Fire Risk Assessments of Informal Settlements Based on Fire Risk Index and...

[Full title: Fire Risk Assessments of Informal Settlements Based on Fire Risk Index and Bayesian Network]

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Zhang, Shu, South, New, Richard, Town, Doi, Human, Level, Quiroz, Basel, Isabela, Xie, David, Key, Normal, Delhi, Int, Risk, Rush, Maps, Great, Land, Natalia, Comes, Jun, China, Cape, Forward, Data, Under, Put, High, Middle, Jimmy, Open, November, Taylor, Due, Role, Semi, Strong, Morrissey, Africa, Lei, Tel, Flores, Towns, Shen]

Citation: Hu, J.; Xie, X.; Shu, X.; Shen, S.; Ni, X.; Zhang, L. Fire Risk Assessments of Informal Settlements Based on Fire Risk Index and Bayesian Network Int. J. Environ Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 https://doi.org/10.3390/ ijerph 192315689 Academic Editor: Jimmy T. Efird Received: 10 November 2022 Accepted: 24 November 2022 Published: 25 November 2022 Publisher’s Note: MDPI stays neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations Copyright: © 2022 by the authors Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https:// creativecommons.org/licenses/by/ 4.0/) International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health Article Fire Risk Assessments of Informal Settlements Based on Fire Risk Index and Bayesian Network Jun Hu 1,2 , Xuecai Xie 3,4, *, Xueming Shu 3,4 , Shifei Shen 3,4 , Xiaoyong Ni 1,2 and Lei Zhang 3,4 1 School of National Safety and Emergency Management, Beijing Normal University at Zhuhai, Zhuhai 519087, China 2 Academy of Disaster Reduction and Emergency Management, Ministry of Emergency Management & Ministry of Education, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China 3 Department of Engineering Physics, Institute of Public Safety Research, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China 4 Beijing Key Laboratory of City Integrated Emergency Response Science, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China * Correspondence: xiexuecai 1989@126.com; Tel.: +86-181-013-050-96 Abstract: The specific risk assessment of informal settlements (IS) is important for the management of IS and protection of environmental safety and public health. In this paper, we introduced the different types of IS in China, and conducted the fire risk assessment on 26 burning buildings in these IS, providing a semi-quantitative and scenario fire risk perception of IS in China for the readers Two methods, the risk index and the Bayesian network, are proposed and adopted for the fire risk assessment in IS. First, a risk index system with a total of 69 factors is used to assess the degree of fire risk of buildings in IS semi-quantitatively, and the result shows that fire equipment and fire safety management on IS are seriously lacking. Then, a Bayesian network of building fire risk with a total of 66 nodes was established to assess the fire risk from ignition to spread as well as the safety evacuation. Overall, the possibility of ignition is high, but due to the role of fire equipment and fire protection design, the possibilities of fire from ignition to spread is gradually reduced. Finally, we also put forward some feasible suggestions for occupants in IS, community organizations and emergency managers to reduce the fire risk from the aspects of fire equipment and fire safety management Keywords: informal settlements; fire risk; risk index; Bayesian network 1. Introduction In many lowand middle-income countries, there are some informal settlements (IS) in cities. Broadly speaking, informal settlements are places built outside land-use schemes and without planning permission [ 1 ]. In some literature, the “informal settlements” mainly refer to slums or shantytowns in some African countries or Asian countries, and informal settlements, slums, squatter settlements, unplanned towns and shantytowns are terms that are used interchangeably in the literature. From the perspective of risk, the fire risk in IS is at a high level, and it is of great significance to conduct fire risk assessments and understand the risk sources in IS Nowadays, many studies on IS fires have been carried out, including fire dynamics [ 2 – 4 ], human behaviors [ 5 , 6 ], fire detection [ 7 ] and fire investigation [ 8 ]. When it comes to fire risk, David Rush et al. have examined fire risks in IS in New Delhi, Cape Town and Lebanon, based on literature, statistical data and qualitative interviews [ 9 ]; Natalia Flores Quiroz et al have obtained fire risk perception of the IS complex inhabitants with surveys to comprehend why the fire started [ 10 ]; Richard et al. have qualitatively presented an appraisal of various interventions and strategies to improve fire safety in IS in South Africa [ 11 ]; Isabela et al have assessed the fire exposure and risks in IS in Tanzania, mainly based on interviews [ 12 ]; Morrissey and Taylor have analyzed the factors influencing the fire risk in the IS in Cape Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph 192315689 https://www.mdpi.com/journal/ijerph

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Carry, Matthew, Makes, Left, Standard, Wood, Million, John, Idea, Field, Development, Cases, Twigg, Brick, Future, Hand, Lack, Ideas, Going, Market, Still, Hazard, Legal, End, Short, Shown]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 2 of 18 Town qualitatively [ 13 ]. In addition to fires, considering other disasters, such as flooding or earthquake, some studies have also analyzed the comprehensive risks in IS [ 14 – 17 ]. Overall, the discussion and analysis of the fire risk of IS are qualitative in these studies. The fire risks in IS have been discussed to be high, but the degree of “high” has not been quantified. Some scholars have also put forward some ideas of quantitative or semi-quantitative risk assessment; for example, John Twigg et al. have suggested that community-based risk and vulnerability assessment methods could be adapted, Matthew et al. have developed a theoretical framework coupling “disaster hazards”, “vulnerability” and “informal settlements” to conceptualize a detailed risk profile in IS, and Giambelli et al. have presented an idea for the practical decision support system for the IS in Kathmandu [ 1 , 18 , 19 ]. However, the specific assessment has yet to be carried out, which is partly due to the lack of relevant information of IS in these countries [ 18 ]. Meanwhile, in addition to the slums, squatter settlements and shantytowns, other IS types should also be studied. IS are not going to disappear completely within a short period in developing countries; instead, the form of IS is constantly changing. In China, with the development of the economy, the number of slums, squatter settlements or shantytowns has disappeared, but there are still some settlements built outside land-use schemes or without planning permission, and they are composed mainly of buildings that deviate from the standard building regulations. Compared to the IS in other countries, the IS in China have some different features, and the types of IS are likely to emerge in other developing countries in the future as society develops. Hence, the research of fire risk in IS in China is meaningful and prospective, as it can expand the scope of current research on IS and provide experience on fire prevention for IS in other developing countries In brief, the research on fire risk in informal settlements is still insufficient. On one hand, the categories of IS can be expanded more than slums, squatter settlements and shantytowns; on the other hand, the fire risk can be assessed in more depth. Recently, the Bayesian network (BN) has been applied in the field of fire risk assessment to reflect the uncertain characteristic of risk [ 20 – 23 ]. Therefore, the fire risk of IS can be further quantified and assessed, so as