divide in India: Way forward & challenges Int. J. Adv. Res. Dev 2017 , 2 , 129–136 25 Awumbila, M Linkages between Urbanization, Rural-Urban Migration and Poverty Outcomes in Africa ; International Organization for Migration: Geneva, Switzerland, 2015; pp. 3–24 26 World Economic Forum. Migration and Its Impact on Cities Futur. Urban Dev. Serv. Initiat 2017 , 7 , 172. Available online: http://www 3.weforum.org/docs/Migration_Impact_Cities_report_2017_low.pdf (accessed on 25 October 2022) 27 Five Year Plans. Available online: https://www.niti.gov.in/planningcommission.gov.in/docs/plans/planrel/fiveyr/default.html (accessed on 2 December 2021).

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Hoffmann, Man, Cambridge, January, Singh, Bossuyt, Europa, Dst, Selamat, Holmes, Soc, Day, Mackenzie, Adarsh, Nilsson, Sachdeva, Moe, Wide, Idea, Kuca, Bureau, Akl, Lid, Shamseer, September, Phil, Tetzlaff, Westlund, Brennan, Gandhi, Varghese, July, Nath, Ambrosio, France, Fadeyi, Naldi, Centre, Mag, Rao, Maresova, Tab, Hogan, Lang, General, Boutron, Mckenzie, Goi]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 21 of 23 28 Page, M.J.; McKenzie, J.E.; Bossuyt, P.M.; Boutron, I.; Hoffmann, T.C.; Mulrow, C.D.; Shamseer, L.; Tetzlaff, J.M.; Akl, E.A.; Brennan, S.E.; et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: An updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews BMJ 2021 , 372 , n 71 [ CrossRef ] [ PubMed ] 29 Mishbah, M.; Purwandari, B.; Sensuse, D.I. Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Proposed Smart Village Conceptual Model: Objectives, Strategies, Dimensions, and Foundations. In Proceedings of the 2018 International Conference on Information Technology Systems and Innovation (ICITSI), Bandung, Indonesia, 22–26 October 2018; pp. 127–133. [ CrossRef ] 30 Naldi, L.; Nilsson, P.; Westlund, H.; Wixe, S. What is smart rural development? J. Rural Stud 2015 , 40 , 90–101. [ CrossRef ] 31 Planning Commission. 2017. Available online: https://pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=170000 (accessed on 24 September 2022) 32 Solagberu, R. Rural Development in the Twenty-First Century as a Global Necessity. In Rural Development-Contemporary Issues and Practices ; IntechOpen: Rijeka, Croatia, 2012. [ CrossRef ] 33 Czapiewski, K.; Stawicka, E. New paradigm of rural development—New challenges for extension services Rural. Areas Dev 2009 , 6 , 275–284 34 Idea, T Adarsh Gram (Model Village): A Concept Note ; No. Census 2011; Swaniti: New Delhi, India, 2012; pp. 1–6. Available online: http://unnat.iitd.ac.in/pdf/model_village.pdf (accessed on 11 June 2022) 35 NRHM. National Rural Health Mission. Available online: https://nhm.gov.in/index 1.php?lang=1&level=1&sublinkid=969&lid= 49 (accessed on 25 September 2022) 36 Elementary Education|Government of India, Ministry of Education. Available online: https://www.education.gov.in/en/ssa (accessed on 25 September 2022) 37 MGNREGA. Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Gurantee Act. Available online: https://nregarep 1.nic.in/Netnrega/ home.aspx (accessed on 25 September 2022) 38 DAY NRLM—MoRD, GoI. Available online: https://www.nrlm.gov.in/outerReportAction.do?methodName=showIndex#gsc. tab=0 (accessed on 25 September 2022) 39 Comparative Perspective. Designing Policy Framework for Smart Entrepreneurship and Self-reliant Smart Village Economy: An Entrepreneurial Funnel Framework-Tribhuvan Nath J. SSRN Electron. J 2021 . [ CrossRef ] 40 Ambrosio-Albal á , M.; Bastiaensen, J. The New Territorial Paradigm of Rural Development: Theoretical Foundations from Systems and Institutional Theories. 