Review of classical vs. contemporary research methods in Ayurveda
Journal name: Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine
Original article title: Review on comparability of ‘classical’ and ‘contemporary’ research methods in the context of Ayurveda
The Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine (JAIM) is an open-access publication promoting collaboration between Ayurveda, traditional medicine, and biomedicine, publishing research on integrative health sciences
This page does not contain the article itself; See source (below) for actual content.
Original source:
This page only sums up technical details and meta-data hence you should visit the source to read the original article which includes the author, publication date, notes and references.
M.V. Vinodkumar, A.K. Anoop
Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine:
(A monthly peer-reviewed publication)
Full text available for: Review on comparability of ‘classical’ and ‘contemporary’ research methods in the context of Ayurveda
Year: 2020 | Doi: 10.1016/j.jaim.2019.02.005
Copyright (license): CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Download the PDF file of the original publication
Glossary definitions and references:
Scientific and Ayurvedic Glossary list for “Review of classical vs. contemporary research methods in Ayurveda”. This list explains important keywords that occur in this article and links it to the glossary for a better understanding of that concept in the context of Ayurveda and other topics.
1) Table:
Table refers to a structured arrangement of data or information, typically organized in rows and columns. In the context of research and comparisons, tables help in visualizing and summarizing large amounts of information, making it easier to identify patterns, relationships, and key insights between classical and contemporary research methodologies.
2) Ayurveda (Ayus-veda):
Ayurveda is an ancient Indian system of medicine that emphasizes holistic health, preventive care, and individualized treatment based on the balance of bodily systems. It utilizes natural remedies and lifestyle changes, and is grounded in classical texts that detail various approaches to health, disease, and wellness, reflecting a rich tradition of medical practice.
3) Knowledge:
Knowledge encompasses the understanding, awareness, and insights gained through experience, education, and research. In the context of scientific inquiry and Ayurveda, knowledge serves as a foundation for developing theories and methodologies that guide practices in both traditional and contemporary frameworks of medicine and health care.
4) Anumana:
Anumana, translated as inference, is a key concept in Indian philosophy and epistemology, particularly in the Nyaya school. It represents a method of reasoning that allows one to draw conclusions from premises based on observations, forming a crucial part of both classical Ayurvedic inquiry and contemporary scientific methods.
5) Study (Studying):
A study refers to a detailed examination or analysis of a particular subject or phenomenon. In research, it involves systematic methods of gathering and interpreting data to derive conclusions, validate theories, and explore relationships among variables, ultimately contributing to the body of knowledge in a specific field.
6) Nature:
Nature represents the inherent characteristics and essence of organisms, processes, and systems within the environment. In research, understanding the nature of variables, relationships, and phenomena is critical for accurate analysis and interpretation, allowing researchers to make informed conclusions about the interactions and principles underlying their studies.
7) Hetu:
Hetu refers to the cause or reason in the context of reasoning and logic, particularly in the Indian epistemological tradition. It plays a significant role in establishing connections between observations and inferences, serving as the foundation for arguments that validate conclusions in both classical and contemporary scientific methodologies.
8) Caraka:
Caraka is a pivotal figure in ancient Indian medicine, recognized as a foundational contributor to Ayurvedic literature. His work, the Carakasamhita, outlines principles of diagnosis, treatment, and the philosophical underpinnings of Ayurveda, making it essential for understanding Ayurvedic research methodologies and their relevance to contemporary practices.
9) Science (Scientific):
Science encompasses systematic study aimed at understanding natural phenomena through observation, experimentation, and analysis. It relies on empirical evidence and logical reasoning to formulate theories and principles that explain the workings of the universe, influencing various disciplines, including traditional practices like Ayurveda.
10) Discussion:
Discussion in research is a critical component where findings are analyzed and interpreted in relation to hypotheses, existing literature, and broader implications. It allows researchers to contextualize their results, evaluate their significance, and propose future directions, facilitating knowledge advancement and application in real-world settings.
11) Inference:
Inference is the process of deriving logical conclusions from premises known or assumed to be true. In research, it involves interpreting data and establishing relationships, which enriches the understanding of phenomena, whether in classical systems like Ayurveda or contemporary scientific frameworks.