to perceive the specific degree of risk and how the fire risk changes in different stages Accordingly, we carry out a semi-quantitative and staged fire risk assessment for IS in China with two methods, namely the risk index and the Bayesian network. The risk index is based on an index system currently widely used in China’s fire protection market, and it can clarify the sources of risks in IS and characterize the degree of high risk; while with the Bayesian network, the fire risk can be analyzed from ignition to spread. This research is helpful to supplement the current research on fire risk in IS and provide valuable experience on fire prevention for IS in other developing countries. The paper is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces the types and characteristics of IS in China and provides brief information on selected IS fire cases. Section 3 introduces the two risk assessment methods, namely the risk index and the Bayesian network. Section 4 provides the risk assessment results of IS in China with the two methods mentioned above, and Section 5 makes a detailed discussion of the fire risk and puts some feasible suggestions to reduce the risk. Finally, Section 6 concludes this paper 2. IS Types and Fire Cases 2.1. IS Types in China By the end of 2018, more than 100 million shantytown residents had left the shantytowns and lived in the planned buildings in China [ 24 ]. However, there are still some other types of IS in China, which are composed mainly of buildings that deviate from the standard building regulations. Considering the risk of fire, the IS in China are categorized as follows, and some typical constructions are shown in Figure 1 : 1 Old communities (OC): The formation of these communities is legal and planned, but the construction of the buildings is relatively old. The old communities have a great fire hazard, as the construction materials (such as wood and brick) and fire

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Steel, Meet, Four, Decoration, Urban, Vic, Body, Main, Areas, Floors, Bricks, Hard, Table, Color, Serious, Roof]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 3 of 18 protection design (such as fire separation distance) meet the previous standards, but do not comply with the current fire regulations 2 Informally constructed settlements (ICS): These settlements mostly appear in urban– rural fringe areas or villages in the city (VIC, a special phenomenon of urbanization in China), and some buildings were constructed without official approval. After construction, they have not been checked or audited by the fire department, so they are fragile in the event of a fire 3 Informally modified settlements (IMS): In these settlements, the construction of the buildings was approved, but the later modifications, such as additional floors, decoration processes or annexes, were private and illegal. After the modifications, the fire hazards of the building increased. For example, some buildings used cheap but flammable color steel plates as roofs 4 Informally functioned settlements (IFS): In these settlements, the construction of the buildings was approved, but the owners changed the function of the buildings without authorization, which greatly increased the fire risk. For example, in some residential buildings, the functions of accommodation, production, storage and business are mixed, leading to the increase in flammable substances. These settlements are also called “mixed-function settlements” in China, and they violate the regulations of fire safety requirement for places combining habitation, production, storage and business (GA 703-2007) [ 25 ]. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 3 of 19 standard building regulations. Considering the risk of fire, the IS in China are categorized as follows, and some typical constructions are shown in Figure 1: 1 Old communities (OC): The formation of these communities is legal and planned, but the construction of the buildings is relatively old. The old communities have a great fire hazard, as the construction materials (such as wood and brick) and fire protection design (such as fire separation distance) meet the previous standards, but do not comply with the current fire regulations. 2 Informally constructed settlements (ICS): These settlements mostly appear in urban– rural fringe areas or villages in the city (VIC, a special phenomenon of urbanization in China), and some buildings were constructed without official approval. After construction, they have not been checked or audited by the fire department, so they are fragile in the event of a fire. 3 Informally modified settlements (IMS): In these settlements, the construction of the buildings was approved, but the later modifications, such as additional floors, decoration processes or annexes, were private and illegal. After the modifications, the fire hazards of the building increased. For example, some buildings used cheap but flammable color steel plates as roofs. 4 Informally functioned settlements (IFS): In these settlements, the construction of the buildings was approved, but the owners changed the function of the buildings without authorization, which greatly increased the fire risk. For example, in some residential buildings, the functions of accommodation, production, storage and business are mixed, leading to the increase in flammable substances. These settlements are also called “mixed-function settlements” in China, and they violate the regulations of fire safety requirement for places combining habitation, production, storage and business (GA 703-2007) [25]. ( a ) ( b ) ( c ) ( d ) Figure 1. Four types of IS in China. ( a ) Old communities, where the main body of the building was made of bricks. ( b ) Informally constructed settlements, where the buildings were constructed without official approval. ( c ) Informally modified settlements, where the additional decoration of the roof was private and illegal. ( d ) Informally functioned settlements, where the functions of accommodation, production, storage and business were mixed. 2.2. Fire Cases To carry out fire risk assessment on IS, it is necessary to obtain comprehensive information of the objects. However, it is hard to obtain the comprehensive information in IS [17]. In this research, we selected 26 building fire cases in IS in China for risk assessment. For one thing, the detailed information of these serious fire cases can be found in the investigation report issued by the fire department [26], based on which the specific risk assessment can be conducted. For another, the result of burning is also a concentrated reflection of the high-risk characteristics of IS. The brief information of the fire cases is shown in Table 1. Figure 1. Four types of IS in China. ( a ) Old communities, where the main body of the building was made of bricks. ( b ) Informally constructed settlements, where the buildings were constructed without official approval. ( c ) Informally modified settlements, where the additional decoration of the roof was private and illegal. ( d ) Informally functioned settlements, where the functions of accommodation, production, storage and business were mixed 2.2. Fire Cases To carry out fire risk assessment on IS, it is necessary to obtain comprehensive information of the objects. However, it is hard to obtain the comprehensive information in IS [ 17 ]. In this research, we selected 26 building fire cases in IS in China for risk assessment. For one thing, the detailed information of these serious fire cases can be found in the investigation report issued by the fire department [ 26 ], based on which the specific risk assessment can be conducted. For another, the result of burning is also a concentrated reflection of the high-risk characteristics of IS. The brief information of the fire cases is shown in Table 1 .