2010; p. 68 41 Office of the Registrar General & Census Commissioner. Primary Census Abstract. In Census of India 2011 ; Office of the Registrar General & Census Commissioner: New Delhi, India, 2013; pp. 1–40 42 CBHI; MHFW, G.; Gururaj, G.; Varghese, M.; Benegal, V.; Rao, G.N.; Pathak, K.; Singh, L.K.E. National Health Profile (NHP) of India-2019. 2016. Available online: http://cbhidghs.nic.in/showfile.php?lid=1147 (accessed on 25 March 2022) 43 Planning Commission of India Press Note on Poverty Estimates, 2011–2012 Government of India Planning Commission July 2013 ; Press Information Bureau: New Delhi, India, 2013; pp. 1–10 44 OECD A New Rural Development Paradigm for the 21 st Century: A Toolkit for Developing Countries, Development Centre Studies ; OECD Publishing: Paris, France, 2016; ISBN 978-92-64-25227-1. [ CrossRef ] 45 Zavratnik, V.; Kos, A.; Duh, E.S. Smart Villages: Comprehensive Review of Initiatives and Practices Sustainability 2018 , 10 , 2559 [ CrossRef ] 46 Heeks, R. Information systems and developing countries: Failure, success, and local improvisations Inf. Soc 2002 , 18 , 101–112 [ CrossRef ] 47 Mackenzie, D. IEEE Smart Village: Sustainable Development Is a Global Mission IEEE Syst. Man Cybern. Mag 2019 , 5 , 39–41 [ CrossRef ] 48 Holmes, J The Smart Villages Initiative: Findings 2014–2017 ; Smart Villages New Thinking Off-Grid Communities Worldwile; The Smart Villages Initiative: Cambridge, UK, 2017; pp. 23–25. Available online: https://e 4 sv.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/ The-Smart-Villages-Initiative-Findings-2014-2017_web.pdf (accessed on 18 March 2022) 49 IEEE Smart Village: Empowering Off-Grid Communities. 2016. Available online: https://technical-community-spotlight.ieee. org/smart-village-fueling-sustainability/ (accessed on 20 May 2022) 50 Agriculture, C.S. Climate-Smart Villages. 2015. Available online: https://www.cgiar.org/innovations/climate-smart-villagesand-valleys/ (accessed on 13 June 2022) 51 Adesipo, A.; Fadeyi, O.; Kuca, K.; Krejcar, O.; Maresova, P.; Selamat, A.; Adenola, M. Smart and climate-smart agricultural trends as core aspects of smart village functions Sensors 2020 , 20 , 5977. [ CrossRef ] [ PubMed ] 52 Phil Hogan, V.B.; Cret , u, C. EU Action for Smart Villages. EU Institutions. 2017, pp. 2–4. Available online: https://ec.europa.eu/ enrd/policy-in-action_en.html (accessed on 3 January 2023) 53 RUMRA & Smart Villages. Available online: https://www.smart-rural-intergroup.eu/inaugural-meeting-of-the-new-intergroupsmart-villages-for-rural-communities/ (accessed on 27 April 2022) 54 Sachdeva, K. Digital India: Opportunities and Challenges Int. J. Sci. Technol. Manag 2017 , 5 , 1–6 55 MoE&IT. Di-Initiatives|Digital India Programme|Ministry of Electronics & Information Technology(MeitY) Government of India. Available online: https://digitalindia.gov.in/di-initiatives (accessed on 12 May 2022) 56 Department of Science & Technology. Available online: https://dst.gov.in/movement-inspire-rural-entrepreneurship-spreadsfar-wide-dst-support (accessed on 1 December 2021).