12) Observation:
Observation is a fundamental process in research involving the systematic gathering of data through sensory experience. It serves as a basis for hypothesis formulation and testing, and is essential for identifying patterns and relationships that inform both Ayurvedic practices and modern scientific inquiry.
13) Sadhya:
Sadhya refers to the desired outcome or objective in Ayurvedic and philosophical contexts. It signifies the target that treatment or research aims to achieve, thereby directing the focus of inquiry and intervention strategies in both classical and contemporary healthcare practices.
14) Vyapti:
Vyapti denotes the relationship of association or correlation between two variables. In research, establishing vyapti is crucial for determining patterns and causality, thereby facilitating deeper understanding of interactions in health phenomena, as recognized in both Ayurvedic and contemporary scientific methodologies.
15) Medicine:
Medicine is a broad field dedicated to the diagnosis, treatment, and prevention of illness and the promotion of health. It encompasses various systems like Ayurveda and modern biomedicine, each offering unique methodologies, philosophies, and practices aimed at understanding human health and disease.
16) Language:
Language is a system of communication, vital for conveying complex ideas, methodologies, and findings in research. It facilitates the articulation of concepts, theories, and data analysis, playing a key role in making research comprehensible within and across different fields, including Ayurveda and modern scientific communities.
17) Darshana (Darsana):
Darsana refers to a philosophical system in Indian thought that encompasses various schools of knowledge and inquiry. In the context of Ayurveda, darsana provides a philosophical foundation for understanding health, disease, and the human body, influencing the methodological approaches to research within the tradition.
18) Sutra:
Sutra refers to a concise, aphoristic statement given in traditional texts, often serving as guidelines or principles. In Ayurveda, sutras encapsulate complex ideas into succinct teachings, allowing for easier comprehension and transmission of essential knowledge across generations in both philosophical and practical contexts.
19) India:
India is the geographical and cultural context where Ayurveda originated and flourished. The country's rich philosophical traditions and holistic approach to health have significantly influenced both classical and contemporary practices, creating a diverse landscape for researching and understanding human health and well-being.
20) Karya:
Karya translates to action or the desired effect in the context of Ayurveda. It signifies the outcome or result of an intervention, such as achieving health balance, and is crucial for understanding the functional aspects of treatment methodologies and evaluating their effectiveness in research.
21) Pratyaksha (Pratyaksa):
Pratyaksha refers to perception through direct observation, a key means of acquiring knowledge in both Ayurveda and scientific methodologies. It underlines the importance of empirical evidence in establishing facts, guiding research inquiries, and validating practices across various disciplines.
22) Hetvabhasa (Hetu-abhasa):
Hetvabhasa denotes fallacious reasoning or misleading cause in philosophical and logical arguments. Recognizing hetvabhasa is essential in research to avoid biases, errors, and invalid conclusions, ensuring that methodologies and interpretations remain sound and credible in both Ayurveda and contemporary sciences.
23) Padartha (Pada-artha):
Padartha refers to the concept of 'thing' or 'object' in Indian philosophy, including Ayurveda. Understanding padartha is crucial for defining the elements of study in research, as it encompasses various classifications of materials and entities that affect health and treatment outcomes.
24) Kerala:
Kerala is a state in India recognized for its rich cultural heritage and as a hub for Ayurveda. The state plays a pivotal role in the preservation, promotion, and research of Ayurvedic practices, influencing modern integrative health approaches regionally and globally.
25) Paksha (Paksa):
Paksha signifies the subject or the instance under observation in logical analysis. It is a critical aspect of inquiry in Ayurveda that defines the sample population or the phenomenon being studied, aiding researchers in drawing valid conclusions based on evidence.
26) Karana:
Karana translates to the instrument or means used to achieve an outcome in the context of Ayurveda. Identifying karana is essential for understanding the mechanisms of interventions and their effectiveness in producing desired health results during research.
27) Nyaya:
Nyaya is one of the classical Indian philosophical systems focusing on logic and reasoning. It provides foundational principles for critical thinking and argumentation in the analysis and validation of knowledge, significantly impacting both Ayurvedic philosophy and scientific inquiry.
28) Rules:
Rules are established guidelines or principles that govern conduct or procedures in various contexts. In research and medical practices like Ayurveda, rules provide a structured framework for conducting inquiries, ensuring methodological rigor, and enhancing the validity of findings.