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Transport, June, January, Date, Single, Time, December, September, Large, February, August, Labor, Grade, Rui, State, Harbin, Case, Knowledge, April, Factor, Common]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 4 of 18 Table 1. The brief information of the fire cases in IS Case Number Date City Cause IS Type Casualty 1 13 January 2011 Changsha Electric heater failure IMS 14 2 17 January 2011 Wuhan Unclear OC 14 3 25 April 2011 Beijing Electrical circuit failure ICS 42 4 8 August 2013 Rui’an Electrical circuit failure OC 7 5 19 November 2013 Beijing Electric heater IFS 16 6 1 January 2013 Hangzhou Arson IMS 5 7 11 December 2013 Shenzhen Electrical circuit failure IFS 21 8 11 January 2014 Shangri-La Electric heater OC 0 9 14 January 2014 Taizhou Electrical circuit failure IMS 21 10 16 November 2014 Shouguang Electrical circuit failure ICS 31 11 29 November 2014 Cixi Electrical circuit failure IFS 6 12 26 December 2014 Fuyang Unclear ICS 11 13 21 May 2015 Xi’an Electrical equipment failure ICS 3 14 25 May 2015 Pingdingshan Electrical circuit failure ICS 45 15 2 January 2015 Harbin Electric heater OC 19 16 25 June 2015 Zhengzhou Electrical circuit failure ICS 17 17 31 December 2015 Shenyang Unclear OC 6 18 15 February 2016 Qionglai Careless use of fire OC 5 19 18 June 2016 Shanghai Electrical circuit failure IMS 5 20 23 September 2016 Chengdu Electrical circuit failure IFS 0 21 26 May 2016 Hangzhou Careless use of fire IMS 7 22 25 September 2017 Yuhuan Electrical circuit failure ICS 13 23 4 November 2017 Dunhuang Careless use of fire ICS 0 24 18 November 2017 Beijing Electrical circuit failure IFS 27 25 30 December 2017 Ganzhou Electrical circuit failure ICS 5 26 28 December 2018 Sanming Careless use of fire OC 5 These fire cases occurred in the above-mentioned four types of IS in different areas of China (to the city level) from 2011 to 2018. In these cases, the causes of the fire include electrical failure, arson and careless use of fire, and many fires have caused serious casualties. In particular, the common cause of some electrical fires in IS is a short circuit caused by electric bicycle charging (e.g., Case 3, 4, 19 and 22). In fact, not only for IS, but the fires also caused by electric bicycles account for a large proportion of the current number of fires in China. The electric bicycle has served as a means of transport for many families, as it is cheap and labor-saving. However, many fires are caused by the excessive charging time or the unqualified battery [ 27 ]. 3. Risk Assessment Methods 3.1. Fire Risk Index Fire risk index is a widely applied method in the field of fire risk assessment. With this method, the value called “risk index” is a measure of the level of safety/risk in the evaluation object. First, the fire risk index system is composed of many factors which are selected by experts, including scientists, insurance, fire brigade, etc. Second, the importance of each factor is decided by assigning a value. This value is based on the knowledge and the experience of experts with a weight assignment method such as the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and fuzzy mathematical model [ 28 , 29 ]. Meanwhile, the state of each factor is determined with another value, representing the grade of each factor. Finally, these values are operated by some combination of arithmetic functions to achieve a single value, and that is risk index. A popular arithmetic function is shown in Formula (1): I = n ∑ i = 1 w i x i (1)

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Stage, Quite, Rules, Dag, Staff, Doors, Tool, Major, Big, Tanzer, Full, Company, Lower, Study, Small, Early, Bigger, Burns]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 5 of 18 where I denotes the risk index, n denotes the total number of factors, w i is the weight of factor i, and x i is the grade for factor i The fire risk index system, including the factors and weights, varies depending on the country/region and building type. Some studies have built risk index systems for the fire risk in IS [ 30 – 33 ], but the risk index systems are quite different for different IS cases, and the risk characteristics of IS are not summarized under the same evaluation system. In this research, we chose a fire risk index system developed by Global Safety Tanzer Technology Company. This fire risk index system is widely applicable for different buildings, as it has been used for fire risk assessment on more than 50,000 households and businesses in China and affirmed and recognized by the users [ 34 ]. With this index system, the risk characteristics of IS can be summarized under the same evaluation system This system is composed of 69 factors, which are selected by the experts based on the fire regulations in China and considering the availability of information, and the weight of each factor is decided by experts with the AHP method. The factors are structured under three global factors: fire protection design, fire equipment and fire safety management The total sub-factors, weights and assignment rules are specifically shown in Appendix A . Meanwhile, it should be noted that the “fire risk index” is a measure of the level of safety in this paper, that is, the higher the index value, the lower the risk. In this way, the safest state corresponds to a score of 100 points, and the most unsafe state corresponds to 0. Both 100 points and 0 points are idealized states and do not exist in practice. The score ratio of each global factor is shown in Table 2 . In this paper, the risk index and safety score are the same thing Table 2. The score ratio of each global factor for the fire risk index Global Factor Scores fire protection design 20 fire equipment 40 fire safety management 40 3.2. Bayesian Network The ending scene of a building fire is uncertain. It may be a small fire extinguished at the early stage after ignition, or a big fire extinguished after full development or even spread to the neighboring buildings. During the whole process of burning, the measures including fire prevention and firefighting will be involved, making the possibility of small fire to big fire continuously reduced. Meanwhile, the reliability of fire prevention and firefighting (fire doors, sprinkler systems, etc.) is uncertain, as they are affected by many factors. Therefore, the fire risk changes in stages With the fire risk index, the risk sources of fire and their impacts can be understood comprehensively, but it cannot reflect the stage characteristics of fire risk. Bayesian network (BN) is a tool for uncertainty reasoning based on graph theory, and it consists of a directed acyclic graph (DAG) and conditional probability tables (CPT). The DAG displays the relationship between various variables qualitatively, while the CPT express their relationship quantitatively. BN has been widely used in the field of risk assessment [ 20 – 23 ], and in some research, it is used to assess the risk at different fire stages [ 22 , 23 , 35 ]. In this study, the conceptual framework for fire risk assessment based on the Bayesian network is shown in Figure 2 . According to the intensity of combustion, a fire is divided into the following major stages: ignition, growth, development and spread. The “growth” stage represents the early stage after the ignition, when the fire is small and can be extinguished by personnel; the “development” stage indicates that the fire is bigger and difficult to be controlled by personnel (building occupants, staff, but not including professional firefighters), and it burns fully inside the building; the “spread” stage means the fire is so big that it can spread to the neighboring buildings. In this way, the fire risk is characterized by the possibilities of the fire in different stages, as well as the possibility of safety evacuation under different situations (the prevention of casualties in building fires is more