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Van Der Steen, Eng, Aqua, Ghana, Twist, Real, Constantin, Ingle, Jia, Vignesh, Haddad, Roland, Gupta, Sahu, Pal, Hunger, Thomas, Datta, Aff, Net, Tps, York, Worlds, Gabel, Ghasemi, Mankar, Jamaluddin, Devi, Florin, Zain, Rani, Tools, Front, Bus, Tule, August, London, Dearden, Hazarika, Desa, Meyer, Damgaard, Sasikumar, Salvia, Akbari, Zarei, Jamba, Quaranta, Place, Ghosh, November, Zhou, Orru, Hansson, Jones, Kowalski, Assam, Afrah, Lowe, Steen, Gautam, Lin, Hir, Hum]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 22 of 23 57 Rural Development: A Strategy for Poverty Alleviation in India. Available online: https://www.nistads.res.in/all-html/ RuralDevelopment_AstrategyforpovertyalleviationinIndia.html (accessed on 21 September 2021) 58 Vignesh, A.; Sasikumar, M.; Devi, S. The Role of ICT in Rural Development Int. J. Sci. Res. Comput. Sci. Appl. Manag. Stud IJSRCSAMS 2018 , 7 , 5–8. Available online: www.ijsrcsams.com (accessed on 11 January 2023) 59 Sahu, P.P.; Ghosh, A. Mainstreaming Smart Village in Rural Development: A Framework for Analysis and Policy. 2018, pp. 1–48 Available online: http://nirdpr.org.in/nird_docs/tps/DG_Smart-Village-9-2-18.pdf (accessed on 18 January 2023) 60 Salvia, R.; Quaranta, G. Place-based rural development and resilience: A lesson from a small community Sustainability 2017 , 9 , 889. [ CrossRef ] 61 Pal, S. 15 Inspiring Indian Villages That Are Showing the Way Forward. 2017. Available online: https://www.thebetterindia. com/85354/inspiring-indian-villages-sustainable-development/ (accessed on 17 August 2021) 62 Orru, K.; Hansson, S.; Gabel, F.; Tammpuu, P.; Krüger, M.; Savadori, L.; Meyer, S.F.; Torpan, S.; Jukarainen, P.; Schieffelers, A.; et al. Approaches to ‘vulnerability’ in eight European disaster management systems Disasters 2022 , 46 , 742–767. [ CrossRef ] 63 Dearden, P.; Kowalski, B.; Lowe, J.; Roland, R.; Surridge, M.; Thomas, S.; Jones, S Tools for Development ; Department for International Development (DFID): London, UK, 2003; Volume 66. Available online: http://www.protectedareas.info/upload/ document/toolsfordevelopment-dfid.pdf (accessed on 12 November 2022) 64 Ghambarali, R.; Alibaygi, A.; Rasekhi, B.; Pezeshki, V.; Ghasemi, S.; Akbari, Z. Challenges of Sustainable Rural Development from Perspective of Villagers Int. Res. J. Appl. Basic Sci 2013 , 7 , 253–258. Available online: www.irjabs.com (accessed on 10 November 2022) 65 Zarei, S.; Bozorg-Haddad, O.; Kheirinejad, S.; Lo á iciga, H.A. Environmental sustainability: A review of the water-energy-food nexus Aqua Water Infrastruct. Ecosyst. Soc 2021 , 70 , 138–154. [ CrossRef ] 66 Florin-Constantin Mihai One Global Map but Different Worlds: Worldwide Survey of Human Access to Basic Utilities Hum. Ecol 2017 , 45 , 425–429. [ CrossRef ] 67 Afrah, N. Lack of Infrastructure: The Impact on Economic Development as a case of Lack of Infrastructure: The Impact on Economic Development as a case of Benadir region and Hir-shabelle, Somalia Dev. Ctry. Stud 2019 , 7 , 49–55 68 Rani, B.J.S. Smart Village-The Real Future of India Int. J. Innov. Res. Inf. Secur 2016 , 3 , 2015–2017 69 Somwanshi, R.; Shindepatil, U.; Tule, D.; Mankar, A.; Ingle, N. Study and Development of Tillor Buzurg Village as a Smart Village Int. J. Sci. Eng. Res 2016 , 7 , 395–408. Available online: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Megharima-Datta/publication/34 0315742_STUDY_AND_DEVELOPMENT_OF_TILLOR_BUZURG_VILLAGE_AS_A_SMART_VILLAGE/links/5 e 83 b 7749285 1 c 2 f 5270 d 8 b 0/STUDY-AND-DEVELOPMENT-OF-TILLOR-BUZURG-VILLAGE-AS-A-SMART-VILLAGE.pdf (accessed on 25 December 2022) 70 Nyahunda, L.; Tirivangasi, H.M. Challenges faced by rural people in mitigating the effects of climate change in the Mazungunye communal lands, Zimbabwe Jamba J. Disaster Risk Stud 2019 , 11 , 1–9. [ CrossRef ] [ PubMed ] 71 UNCTAD. Renewable Energy Technologies for Rural Development. In UNCTAD Current Studies on Science, Technology and Innovation ; United Nations: New York, NY, USA, 2010; p. 42 72 Sariatli, F. Linear Economy Versus Circular Economy: A Comparative and Analyzer Study for Optimization of Economy for Sustainability Visegr. J. Bioecon. Sustain. Dev 2017 , 6 , 31–34. [ CrossRef ] 73 Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development Rural Well-Being ; OECD: Paris, France, 2020. [ CrossRef ] 74 Bukht, R.; Heeks, R. Defining, Conceptualising and Measuring the Digital Economy SSRN Electron. J 2017 . [ CrossRef ] 75 Hazarika, S. Skill