29) Vaisheshika (Vaisesika, Vaishesika, Vaiseshika):
Vaiseshika is an ancient Indian philosophy that classifies knowledge based on particular characteristics. It emphasizes the importance of categorizing and understanding the diverse nature of substances and phenomena, influencing Ayurvedic practices and the framework for scientific classification in modern contexts.
30) Activity:
Activity refers to an action or a set of actions performed to achieve a specific result, such as interventions in health care. Understanding activity is crucial in research to evaluate the effectiveness of treatments and to analyze outcomes in both classical Ayurvedic and modern scientific investigations.
31) Samanya:
Samanya translates to generality or the principle of universality in Ayurveda. It is fundamental for understanding common characteristics shared by substances or phenomena, aiding in the categorization and formulation of theories that apply across different contexts and conditions.
32) Yukti:
Yukti refers to reasoning or logical inference in Indian philosophy. It represents the mental processes employed in analysis and conclusion-drawing, enabling researchers to connect evidence to theories effectively in both Ayurvedic and contemporary scientific methodologies.
33) Reliability:
Reliability denotes the consistency and dependability of measurements or assessments in research. In both Ayurveda and modern science, ensuring reliability is paramount for validating results and establishing trust in methodologies that guide health interventions and treatment protocols.
34) Pramana:
Pramana refers to valid means of knowledge acquisition in philosophical traditions, primarily in Ayurveda. Understanding the various pramanas, such as perception and inference, is critical for establishing credible foundations for research, theoretical developments, and practical applications in health care.
35) Reason:
Reason is the cognitive process of forming conclusions, judgments, or inferences from facts or premises. In research, it plays a vital role in validating hypotheses and developing theories, underlining the importance of logical thinking in both classical Ayurvedic and modern scientific approaches.
36) Tarka (Darka, Dharka):
Tarka refers to the deductive reasoning process used in Indian philosophy to derive conclusions. It aids in establishing logical relationships between premises and outcomes, contributing significantly to the methodology of inquiry in Ayurveda and enhancing the rigor of scientific argumentation.
37) Sage:
Sage often denotes a wise or revered teacher in philosophical traditions, including Ayurveda. The contributions of sages are foundational in shaping the discourse of knowledge, providing valuable insights that drive both theoretical and practical advancements in health and well-being.
38) Caraka-samhita:
Caraka-samhita is a foundational text in Ayurveda that presents comprehensive principles of medicine, diagnosis, and treatment. It serves as a guideline for Ayurvedic practitioners, providing insights that influence both traditional practice and contemporary research in holistic health care.
39) Sutrasthana (Sutra-sthana):
Sutrasthana refers to one of the sections of the Carakasamhita, focusing on foundational principles and methodologies. This section outlines critical concepts vital for understanding Ayurvedic practice, serving as a reference for both classical understanding and modern research initiatives.
40) Anusandhana (Anusamdhana):
Anusandhana refers to the exploration and investigation of phenomenon or principles in Ayurveda. This term underscores the importance of in-depth inquiry and systematic research methodologies employed in understanding health and treatment outcomes within Ayurvedic practices.
41) Pancabhuta (Panca-bhuta, Pancan-bhuta, Pamcabhuta):
Pancabhuta signifies the five elements (earth, water, fire, air, and space) that constitute all matter in Ayurveda. These elements frame the understanding of health and disease, and their interaction forms a basis for Ayurvedic diagnostics and therapeutic approaches.
42) Tridosha (Tridosa, Tri-dosha):
Tridosha refers to the three fundamental bodily energies (Vata, Pitta, Kapha) in Ayurveda that influence health and personality. The concept underpins Ayurvedic practice, guiding personalized treatments and understanding individual constitution in both classical texts and contemporary applications.
43) Prakriti (Prakrti):
Prakriti refers to an individual’s inherent constitution or nature in Ayurveda, determined by the balance of the tridoshas. Understanding prakriti is essential for tailoring treatments and preventive measures, ensuring alignment with an individual's unique physiological and psychological profile.
44) Sanskrit:
Sanskrit is the ancient language of India in which most classical texts, including Ayurvedic literature, are written. It provides the linguistic framework for conveying complex philosophical ideas and medical knowledge, facilitating the preservation and transmission of traditional wisdom through generations.