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Alarm, Low, Set, Speed, Names, Wind, Property]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 6 of 18 important, so we only consider evacuation, while other consequences such as property damage and building collapse are not considered in this paper). Generally, the possibility of ignition is related to the ignition sources and hazard management; the possibility of growth is related to the reliability of fire alarm systems and human response after ignition; the possibility of development is related to the reliability of fire control measures such as fire shutter, sprinkler system, fire-retardant structure and response of the fire brigade; the possibility of spread is related to the fire separation and weather factors (mainly wind speed); and the possibility of safety evacuation is related to emergency announcements, evacuation facilities, evacuation skills and the fire scene environment when the fire is out of human control Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 6 of 19 In this study, the conceptual framework for fire risk assessment based on the Bayesian network is shown in Figure 2. According to the intensity of combustion, a fire is divided into the following major stages: ignition, growth, development and spread. The “growth” stage represents the early stage after the ignition, when the fire is small and can be extinguished by personnel; the “development” stage indicates that the fire is bigger and difficult to be controlled by personnel (building occupants, staff, but not including professional firefighters), and it burns fully inside the building; the “spread” stage means the fire is so big that it can spread to the neighboring buildings. In this way, the fire risk is characterized by the possibilities of the fire in different stages, as well as the possibility of safety evacuation under different situations (the prevention of casualties in building fires is more important, so we only consider evacuation, while other consequences such as property damage and building collapse are not considered in this paper). Generally, the possibility of ignition is related to the ignition sources and hazard management; the possibility of growth is related to the reliability of fire alarm systems and human response after ignition; the possibility of development is related to the reliability of fire control measures such as fire shutter, sprinkler system, fire-retardant structure and response of the fire brigade; the possibility of spread is related to the fire separation and weather factors (mainly wind speed); and the possibility of safety evacuation is related to emergency announcements, evacuation facilities, evacuation skills and the fire scene environment when the fire is out of human control. Figure 2. Conceptual framework for fire risk assessment based on BN. Furthermore, these related factors are affected by sub-factors. For example, whether the fire source exists is related to whether the residents are smoking, using open flames and so on. In total, there are 66 nodes in the Bayesian network for fire risk assessment, and the Bayesian network structure constructed with the software of Netica is shown in Figure 3. The detailed names and states of these nodes are shown in Appendix B. Figure 2. Conceptual framework for fire risk assessment based on BN Furthermore, these related factors are affected by sub-factors. For example, whether the fire source exists is related to whether the residents are smoking, using open flames and so on. In total, there are 66 nodes in the Bayesian network for fire risk assessment, and the Bayesian network structure constructed with the software of Netica is shown in Figure 3 . The detailed names and states of these nodes are shown in Appendix B . Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 7 of 19 Figure 3. The Bayesian network structure for fire risk assessment with the software of Netica. After the construction of Bayesian network structure, it is necessary to set the structural parameters, namely the conditional probabilities, which represent the quantitative relationship between nodes. For the Bayesian network established in this study, the parameters are set based on the knowledge and experience of experts. The correspondence between the orientation of experts and the quantitative possibility value is shown in Table 3. Although the treatment seems subjective, it is widely used in the current research as the conditional probability is difficult to objectively determine [21,22,35]. Table 3. The correspondence between the orientation of experts and the possibility value. Orientation Possibility(%) very likely 99 likely 80 possible 50 unlikely 20 very unlikely 1 4. Results According to the investigation report issued by the fire department, we can obtain the comprehensive information of the burning cases in IS. Then the grades for factors in the fire risk index system and the states of nodes in the Bayesian network can be obtained. Risk assessment can be carried out by using fire risk index and BN methods. 4.1. Fire Risk Index in IS Based on the grades and weights of factors in the fire risk index system, the fire risk indexes of the 26 burning cases in IS can be obtained, and the results are shown in Figure 4. Generally speaking, a score below 60 means that the building is unsafe. Obviously, the risk of these fire cases is high, and the safety score is low. Except for Case 6, which has a significantly higher score, the safety scores of the other 25 cases did not exceed 60 points Figure 3. The Bayesian network structure for fire risk assessment with the software of Netica.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Ways, Less, Better, Enough, Smoke, Lighting, Safe]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 7 of 18 After the construction of Bayesian network structure, it is necessary to set the structural parameters, namely the conditional probabilities, which represent the quantitative relationship between nodes. For the Bayesian network established in this study, the parameters are set based on the knowledge and experience of experts. The correspondence between the orientation of experts and the quantitative possibility value is shown in Table 3 . Although the treatment seems subjective, it is widely used in the current research as the conditional probability is difficult to objectively determine [ 21 , 22 , 35 ]. Table 3. The correspondence between the orientation of experts and the possibility value Orientation Possibility(%) very likely 99 likely 80 possible 50 unlikely 20 very unlikely 1 4. Results According to the investigation report issued by the fire department, we can obtain the comprehensive information of the burning cases in IS. Then the grades for factors in the fire risk index system and the states of nodes in the Bayesian network can be obtained. Risk assessment can be carried out by using fire risk index and BN methods 4.1. Fire Risk Index in IS Based on the grades and weights of factors in the fire risk index system, the fire risk indexes of the 26 burning cases in IS can be obtained, and the results are shown in Figure 4 . Generally speaking, a score below 60 means that the building is unsafe. Obviously, the risk of these fire cases is high, and the safety score is low. Except for Case 6, which has a significantly higher score, the safety scores of the other 25 cases did not exceed 60 points (The cause of Case 6 is arson, and the building was equipped with some fire facilities, although the construction of the building is illegal) Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 8 of 19 (The cause of Case 6 is arson, and the building was equipped with some fire facilities, although the construction of the building is illegal). It can be seen that the scores for fire protection design of many cases are no more than 10 points. This is related to the building materials with low fire resistance ratings and inadequate design of fire separation and evacuation. The fire equipment and fire safety management are seriously lacking for some cases, as one of them has a score of 0 (Case 4, 9 and 10), or even both are 0 (Case 2, 3, 25 and 26). The complete fire equipment includes a water supply system, fire hydrant system, sprinkler system, automatic fire alarm system, smoke management system, emergency lighting system, evacuation indicator system and fire extinguishers. But for many buildings in IS, there was no fire equipment, or the fire equipment was incomplete, and thus the safety score for this item is low. Fire safety management has not received enough attention in IS, leading to its low safety score. The fire control publicity and training provided by the communities are inadequate in IS: on one hand, people have little knowledge of requirements on safe ignition (Case 4, 11, 21 and 26). On the other hand, there is no training and drill for extinguishment or evacuation, resulting in the improper response to the fire at an early stage (Case 21 and 25) and incorrect escape ways when the fire becomes big (Case 4, 11 and 17). Figure 4. Safety scores of burning cases in IS. Fire equipment and fire safety management are seriously lacking in some cases. 4.2. Fire Risk in Stages with BN According to the Bayesian network, the possibilities from ignition to spread, and the safety evacuation are analyzed. Overall, the probability value of 20% or less can be considered as safe, according to the criteria in Table 3. The results are shown in Figures 5 and 6. It can be seen that the possibility of ignition in IS is high, but due to the role of fire equipment and fire protection design, the possibilities of a fire from ignition to spread is gradually reduced. If the fire protection design is better and the reliability of the fire equipment is higher, the reduction process is more obvious (Case 6 and 19). Moreover, the results are consistent with the results of the fire risk index method. The safety score of Case 6 is the highest among all the cases with the fire risk index, while the possibility from ignition to spread is the lowest, and the possibility of safety evacuation is the highest for Case 6 with the Bayesian network. The cases with lower safety scores in the fire risk index, such as Cases 2, 3, 25 and 26, have higher possibilities from ignition to spread, and the possibilities of safety evacuation is also lower, correspondingly, with the Bayesian network. Figure 4. Safety scores of burning cases in IS. Fire equipment and fire safety management are seriously lacking in some cases It can be seen that the scores for fire protection design of many cases are no more than 10 points. This is related to the building materials with low fire resistance ratings and inadequate design of fire separation and evacuation. The fire equipment and fire safety management are seriously lacking for some cases, as one of them has a score of 0 (Case 4, 9 and 10), or even both are 0 (Case 2, 3, 25 and 26). The complete fire equipment includes a water supply system, fire hydrant system, sprinkler system, automatic fire alarm system,