Development for Rural Entrepreneurship: A study on State Institute of Rural Development (SIRD), Assam Int J. Res. Anal 2016 , 3 , 61–66. Available online: http://ijrar.com/upload_issue/ijrar_issue_316.pdf (accessed on 19 September 2022) 76 Zhou, M.; Lin, W. Adaptability and life satisfaction: The moderating role of social support Front. Psychol 2016 , 7 , 1134. [ CrossRef ] 77 Elkjaer, T.; Damgaard, J. How Digitalization and Globalization have Remapped the Global FDI Network. In Proceedings of the 16 th Conference of IAOS OECD Headquarters, Paris, France, 19–21 September 2018; pp. 1–13 78 Van der Steen, M.; van Twist, M. Strategies for robustness: Five perspectives on how policy design is done Policy Soc 2018 , 37 , 491–513. [ CrossRef ] 79 Gupta, A.; Gautam, S. ICT for Rural Development: Opportunities and Challenges Int. J. Inf. Comput. Technol 2017 , 7 , 13–23 Available online: https://www.ripublication.com/irph/ijict 17/ijictv 7 n 1_02.pdf (accessed on 20 May 2022) 80 Manggat, I.; Zain, R.; Jamaluddin, Z. The Impact of Infrastructure Development on Rural Communities: A Literature Review Int. J. Acad. Res. Bus. Soc. Sci 2018 , 8 , 637–648. [ CrossRef ] 81 Ghosh, M. Infrastructure and Development in Rural India Margin 2017 , 11 , 256–289. [ CrossRef ] 82 DESA. Creating an Inclusive Society: Practical Strategies to Promote Social Integration. Division for Social Policy and Development United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs Aff. 2009, pp. 1–73. Available online: https://www.un.org/esa/ socdev/egms/docs/2009/Ghana/inclusive-society.pdf (accessed on 20 November 2022) 83 UNCTD The Role of Science, Technology and Innovation in Ensuring Food Security by 2030 ; United Nations Conference on Trade and Development: Geneva, Switzerland, 2017; pp. 9–25 84 Jia, H. Agriculture: Science and technology safeguard sustainability Natl. Sci. Rev 2019 , 6 , 595–600. [ CrossRef ] [ PubMed ] 85 Batchu, R.; Pindoriya, N.M Wireless and Satellite Systems ; Springer: Cham, Switzerland, 2015; Volume 154 86 Agriculture, Hunger and Food Security. Available online: https://agris.fao.org/agris-search/search.do?recordID=GB 2013202132 (accessed on 19 May 2022).

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Senthil Kumar, Lee, Files, Bauza, Royal, Math, Str, Kumar, Edu, Niger, February, Tudor, Clasen, Jung, Vinti, Senthil, Velis, Safer, Boateng, Vaccari, End, Property, Sridevi]

Sustainability 2023 , 15 , 7536 23 of 23 87 Un, D.; Stepi, P.; Stepi, H.P.; Kim, Y.; Seoin, S.; Stepi, B.; Lee, D.; Yongsuk, S.; Stepi, J.; Jung, T.; et al. The Role of Science, Technology and Innovation Policies in the Industrialization of Developing Countries. 2021. Available online: https://www. unido.org/sites/default/files/files/2022-03/STI_Policies.pdf (accessed on 15 June 2022) 88 Vinti, G.; Vaccari, M. Solid waste management in rural communities of developing countries: An overview of challenges and opportunities Clean Technol 2022 , 4 , 1138–1151. [ CrossRef ] 89 Vinti, G.; Bauza, V.; Clasen, T.; Medlicott, K.; Tudor, T.; Zurbrügg, C.; Vaccari, M. Municipal solid waste management and adverse health outcomes: A systematic review Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2021 , 18 , 4331. [ CrossRef ] [ PubMed ] 90 Cook, E.; Velis, C Global Review on Safer End of Engineered Life ; Report; Royal Academy of Engineering: London, UK, 2020; pp. 34–45. [ CrossRef ] 91 Dafauti, B. ICT Impact in Health Delivery in Rural India 2018 . Volume 7. Issue 6. Available online: https://www.researchgate. net/publication/358424098_ICT_Impact_in_Health_Delivery_in_Rural_India (accessed on 3 November 2022) 92 Boateng, M.S. The role of information and communication technologies in Ghana’s rural development Libr. Philos. Pract 2012 , 1–22. Available online: http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/libphilprac/871 (accessed on 1 February 2023) 93 Sridevi, J.; Senthil Kumar, K. E-Governance in India: Opportunities and Challenges Int. J. Pure Appl. Math 2019 , 4 , 675–680 94 Atkoˇci ¯unien ˙e, V.; Vaznonien ˙e, G.; Aleksandraviˇcius, A. The Role of Rural Development Administrators in Rural Institutions Manag. Theory Stud. Rural Bus. Infrastruct. Dev 2018 , 40 , 143–154. [ CrossRef ] 95 International Telecommunication Union (ITU). Building Smart Villages: A Blueprint as Piloted in Niger. 2020. Available online: https://www.itu.int/dms_pub/itu-d/opb/str/D-STR-SMART_VILLAGE.NIGER-2020-PDF-E.pdf (accessed on 8 December 2022) Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.