45) Samkhya (Sankhya, Shankhya):
Sankhya is one of the six classical schools of Indian philosophy, primarily focusing on enumeration and categorization of reality. It influences Ayurvedic principles by elucidating the nature of existence and knowledge, forming the foundational aspects of Ayurvedic philosophy and methodology.
46) Anvaya:
Anvaya signifies a positive correlation or relationship established between variables in research. In Ayurveda, understanding anvaya aids in assessing causality and interactions, reinforcing the importance of logical reasoning in evaluating health phenomena and treatment outcomes.
47) Vimana:
Vimana refers to the section of the Carakasamhita that focuses on specialized knowledge and methodologies in Ayurveda. It provides critical insights into research principles, treatment design, and the interpretation of therapeutic efficacy in the context of Ayurvedic practice.
48) Sharman (Sarma, Sharma, Sarman):
Sharma is a common surname in India, often associated with scholars and practitioners in the fields of Ayurveda and philosophy. Individuals with this name have contributed significantly to the evolution and dissemination of Ayurvedic knowledge, reflecting a rich cultural heritage devoted to health and healing.
49) Indian:
Indian pertains to the cultural, philosophical, and historical context of India, where diverse systems of knowledge, including Ayurveda, originated. It highlights the interconnectedness of tradition and modernity in health practices, contributing to a holistic understanding of wellness and healthcare systems.
50) Shamya (Samya):
Samya refers to the state of balance or equality, especially regarding health and disease in Ayurveda. Understanding samya is crucial for developing treatment plans that restore equilibrium within the body, reflecting the holistic principles that guide Ayurvedic practice.
51) Hita:
Hita signifies beneficial or advantageous outcomes, particularly in the context of health and wellness. In Ayurvedic practice, achieving hita is essential for promoting well-being and treating ailments, demonstrating the focus on positive health impacts embedded within Ayurvedic philosophies.
52) Human body:
Human body denotes the physical entity that Ayurveda seeks to understand and maintain through holistic healthcare practices, emphasizing the interconnectedness of body, mind, and spirit. Ayurvedic principles center around restoring and preserving health in the intricate dynamics of the human body.
53) Vyatirekavyapti (Vyatireka-vyapti):
Vyatireka-vyapti describes a negative correlation, emphasizing the absence of one variable resulting in the absence of another. In Ayurveda, recognizing this relationship aids in understanding how absence or presence influences health outcomes, thus informing treatment strategies based on causative factors.
54) Mulaprakriti (Mula-prakriti, Mulaprakrti):
Mula-prakriti refers to the primordial nature or fundamental substance from which everything arises in Ayurveda. Understanding mula-prakriti is essential for recognizing the basic elements driving existence and health, contributing to the theory and practice of treatment and diagnosis.
55) Savyabhicara:
Savyabhicara refers to fallacies correlated with misleading evidence or reasoning. In research contexts, identification of savyabhicara is crucial for ensuring validity and reliability of conclusions drawn, playing an important role in maintaining rigor and integrity in both Ayurveda and contemporary scientific practices.
56) Aptopadesha (Aptopadesa, Apta-upadesha):
Aptopadesa denotes authoritative knowledge derived from learned sources or texts. In Ayurveda, it emphasizes the importance of reference to established literature and wisdom of practitioners for guiding treatment methodologies and ensuring alignment with time-tested principles in medicinal practices.
57) Perception:
Perception refers to the awareness and interpretation of sensory data. In research, particularly Ayurvedic studies, perception is crucial for understanding the subjective experiences of individuals, thus guiding assessments of health conditions and effectiveness of treatments in a holistic manner.
58) Anubandha (Anubamdha):
Anubandha indicates the subsequent outcome or connection arising from actions or treatments in Ayurveda. Understanding anubandha is vital for evaluating long-term effects and implications of interventions, reflecting the dynamics of health and disease over time within Ayurvedic practice.
59) Shrikantha (Srikantha, Shri-kantha, Shrikamtha):
Srikantha refers to a modern scholar or commentator in the Ayurveda tradition. Contributions by Srikantha, especially in interpreting classical texts, have helped in bridging traditional knowledge with contemporary applications, enhancing the understanding of Ayurvedic methodologies.
