Editorial: Rethinking Catholicism in Early Modern Italy

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Saint, Every, Alfonso, Modern, New, Less, Church, Doi, Class, Basel, Local, Catholic, North, Naples, Life, Day, Cart, British, Urban, Enough, Lap, Pirillo, Crime, Long, Traveler, John, Show, Corner, Rel, Grand, Power, Main, Benjamin, Edu, Six, Live, Ability, Priest, Blessing, Data, Under, Heart, Century, Born, Foreign, Folk, Architecture, Milton, State, Open, Faithful, English, Last, Capri, Sinner, Fall, Berkeley, Mall, Sign, Burke, Role, Walter, April, Edwin, Author, Self, Rich, Strong, Rome, Liguori, March, Ago, Diego, Canada, Early, Asja, Match, Short, Cis, Common]

Citation: Christopoulos, John, and Diego Pirillo. 2023. Editorial: Rethinking Catholicism in Early Modern Italy Religions 14: 622 https://doi.org/10.3390/ rel 14050622 Received: 16 March 2023 Accepted: 11 April 2023 Published: 6 May 2023 Copyright: © 2023 by the authors Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommonsorg/licenses/by/ 4.0/) religions Editorial Editorial: Rethinking Catholicism in Early Modern Italy John Christopoulos 1, * and Diego Pirillo 2, * 1 Department of History, University of British Columbia, Ponderosa Annex G 21, 2044 Main Mall, Vancouver, BC V 6 T 1 Z 2, Canada 2 Department of Italian Studies, UC Berkeley, Berkeley, CA 94720-2620, USA * Correspondence: johnchristopoulos@ubc.ca (J.C.); dpirillo@berkeley.edu (DP.) In 1925, having spent six months on the island of Capri, Walter Benjamin and Asja L ã cis published a short essay on the city of Naples in the Frankfurter Zeitung . Echoing a long tradition of travel writers and Grand Tourists, who had been both fascinated and repulsed by Italian urban life, Benjamin and L ã cis noted the city’s confusing topography and extravagant architecture, its endemic poverty, and the ubiquity of organized crime, all features that made Naples so different from the “capitals” of European modernity. They also commented on the role that Catholicism played on local customs, especially those of the “popular” classes. In particular, they seemed troubled by the effortless blending of the sacred and the profane and the power of Catholicism and its institutions to structure everyday life: “Some years ago a priest was drawn on a cart through the streets of Naples for indecent offenses. He was followed by a crowd hurling maledictions. At a corner a wedding procession appeared. The priest stands up and makes the sign of a blessing, and the cart’s pursuers fall on their knees. So absolutely, in this city, does Catholicism strive to reassert itself in every situation. Should it disappear from the face of the earth, its last foothold would perhaps be not Rome, but Naples. Nowhere can this people live out its rich barbarism, which has its source in the heart of the city itself, more securely than in the lap of the Church. It needs Catholicism, for even its excesses are then legalized by a legend, the feast day of a martyr. Here Alfonso de Liguori was born, the saint who made the practice of the Catholic Church supple enough to accommodate the trade of the swindler and the whore, in order to control it with more or less rigorous penances in the confessional, for which he wrote a three-volume compendium. Confession alone, not the police, is a match for the self-administration of the criminal world, the camorra.”. ( Benjamin 1986 , p. 163) Despite being a sinner, the priest remains in control of the sacred. The crowd chastises him for his sexual indecency but also reveres his power, finding it deeply meaningful and submitting to his authority. Catholicism both allows illicit practices and disciplines them through the sacrament of confession. The apparent inconsistencies in Italian life that Benjamin and L â cis observed were hardly new in the early 20 th century. The unapologetic blending of the sacred and profane and the power the Church (often portrayed as corrupt and immoral) wielded over the common folk were favored tropes of foreign visitors to Italy since at least the sixteenth century ( Burke 1987 ; Calaresu 2007 ). From Montaigne to Milton and Goethe, observers from north of the Alps had long pondered over Italian Catholicism and commented on its ability to shape institutions and discipline people’s minds and behaviors. Many of them—such as the English Protestant traveler Edwin Sandys, author of the Relation of the State of Religion (1605)—criticized what they considered Catholic superstitions and lamented that Latin liturgy prevented the faithful from understanding rituals, but also acknowledged that powerfully delivered sermons and beautiful and ornate Italian churches nourished authentic “reverence and devotion” ( Sandys 1605 ). Religions 2023 , 14 , 622. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel 14050622 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/religions