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Reach, Road, Long, Rainy, Far, Get, Min, Need]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 8 of 18 smoke management system, emergency lighting system, evacuation indicator system and fire extinguishers. But for many buildings in IS, there was no fire equipment, or the fire equipment was incomplete, and thus the safety score for this item is low. Fire safety management has not received enough attention in IS, leading to its low safety score. The fire control publicity and training provided by the communities are inadequate in IS: on one hand, people have little knowledge of requirements on safe ignition (Case 4, 11, 21 and 26). On the other hand, there is no training and drill for extinguishment or evacuation, resulting in the improper response to the fire at an early stage (Case 21 and 25) and incorrect escape ways when the fire becomes big (Case 4, 11 and 17) 4.2. Fire Risk in Stages with BN According to the Bayesian network, the possibilities from ignition to spread, and the safety evacuation are analyzed. Overall, the probability value of 20% or less can be considered as safe, according to the criteria in Table 3 . The results are shown in Figures 5 and 6 . It can be seen that the possibility of ignition in IS is high, but due to the role of fire equipment and fire protection design, the possibilities of a fire from ignition to spread is gradually reduced. If the fire protection design is better and the reliability of the fire equipment is higher, the reduction process is more obvious (Case 6 and 19). Moreover, the results are consistent with the results of the fire risk index method. The safety score of Case 6 is the highest among all the cases with the fire risk index, while the possibility from ignition to spread is the lowest, and the possibility of safety evacuation is the highest for Case 6 with the Bayesian network. The cases with lower safety scores in the fire risk index, such as Cases 2, 3, 25 and 26, have higher possibilities from ignition to spread, and the possibilities of safety evacuation is also lower, correspondingly, with the Bayesian network Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 9 of 19 Figure 5. Possibilities from ignition to spread of burning cases in IS. It is gradually reduced. Figure 6. Possibilities for safety evacuation of burning cases in IS. The possibility of Case 6 is the highest. The high fire risk of IS is specifically explained from the fire process and evacuation: 1 Ignition: Judging from the causes of IS fires in Table 1, 18 of these cases were electrical fires. The electrical wiring in IS is mostly irregular, and, coupled with improper operation or no separation of combustible materials (Case 9, 10 and 24), the possibility of fire is high. 2 Fire growth: After the ignition, a fire can be extinguished in the stage of growth. Two conditions need to be satisfied for extinguishing: the fire is discovered in time, and the human response is correct. However, in the fire cases, the two conditions were not met. Some fires occurred during the night when people were asleep, and there is no fire detector installed, so the fire is hardly detected in time. Secondly, the fire extinguishers were extremely lacking in IS, and the residents did not receive training on how to extinguish a fire. Therefore, the extinguishment is unlikely to succeed, and the possibility of growth is high. 3 Fire development: If there is a fire compartment or sprinkler system in the building, or the fire brigade can arrive timely, the possibility of fire development can be reduced significantly. For many burning cases in IS, these is no fire compartment or sprinkler system (or it is damaged), and thus the prevention of the fire development mainly depends on the fire brigade. However, many IS are far away from the fire brigades, so it took a long time for the fire brigade to reach the fire site. In only four of the 26 fires, firefighters arrived at the burning building within 5 min after receiving the alarm. In rainy weather (Case 25), or if the road into IS is blocked (Case 4 and 18), the situation will get worse. 4 Fire spread: Whether the fire will spread to the neighboring buildings is mainly related to the fire separation distance and weather factors (mainly wind speed). For Figure 5. Possibilities from ignition to spread of burning cases in IS. It is gradually reduced Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 9 of 19 Figure 5. Possibilities from ignition to spread of burning cases in IS. It is gradually reduced. Figure 6. Possibilities for safety evacuation of burning cases in IS. The possibility of Case 6 is the highest. The high fire risk of IS is specifically explained from the fire process and evacuation: 1 Ignition: Judging from the causes of IS fires in Table 1, 18 of these cases were electrical fires. The electrical wiring in IS is mostly irregular, and, coupled with improper operation or no separation of combustible materials (Case 9, 10 and 24), the possibility of fire is high. 2 Fire growth: After the ignition, a fire can be extinguished in the stage of growth. Two conditions need to be satisfied for extinguishing: the fire is discovered in time, and the human response is correct. However, in the fire cases, the two conditions were not met. Some fires occurred during the night when people were asleep, and there is no fire detector installed, so the fire is hardly detected in time. Secondly, the fire extinguishers were extremely lacking in IS, and the residents did not receive training on how to extinguish a fire. Therefore, the extinguishment is unlikely to succeed, and the possibility of growth is high. 3 Fire development: If there is a fire compartment or sprinkler system in the building, or the fire brigade can arrive timely, the possibility of fire development can be reduced significantly. For many burning cases in IS, these is no fire compartment or sprinkler system (or it is damaged), and thus the prevention of the fire development mainly depends on the fire brigade. However, many IS are far away from the fire brigades, so it took a long time for the fire brigade to reach the fire site. In only four of the 26 fires, firefighters arrived at the burning building within 5 min after receiving the alarm. In rainy weather (Case 25), or if the road into IS is blocked (Case 4 and 18), the situation will get worse. 4 Fire spread: Whether the fire will spread to the neighboring buildings is mainly related to the fire separation distance and weather factors (mainly wind speed). For Figure 6. Possibilities for safety evacuation of burning cases in IS. The possibility of Case 6 is the highest.