60) Paramarsha (Paramarsa):
Paramarsa signifies the critical reflection or analysis of evidence and reasoning in logic. This evaluative process is fundamental in Ayurvedic inquiry, ensuring that conclusions drawn from observations are valid, thereby reinforcing the intellectual rigor characteristic of both classical and modern scientific approaches.
61) Education:
Education refers to the process of acquiring knowledge and skills through systematic instruction. In the context of Ayurveda, education plays a pivotal role in training practitioners and researchers, ensuring the transmission of traditional wisdom and contemporary scientific methodologies in health care.
62) Vagbhata:
Vagbhata is a significant figure in Ayurvedic history, known for his works, including the Ashtanga Hridaya. His contributions shape Ayurvedic doctrine and practice, providing insights into the principles of diagnosis, treatment, and holistic health, thus influencing contemporary understanding in the field.
63) Varanasi (Varanashi):
Varanasi, an ancient city in India, is a cultural and spiritual center where rich traditions, including Ayurveda, thrive. It represents a historical context for studying classical texts, methodologies, and practices, contributing to the broader understanding of Indian systems of health.
64) Pratijna:
Pratijna refers to a statement of hypothesis or the assertion of a conclusion drawn from premises. It serves as a foundational element in both logical reasoning and Ayurvedic research, guiding inquiries and establishing the framework for testing and validation.
65) Agnivesha (Agnivesa, Agni-vesha):
Agnivesa is a prominent figure in Ayurveda, credited with the composition of the Agnivesh Tantra, an essential text in Ayurvedic tradition. His work has significantly influenced medical practices, establishing principles of treatment and healing that continue to inform contemporary Ayurvedic methodologies.
66) Samhita:
Samhita refers to a collection or compilation of texts that systematically present knowledge, often in poetic form. In Ayurveda, samhitas are vital resources that detail theories, practitioners' guidelines, and treatment protocols, shaping both classical methodologies and modern integrative practices.
67) Purusha (Purusa):
Purusha signifies the individual self or consciousness in various philosophical traditions. In Ayurveda, understanding purusha is essential for recognizing the interplay between consciousness and health, influencing treatment approaches that acknowledge the holistic nature of human well-being.
68) Drishta (Drsta):
Drishta refers to observable phenomena or evident aspects in research. In Ayurvedic context, emphasizing drishta enhances the focus on empirical aspects of health and treatment, ensuring that observations are foundational for drawing valid conclusions and establishing effective practices.
69) Ghataka:
Ghataka translates to components or factors that contribute to an outcome in a process. In research methodology, understanding ghataka is essential for analyzing variables and their interactions, especially in determining effective treatment strategies in both classical and modern contexts.
70) Quality:
Quality denotes the standard or degree of excellence in outcomes, practices, or materials. In Ayurveda, assessing quality is crucial for ensuring effective treatments, reliable measurements, and high standards of care, reflecting the commitment to holistic health and wellness.
71) Disease:
Disease refers to a condition adversely affecting the body or mind, disrupting normal functioning. Understanding disease is fundamental in Ayurvedic practice, guiding diagnosis, treatment planning, and the pursuit of holistic health through a balanced approach, using natural remedies and personalized care.
72) Bandha (Bamdha):
Bandha refers to the relationship or connection between factors or phenomena. In Ayurvedic terms, understanding bandha is crucial for identifying interactions that influence health outcomes, thereby guiding treatment protocols and methodologies for addressing various health conditions.
73) Ashraya (Asraya):
Asraya indicates the support or foundation underlying phenomena in Ayurveda. Recognizing asraya is essential for understanding health conditions, as it relates to the basis upon which treatment strategies are constructed, ensuring relevance and effectiveness in patient care.
74) Purity:
Purity refers to the untainted or unadulterated state of essence, especially in traditional practices. In Ayurveda, maintaining purity in methods and interventions is vital for ensuring the integrity of treatments, reflecting an adherence to principles that guide holistic health.
75) Satta (Shatta):
Satta represents the state of existence or being in philosophical discourse. In the context of Ayurveda, understanding satta is essential for grasping the underlying realities of health and disease, guiding theoretical and practical approaches to treatment and wellness.
[Note: The above list is limited to 75. Total glossary definitions available: 178]