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Story, Art, America, Change, Prosperi, Aim, Own, Work, Mayer, Ask, Reader, Key, Israel, Lucette, Heinz, Europe, Paolo, Fields, Goes, Johann, Bonora, Present, Schilling, Topic, Felici, Firpo, Trent, Wolfgang, Answer, Beyond, Luther, Stephan, Beller, Aaron, Roman, Age, Rise, Hsia, Point, Reinhard, Back, Hubert, Faith, Fore, Reinhardt, Tell, Chia, Tedeschi, Holy, Carlo, Ginzburg, Label, Case, Knowledge, Rather, Still, Past, Study, Goal, Malley, Black, Sides, German, Look]

Religions 2023 , 14 , 622 2 of 4 It was in the early modern period, while confronting Luther and the Protestant Reformations, that the Catholic Church renovated itself and developed new mechanisms and institutions to shape Italian society. This Special Issue goes back to this epoch, commonly known as the “Counter Reformation”, and brings together an interdisciplinary group of scholars from Europe, Israel, and North America to discuss new approaches and methodologies for the study of Catholicism in sixteenthand seventeenth-century Italy. In doing so, the volume also considers a methodological problem which Carlo Ginzburg and Lucette Valensi have recently re-examined, namely the relationship between the observer’s and the actor’s categories (a tension between current scholarly interests), inevitably born out of present-day concerns, and the answers historians look for in sources from a different period ( Ginzburg 2013 ; Valensi 2012 ). The reader will not find a conclusive answer to this epistemological problem but rather a series of specific case studies that aim to verify what contemporary methodologies can reveal about early modern Italy. Indeed, although the past does not change, knowledge of the past is constantly evolving as we ask new questions of the sources that we study As is well known, the history of the transformations to Italian religious life has been a battleground for centuries, starting with Paolo Sarpi’s famous definition of Trent as the “Iliad of our age” ( Ditchfield 2008 ; Sarpi 2011 ). Confessional, political, and ideological commitments have infused and shaped representations both within academia and in the broader public sphere. Historians have argued vehemently about and vacillated between competing and overlapping paradigms, often signaled by the use of specific terms to describe the period. From its coining in 1776 by the German jurist Johann Stephan Pütter, the “Counter Reformation” asserted the reactionary and forced re-Catholicization of Protestant lands and the often draconian suppression of heterodoxy in Catholic lands. Key to and perhaps most emblematic of this approach has been the role of the Roman Inquisition. In contrast, the “Catholic Reformation” first outlined by the German historian Hubert Jedin emphasized the Church’s own internal efforts to reform its institutions, theology, and the morality of the faithful ( Jedin 1946 ; Jedin 1949–1975 ). In the recent decades of the 20 th century, moving beyond the debate over the spiritual drivers of reform, historians such as Wolfgang Reinhardt, Heinz Schilling, and Paolo Prodi turned to the paradigm of “confessionalization”, linking religion and secular politics and asserting convergences between Catholicism, Protestantism, and the rise of the modern state ( Reinhard 1977 ; Schilling 1981 ; Prodi 1982 ). Returning anew to the “Counter Reformation”, others have warned against ignoring or de-emphasizing the repressive apparatus of the Catholic Church’s institutions and have illuminated the various mechanisms of “social discipline” that sought to condition the behaviors and mentalities of the laity ( Bonora 2001 ; Bonora 2016 ; Felici 2009 ; Fragnito 2011 ; Firpo 2014 ; Firpo 2016 ). The opening of the Archive for the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith, the former Holy Office of the Inquisition, in 1998 marked a turning point in historiography, enabling scholars to recover the workings of the Roman Inquisition and its wide-reaching impact on Italian spiritual, intellectual, and social life ( Tedeschi 1991 ; Prosperi 1996 ; Fragnito 2001 ; Prosperi 2003 ; Black 2009 ; Mayer 2013 ; Mayer 2014 ; Firpo 2014 ; Aaron-Beller and Black 2018 ; Caravale 2022 ). Most recently, scholars have adopted the capacious and flexible yet elusive terms “early modern Catholicism” or “the World of Catholic Renewal”, seeking to emphasize the diverse early modern and globalizing features of the faith, its practitioners, and institutions ( O’Malley 2002 ; Po-chia Hsia 1998 ; Bamji et al. 2013 ). Today, all these terms coexist, often uneasily, and continue to shape research projects Instead of taking sides in the never-ending controversy over how to label, research, and tell the story of religious change in early modern Italy, the goal of this Special Issue is to collect some of the most innovative recent work on the period by a new generation of scholars approaching our topic from the perspectives of diverse fields. The volume showcases the plurality of approaches used today to study the period still traditionally referred to as the “Counter Reformation”. Our aim is to bring to the fore the new research trajectories that historians, literary scholars, musicologists, and art historians are pursuing, as well as the