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Poor, Channel, Try, Walls, See, Rental]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 9 of 18 The high fire risk of IS is specifically explained from the fire process and evacuation: 1 Ignition: Judging from the causes of IS fires in Table 1 , 18 of these cases were electrical fires. The electrical wiring in IS is mostly irregular, and, coupled with improper operation or no separation of combustible materials (Case 9, 10 and 24), the possibility of fire is high 2 Fire growth: After the ignition, a fire can be extinguished in the stage of growth. Two conditions need to be satisfied for extinguishing: the fire is discovered in time, and the human response is correct. However, in the fire cases, the two conditions were not met. Some fires occurred during the night when people were asleep, and there is no fire detector installed, so the fire is hardly detected in time. Secondly, the fire extinguishers were extremely lacking in IS, and the residents did not receive training on how to extinguish a fire. Therefore, the extinguishment is unlikely to succeed, and the possibility of growth is high 3 Fire development: If there is a fire compartment or sprinkler system in the building, or the fire brigade can arrive timely, the possibility of fire development can be reduced significantly. For many burning cases in IS, these is no fire compartment or sprinkler system (or it is damaged), and thus the prevention of the fire development mainly depends on the fire brigade. However, many IS are far away from the fire brigades, so it took a long time for the fire brigade to reach the fire site. In only four of the 26 fires, firefighters arrived at the burning building within 5 min after receiving the alarm. In rainy weather (Case 25), or if the road into IS is blocked (Case 4 and 18), the situation will get worse 4 Fire spread: Whether the fire will spread to the neighboring buildings is mainly related to the fire separation distance and weather factors (mainly wind speed). For some burning cases, the fire separation distance was not considered during design (Case 8, 13 and 18). Some buildings designed the fire separation, but it was occupied by combustible sundries or illegally modified, increasing the possibility of fire spread on the contrary (Case 3, 19 and 23). The wind speed was not found to aggravate the spread in these cases, but it cannot be ignored, especially for those areas with higher wind speed. Some studies have also analyzed the effects of fire separation distance and ventilation in IS [ 2 , 36 ]. 5 Safety evacuation: From the perspective of safe evacuation, we try to fully consider the factors that affect the evacuation (See Appendix B ). In these cases, the factors are in poor condition for IS. There was only one staircase and one exit, and the evacuation channel was filled with combustible materials in many houses (Case 4, 11, 16, 17, 19 and 25). In some industrial buildings, the emergency lighting system and evacuation indicator system was damaged and did not function (Case 9 and 10). Meanwhile, there are many short-term rental houses in IS, and the occupants have low awareness of fire safety and are also unfamiliar with the escape routes of the building. Once a fire occurs, it is easy to cause casualties 5. Discussion According to the above analysis, we have a semi-quantitative and staged understanding of the fire risk in IS in China. In this section, we will have a discussion of the high fire risk in IS based on the fire risk sources, including fire protection design, fire equipment and fire safety management, and then put forward some suggestions to reduce the fire risk 5.1. Fire Risk Sources • Fire protection design First, in terms of building materials, many buildings in old communities use brick, adobe or wood for their walls, but these materials have low fire resistance ratings. In some buildings, the ceilings, floors and walls are wood, which will aggravate the development and spread of fire (e.g., Case 4, 8, 18 and 26). For some buildings in the informally constructed or modified settlements, the roof is made of color steel plates. Figure 7 shows a

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Top, Chinese, Sparks, Burn, Wire, Path, Hall, Closed, Block, Heaven, Carbon, Turn, Bare, Ability, Kitchen, Wall, Lot, Glass, Plate, Area, Living, Reason, Impossible, Take, Kind, Rooms, Heat, Trip, General, House]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 10 of 18 kind of common color steel plate on the market in China [ 37 ], which is cheap, convenient and beautiful for construction. However, it is a great fire hazard as it has poor fire resistance The strength of this material will rapidly decrease and collapse easily when the building catches fire, forming a large area of combustion and producing dense smoke and high temperature [ 38 – 40 ]. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 10 of 19 some burning cases, the fire separation distance was not considered during design (Case 8, 13 and 18). Some buildings designed the fire separation, but it was occupied by combustible sundries or illegally modified, increasing the possibility of fire spread on the contrary (Case 3, 19 and 23). The wind speed was not found to aggravate the spread in these cases, but it cannot be ignored, especially for those areas with higher wind speed. Some studies have also analyzed the effects of fire separation distance and ventilation in IS [2,36]. 5 Safety evacuation: From the perspective of safe evacuation, we try to fully consider the factors that affect the evacuation (See Appendix B). In these cases, the factors are in poor condition for IS. There was only one staircase and one exit, and the evacuation channel was filled with combustible materials in many houses (Case 4, 11, 16, 17, 19 and 25). In some industrial buildings, the emergency lighting system and evacuation indicator system was damaged and did not function (Case 9 and 10). Meanwhile, there are many short-term rental houses in IS, and the occupants have low awareness of fire safety and are also unfamiliar with the escape routes of the building. Once a fire occurs, it is easy to cause casualties. 5. Discussion According to the above analysis, we have a semi-quantitative and staged understanding of the fire risk in IS in China. In this section, we will have a discussion of the high fire risk in IS based on the fire risk sources, including fire protection design, fire equipment and fire safety management, and then put forward some suggestions to reduce the fire risk. 5.1. Fire Risk Sources • Fire protection design First, in terms of building materials, many buildings in old communities use brick, adobe or wood for their walls, but these materials have low fire resistance ratings. In some buildings, the ceilings, floors and walls are wood, which will aggravate the development and spread of fire (e.g., Case 4, 8, 18 and 26). For some buildings in the informally constructed or modified settlements, the roof is made of color steel plates. Figure 7 shows a kind of common color steel plate on the market in China [37], which is cheap, convenient and beautiful for construction. However, it is a great fire hazard as it has poor fire resistance. The strength of this material will rapidly decrease and collapse easily when the building catches fire, forming a large area of combustion and producing dense smoke and high temperature [38–40]. Figure 7. A kind of common color steel plate on the market. It is dangerous when burning. Second, the design of fire separation and evacuation in IS is inadequate. There is a lack of fire compartment in some buildings. For example, the facade of the building in Case 2 is barbed wire instead of solid wall, and in Case 11, the partition wall between the kitchen and the hall has not reached the ceiling, which failed to prevent the fire. In many Figure 7. A kind of common color steel plate on the market. It is dangerous when burning Second, the design of fire separation and evacuation in IS is inadequate. There is a lack of fire compartment in some buildings. For example, the facade of the building in Case 2 is barbed wire instead of solid wall, and in Case 11, the partition wall between the kitchen and the hall has not reached the ceiling, which failed to prevent the fire. In many houses, there is only one staircase and one exit; even worse, the evacuation channel is filled with combustible materials such as cartons and plastic bottles or parked with bicycles/electric bicycles. When a fire occurs, they will burn and generate a lot of heat and smoke to increase the fire, but also block the evacuation route. For many burning cases, the house was built with a middle staircase and surrounded by rooms according to residents’ living habits, and the internal structure is shown in Figure 8 . In this structure, the only path to go up and down is the staircase in the middle that leads to the top, and the top is closed with glass for lighting. This type of house was called “Tongtian house”, which means the house can be directly connected to the heaven in Chinese. However, once a fire occurs, the middle are with the staircase of the building will serve as a chimney. Smoke spreads rapidly from bottom to top, and once the smoke starts to enter the stairwell, the stairwell becomes the smoke spreading channel, which overlaps with the personnel escape channel, leading to the failure of evacuation. In addition, as the roof is enclosed with glass, there is a large amount of heat and toxic smoke generated in the stairwell without exhausting, making it impossible for people to survive [ 41 ]. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 11 of 19 houses, there is only one staircase and one exit; even worse, the evacuation channel is filled with combustible materials such as cartons and plastic bottles or parked with bicycles/electric bicycles. When a fire occurs, they will burn and generate a lot of heat and smoke to increase the fire, but also block the evacuation route. For many burning cases, the house was built with a middle staircase and surrounded by rooms according to residents’ living habits, and the internal structure is shown in Figure 8. In this structure, the only path to go up and down is the staircase in the middle that leads to the top, and the top is closed with glass for lighting. This type of house was called “Tongtian house”, which means the house can be directly connected to the heaven in Chinese. However, once a fire occurs, the middle are with the staircase of the building will serve as a chimney. Smoke spreads rapidly from bottom to top, and once the smoke starts to enter the stairwell, the stairwell becomes the smoke spreading channel, which overlaps with the personnel escape channel, leading to the failure of evacuation. In addition, as the roof is enclosed with glass, there is a large amount of heat and toxic smoke generated in the stairwell without exhausting, making it impossible for people to survive [41]. Figure 8. The internal structure of “Tongtian house”. In this structure, the only path to go up and down is the staircase in the middle that leads to the top. Third, the electrical fire protection design of some buildings in IS is not standardized (e.g., Case 9, 11, 22 and 25). The laying of electrical wires or cables is hazardous as they are bare, and there is a lack of short-circuit protective devices (SCPD), or the SCPD was installed incorrectly. When sparks are generated by an electrical fault, they can easily turn into big fires if the combustibles are not separated, such as combustibles directly covered on the electrical wires, or the distance from the electrical circuit is too small. • Fire equipment For ordinary residential buildings, considering the affordability of different classes, the configuration of fire equipment is not mandatory in the fire regulations in China, so the actual situation is that there is no fire equipment in most residential buildings, especially in IS with low economic levels. The fire detector, for instance, is not installed in houses, which makes it difficult for people to detect fires early and take actions to extinguish them or escape, especially during the night. The reason for serious casualties in some cases is that the fire occurred at night or early morning when people were asleep, or the discovery and alarm of the fire were late, inducing the death of carbon monoxide inhalation. The fire extinguishers are also extremely lacking, and the effectiveness of extinguishing a fire by personnel is extremely low. Due to the lower floors of general residences in IS, there is no mandatory requirement of an automatic sprinkler system, so the firefighting mainly depends on the fire brigade when the fire becomes larger. However, many IS are far away from the city and the fire brigades; the fire brigade has to spend a longer time on the trip, weakening the fire control ability. For industrial and commercial buildings, such as plants, hotels, restaurants, etc., however, the fire hydrant system and automatic sprinkler system are mandatory. In some buildings in IS, they are substandard. For example, the sprinkler system in case 1 was Figure 8. The internal structure of “Tongtian house”. In this structure, the only path to go up and down is the staircase in the middle that leads to the top.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Tank, Flame, Pipe, Close, Oil, Quality]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 11 of 18 Third, the electrical fire protection design of some buildings in IS is not standardized (e.g., Case 9, 11, 22 and 25). The laying of electrical wires or cables is hazardous as they are bare, and there is a lack of short-circuit protective devices (SCPD), or the SCPD was installed incorrectly. When sparks are generated by an electrical fault, they can easily turn into big fires if the combustibles are not separated, such as combustibles directly covered on the electrical wires, or the distance from the electrical circuit is too small • Fire equipment For ordinary residential buildings, considering the affordability of different classes, the configuration of fire equipment is not mandatory in the fire regulations in China, so the actual situation is that there is no fire equipment in most residential buildings, especially in IS with low economic levels. The fire detector, for instance, is not installed in houses, which makes it difficult for people to detect fires early and take actions to extinguish them or escape, especially during the night. The reason for serious casualties in some cases is that the fire occurred at night or early morning when people were asleep, or the discovery and alarm of the fire were late, inducing the death of carbon monoxide inhalation. The fire extinguishers are also extremely lacking, and the effectiveness of extinguishing a fire by personnel is extremely low. Due to the lower floors of general residences in IS, there is no mandatory requirement of an automatic sprinkler system, so the firefighting mainly depends on the fire brigade when the fire becomes larger. However, many IS are far away from the city and the fire brigades; the fire brigade has to spend a longer time on the trip, weakening the fire control ability For industrial and commercial buildings, such as plants, hotels, restaurants, etc., however, the fire hydrant system and automatic sprinkler system are mandatory. In some buildings in IS, they are substandard. For example, the sprinkler system in case 1 was closed, the indoor fire hydrant was not connected to the municipal pipe network and there was no fire water tank in Case 9, and in Case 20, a component of the sprinkler system failed, causing the system to fail to function It should be pointed out that many burning cases in IS were originally designed as residential buildings, but they were actually turned into “mixed-function” buildings, which mixed the functions of accommodation, production, storage and business (IFS, e.g., Case 3, 5, 7, 8 and 15). For this type of building, it is not a standardized and legal single-function building, so fire equipment should be necessary. In these burning cases, there was no related fire equipment Moreover, some IS are located in urban–rural fringe areas or villages in the city, where the number and layout of municipal fire hydrants are improper. It will also reduce the fighting ability of the fire brigade • Fire safety management Relatively, most of the residents in IS are lower-income and less-educated, and their safety awareness is low. Some studies have revealed the high fire risk related to low income and education [ 42 – 44 ]. The fire control publicity and training provided by the communities are inadequate: on one hand, people have little knowledge of requirements on safe ignition, so the use of electrical appliances or oil was improper, or the open flame was close to combustible materials. On the other hand, there is no training and drill for extinguishment or evacuation, resulting in the improper response to the fire at an early stage and incorrect escape ways when the fire becomes big; some even jumped off the building (Case 4). Similarly, the burning of industrial or commercial buildings in IS have caused serious casualties due to the insufficient emergency quality and capabilities of staff, as they were not trained in accordance with fire regulations In the informally functioned settlements, the mixed functions have also led to a large increase in flammable and combustible substances. In terms of management, the fire responsibility has not been cleared, and the strict fire safety operating procedures, detailed extinguishment and evacuation plans have not been formulated.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Change, Gas, Train, Basic, Micro, Simple, Cost, Manner, Rate]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 12 of 18 5.2. Solutions In this section, we attempt to provide some suggestions to reduce the risk, respectively, for the building occupants, community organizations and emergency managers: For the occupants, it is necessary to check the electrical system regularly and dispose the combustibles properly. Worn and aging wires need to be replaced in time, and the bared wires can be protected by flame-retardant pipe. At the same time, the combustibles should be away from electrical circuits or electrical equipment as far as possible. Some simple but useful fire equipment, such as fire detectors, fire extinguishers, gas masks and escape ropes, should also be gradually promoted to be configured within families. Since the income level of occupants in IS is relatively low, the cost of the renovation and configuration can be partly subsidized by the government to increase the coverage rate For community organizations, managers and volunteers can provide the basic knowledge of fire prevention and response, especially the use of fire extinguishers and safe evacuation, through regular community promotion activities, such as evacuation drills and practical fire extinguisher training. Meanwhile, through community inspections, a reminder