Other Environmental Sciences Concepts:

[back to top]

Discover the significance of concepts within the article: ‘Transitions towards Sustainable and Resilient Rural Areas in Revitalising India’. Further sources in the context of Environmental Sciences might help you critically compare this page with similair documents:

New Delhi, Water purification, Economic development, Transparency, Resource management, Potable water, Poverty alleviation, Clean drinking water, Holistic development, Science and technology, Interconnectedness, Elementary education, Information technology, Government of India, Health care, Globalization, Economic growth, Natural catastrophe, Community involvement, Climate change, Potable water supply, Fundamental concept, Solid waste, Financial concerns, Local governance, Rural India, Five Year Plan, Public resources, Private sector, Social integration, Agricultural machinery, Government service, Infrastructure development, Rural development, Environmental degradation, Sustainable development, Global south, New paradigm, Developing countries, Environmental harm, Agricultural productivity, Stakeholder engagement, New technologies, Water Conservation, Information and communication technologies, Rural area, Solid Waste Management, Food Security, Social Support, Public Private Partnership, Community Engagement, Systematic Review, Integrated approach, Career opportunities, National Rural Health Mission, Clinical information, Health service, Capacity building, Information and communication technology, Digital divide, Waste management, Digitalization, Circular economy, Environmental sustainability, Rural people, National economic growth, Natural resource, Waste Water, Environmental Monitoring, Safe drinking water, Local market, Clean energy, Soil conservation, Energy Efficiency, Local communities, Rural Communities, Sustainability, Geographic location, Renewable energy, Anaerobic digestion, Quality of water, Agriculture sector, Digital India, Rainwater harvesting, Sustainable environment, Precision farming, Multi-dimensional approach, Health sector, Skill development, Socioeconomic inequalities, Sustainable development goal, Mobile health, Resilience, ICT infrastructure, Agricultural practice, Social infrastructure, Agricultural technology, Waste material, Adaptive learning, Comprehensive development, Emission reduction, Local context, Digital literacy, ICT, Remote patient monitoring, Early warning system, Responsible, Efficient use, Measurable, Civil society organization, Economic reform, Global mission, Rural-urban migration, Self-help group, Key challenge, Adaptable, Non-governmental organisation, Multiple stakeholders, Development domains, Waste production, Renewable source, Rural economies, Government initiative, Local NGO, Local assets, Rural institution, Government programme, Context-specific approaches, Rural region, Community care unit, Urban space, Low-carbon development, Social innovation, Sustainable rural development, Water resource, Social marginalization, Water collection, Sustainable, Water recycling, Resource efficiency, Smart technology, Tailored solutions, Innovation Centre, Digital service, Resilient cities, Climate-Smart Agriculture, Livelihood diversification, Infrastructure investment, Green Energy, Renewable Energy Source, Mobile banking, Renewable energy technologies, Knowledge Innovation, Sustainable energy, Soil and water conservation, Climate risk, ICT solutions, Disaster resilience, Natural Hazard, Smart health, Farming practice, Smart education, Food security issue, Weather condition, E-Governance, New businesses, Digital initiatives, Financial mechanism, Basic utilities, Wireless sensor, Construction Technique, Health diagnostic, Coordinated manner, Implementation capacity.