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Di Cesare, Del Rosario, Di Manno, Zhang, Just, Gap, Irene, Ways, Ideal, Christopher, Press, Cultura, Milan, Cambridge, Tatti, Marcus, Hands, Piemontese, Leonardo, Sartori, Eds, Villa, Concordia, Cesare, Zone, Rosario, Laven, Giovanni, Lavenia, Brill, Kiki, York, Tutino, Katherine, Lens, Saverino, Dell, Elena, Wave, October, Rolfe, Haven, Vergine, Janssen, Prodan, Stefania, Yale, Hand, Powers, Held, Melissa, Manno, Harper, Simon, Bridge, Post, Lucia, Council, Culture, Rems, Michelson, Herzig, Della, Run, Centre, Boston, Romana, Mary, Massimo, Alexandra, Aron, Non, Farnham, Firenze, Libri, Amato, Peter, Bari, Giorgio, Geert, Ties, Cristopher, Laterza, Presa, Fellows, Valente]

Religions 2023 , 14 , 622 3 of 4 new approaches they are employing to refashion our understanding of Catholicism in early modern Italy. Reflecting the different backgrounds of the two editors, the issue was also born out of an effort to bridge the gap between Italian and Anglophone scholarship, which often run on two parallel tracks, ignoring each other. In this respect, it is perhaps not just a coincidence that many of the conversations that led to this Special Issue began in an ideal scholarly “contact zone”, Villa I Tatti, where we were both fellows in 2015/16 This Special Issue consists of fifteen articles arranged into three overlapping sections (Gender, Space, Mobility), and concludes with an epilogue by Stefania Tutino, which ties together the main threads of the preceding essays and situates them in the new wave of scholarship on early modern Catholicism. The first section, Gender, focuses on women’s experiences of social and religious change and the power dynamics that shaped them Authors investigate how women navigated post-Tridentine restrictions on spiritual and intellectual pursuits (Mailes, Rolfe Prodan) and how they experienced persecution and abuse, often at the hands of celebrated Catholic authorities (Herzig, Pomara Saverino, Valente). The second section, Space, investigates how space (material and symbolic, public and private, urban and domestic) facilitated and foreclosed spiritual engagement and religious interactions between diverse groups and actors. Authors study how ecclesiastical visitors evaluated sacred images (Harper), the rise of Catholic antiquarianism (Di Manno), as well as the ways in which non-Catholic groups (Jews and Protestants) experienced space and circumvented Catholic norms (Aron-Beller, Celati, Michelson). Finally, the third section, Mobility, investigates how the boundaries between “orthodoxy” and “heterodoxy” were articulated and implemented, both in Italy and across the Catholic Mediterranean. By adopting the conceptual lens of “mobility”, admittedly a term that risks imprecision, this section explores, on the one hand, the individuals and objects that challenged and defied the “frontiers of heresy” (Amato, Lavenia, Nelles) and, on the other hand, the institutions and powers that tried to police them, such as the Roman Inquisition, the Council, and the Index of Prohibited Books (Dursteler, Marcus) Funding: This research received no external funding Acknowledgments: Many thanks to REMS, the Renaissance and Early Modern Designated Emphasis at UC Berkeley, and to the Department of History at the University of British Columbia, that sponsored the workshop “Religion and Culture in Early Modern Italy: New Questions and Approaches”, held on 30 October 2021, where the papers collected in this Special Issue were first presented. The editors would like to express their gratitude to Simon Ditchfield and Irene Fosi for participating in the workshop and for their comments and suggestions on the volume, as well as to the anonymous referees. Many thanks also to Kiki Zhang and her team at Religions for guiding us through the long publication process Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest References Aaron-Beller, Katherine, and Cristopher Black, eds. 2018 The Roman Inquisition. Centre versus Peripheries . Brill: Leiden-Boston Bamji, Alexandra, Geert H. Janssen, and Mary Laven, eds. 2013 The Ashgate Research Companion to the Counter-Reformation . Farnham: Ashgate Benjamin, Walter. 1986 Reflections: Essays, Aphorisms, Autobiographical Writings . New York: Schocken Books Black, Christopher. 2009 The Italian Inquisition . New Haven: Yale University Press Bonora, Elena. 2001 La Controriforma . Rome-Bari: Laterza Bonora, Elena. 2016. Il ritorno della Controriforma (e la Vergine del Rosario di Gu á pulo) Studi Storici 2: 267–95 Burke, Peter. 1987 The Historical Anthropology of Early Modern Italy . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Calaresu, Melissa. 2007. Travel, and the Picturesque in Late Eighteenth-Century Naples Italian Studies 62: 189–203. [ CrossRef ] Caravale, Giorgio. 2022 Libri pericolosi. Censura e cultura italiana in et à moderna . Rome-Bari: Laterza Ditchfield, Simon. 2008. In Sarpi’s Shadow: Coping with Trent the Italian Way. In Studi in memoria di Cesare Mozzarelli . 2 vols. Milan: Universit à Cattolica, vol. 1, pp. 585–606 Felici, Lucia. 2009 Profezie di riforma e idee di concordia religiosa: Visioni e speranze dell’esule piemontese Giovanni Leonardo Sartori Firenze: Olschki Firpo, Massimo. 2014 La presa di potere dell’inquisizione romana (1550–1553) . Rome-Bari: Laterza.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Stage, Einer, Bologna, Galileo, Concilio, Alla, Turin, Thomas, Datta, Josef, Adriano, View, Gigliola, Herder, Paris, Italiano, Von, London, Pari, Era, Waterson, Craft, Stocker, Ideas, Ronnie, Papale, Laws, Due, Prima, Ces, Mohn, Nella, Property, Dal]

Religions 2023 , 14 , 622 4 of 4 Firpo, Massimo. 2016. Rethinking ‘Catholic Reform’ and ‘Counter-Reformation’: What Happened in Early Modern Catholicism—A View from Italy Journal of Early Modern History 20: 293–312. [ CrossRef ] Fragnito, Gigliola, ed. 2001 Church, Censorship, and Culture in Early Modern Italy . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Fragnito, Gigliola. 2011 Cinquecento italiano. Religione, cultura e potere dal Rinascimento alla Controriforma . Bologna: Il Mulino Ginzburg, Carlo. 2013. Our Words, and Theirs: A Reflection on the Historian’s Craft, Today Chromos 2014: 97–119. [ CrossRef ] Jedin, Hubert. 1946 Katholische Reformation oder Gegenreformation? Ein Versuch zur Klärung der Begriffe nebst einer Jubiläumsbetrachtung über das Trienter Konzil . Luzern: Verlag Josef Stocker Jedin, Hubert. 1949–1975 Geschichte des Konzils von Trient . 4 vols. Freiburg im Breisgau: Herder Mayer, Thomas. 2013 The Roman Inquisition: A Papal Bureaucracy and Its Laws in the Age of Galileo . Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press Mayer, Thomas. 2014 The Roman Inquisition on the Stage of Italy c.1590–1640 . Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press O’Malley, John. 2002 Trent and All That: Renaming Catholicism in the Early Modern Era . Cambridge: Harvard University Press Po-chia Hsia, Ronnie. 1998 The World of Catholic Renewal 1540—1770 . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Prodi, Paolo. 1982 Il sovrano pontefice. Un corpo e due anime: La monarchia papale nella prima et à moderna . Bologna: Il Mulino Prosperi, Adriano. 1996 Tribunali della coscienza: Inquisitori, confessori, missionari . Turin: Einaudi Prosperi, Adriano. 2003 L’Inquisizione romana. Letture e ricerche . Rome: Storia e Letteratura Reinhard, Wolfgang. 1977. Gegenreformation als Modernisierung? Prolegomena zu einer Theorie des konfessionellen Zeitalters Archiv für Reformationsgeschichte-Archive for Reformation History 68: 226–52. [ CrossRef ] Sandys, Edwin. 1605 A Relation of the State of Religion . London: Simon Waterson Sarpi, Paolo. 2011 Istoria del Concilio Tridentino . Turin: Einaudi Schilling, Heinz. 1981 Konfessionskonflikt und Staatsbildung. Eine Fallstudie über das Verhältnis von religiösem und sozialem Wandel in der Frühneuzeit am Beispiel der Grafschaft Lippe . Gütersloh: G. Mohn Tedeschi, John. 1991 The Prosecution of Heresy: Collected Studies on the Inquisition in Early Modern Italy . Binghamton: Medieval and Renaissance Texts and Studies Valensi, Lucette. 2012 Ces é trangers Familiers. Musulmans en Europe (XVIe–XVIIIe si è cles) . Paris: Payot Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content.