of the occupied evacuation channel can be made, and it can be ordered to be corrected For the emergency managers, voluntary firefighters should be trained, and micro fire stations should be established. IS are generally far away from the city center or in rural areas, and the reliability of the professional fire brigade is reduced because of the time of the trip. It is helpful to set up micro fire stations near IS with fire nozzles, hoses, water pumps and fire extinguishers and train volunteer firefighters regularly. With these measures, firefighting and evacuation will be advanced and standardized. However, it is more important for the government to prevent the appearance of new IS by strictly reviewing the construction and gradually promote the demolition of IS in a reasonable and orderly manner if possible These suggestions can be categorized into two types of measures: strengthening fire safety management or improving fire equipment (for IS, the fire protection design can be hardly changed as the buildings have been in use, so the measures from fire protection design are not considered), and we use Bayesian networks to illustrate the effectiveness of these measures. The states of nodes remain unchanged, except for those nodes relating to fire safety management or fire equipment, and the uncertain risk will be changed accordingly. The results are shown in Figure 9 . In this figure, the values of “Fire cases” are the average values of the possibilities of the 26 cases, and the values of “Strengthening fire safety management” and “Improving fire equipment”, respectively, correspond to the possibile results when only the sates of nodes relating to fire safety management or fire equipment are changed Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , x 13 of 19 reviewing the construction and gradually promote the demolition of IS in a reasonable and orderly manner if possible. These suggestions can be categorized into two types of measures: strengthening fire safety management or improving fire equipment (for IS, the fire protection design can be hardly changed as the buildings have been in use, so the measures from fire protection design are not considered), and we use Bayesian networks to illustrate the effectiveness of these measures. The states of nodes remain unchanged, except for those nodes relating to fire safety management or fire equipment, and the uncertain risk will be changed accordingly. The results are shown in Figure 9. In this figure, the values of “Fire cases” are the average values of the possibilities of the 26 cases, and the values of “Strengthening fire safety management” and “Improving fire equipment”, respectively, correspond to the possibile results when only the sates of nodes relating to fire safety management or fire equipment are changed. Figure 9. The risk change with two types of measures: strengthening fire safety management or improving fire equipment. From Figure 9, it can be seen that strengthening fire safety management will greatly reduce the probabilities of ignition and growth, but it cannot significantly prevent the development and spread of fire; while improving fire equipment can significantly prevent the development and spread, although it cannot prevent the occurrence of fire (as unsafe behavior and combustibles still exist). Whether it is to strengthen fire management or increase fire protection facilities, the possibility of safety evacuation can be greatly increased. However, as mentioned above, it requires a certain cost to improve fire equipment, especially for fire hydrant systems and sprinkler systems. The detailed cost-benefit analysis can be carried out further, but generally, strengthening fire management is a more feasible solution for IS, as it improves building safety greatly with low investment costs relatively. Of course, if it is affordable, the configuration of fire equipment will also increase safety. At least compared to other equipment, the cost of fire detectors and extinguishers is lower, and they can be considered in IS in the future. 6. Conclusions The painful fire cases in IS have brought profound lessons to fire researchers and managers in China, and the government of some countries where IS still exist should also learn from them. With the risk index and Bayesian network methods, the specific fire risk of 26 burning buildings in IS in China were assessed in this paper, and the results also revealed the high risk of the buildings in IS. First, the risk index system is used to assess the degree of fire risk of buildings in IS semi-quantitatively from the aspects of fire protection design, fire equipment and fire safety management. Then, a Bayesian network of building fire risk is established to reflect the staged risk change from ignition to spread as well as the safety evacuation. Finally, we also put forward some suggestions for occupants in IS, community organizations and emergency managers to reduce the fire risk from the Figure 9. The risk change with two types of measures: strengthening fire safety management or improving fire equipment.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Natural, Resources, Work, Board, Read, Original, Grant, Author]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 13 of 18 From Figure 9 , it can be seen that strengthening fire safety management will greatly reduce the probabilities of ignition and growth, but it cannot significantly prevent the development and spread of fire; while improving fire equipment can significantly prevent the development and spread, although it cannot prevent the occurrence of fire (as unsafe behavior and combustibles still exist). Whether it is to strengthen fire management or increase fire protection facilities, the possibility of safety evacuation can be greatly increased. However, as mentioned above, it requires a certain cost to improve fire equipment, especially for fire hydrant systems and sprinkler systems. The detailed cost-benefit analysis can be carried out further, but generally, strengthening fire management is a more feasible solution for IS, as it improves building safety greatly with low investment costs relatively. Of course, if it is affordable, the configuration of fire equipment will also increase safety. At least compared to other equipment, the cost of fire detectors and extinguishers is lower, and they can be considered in IS in the future 6. Conclusions The painful fire cases in IS have brought profound lessons to fire researchers and managers in China, and the government of some countries where IS still exist should also learn from them. With the risk index and Bayesian network methods, the specific fire risk of 26 burning buildings in IS in China were assessed in this paper, and the results also revealed the high risk of the buildings in IS. First, the risk index system is used to assess the degree of fire risk of buildings in IS semi-quantitatively from the aspects of fire protection design, fire equipment and fire safety management. Then, a Bayesian network of building fire risk is established to reflect the staged risk change from ignition to spread as well as the safety evacuation. Finally, we also put forward some suggestions for occupants in IS, community organizations and emergency managers to reduce the fire risk from the aspects of fire safety management and fire equipment, which are proved to be effective with the Bayesian network method In this research, we conduct a risk assessment of IS in China and propose some feasible measures to reduce fire risks, aiming to provide reference for the fire management of IS and reduce the occurrence of fires and casualties. Due to current data acquisition, we only studied the burning buildings in IS, and have not yet conducted risk assessment on ordinary buildings in IS that do not catch fire. We will conduct follow-up studies on these ordinary buildings to see if there are new risk characteristics. The risk assessment method can also be improved further: the current risk index system is for all types of buildings, and a risk index system that is more applicable to IS can be constructed, considering the special characteristics of IS; in the Bayesian network, the conditional probabilities are set based on the knowledge and experience of experts, and subsequent research can be improved on the objectivity of the probabilities Author Contributions: Conceptualization, J.H. and X.X.; Funding acquisition, X.S.; Investigation, S.S.; Methodology, J.H. and X.X.; Project administration, S.S.; Resources, X.X., X.N. and L.Z.; Software, X.X. and L.Z.; Supervision, X.S., S.S., X.N. and L.Z.; Writing—original draft, J.H. and X.X.; Writing—review and editing, X.X. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript Funding: This work was supported by the National Key R&D Program of China (Grant No:2020 YFC 0833402) and National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No:72204139). The authors are grateful to the editors and anonymous reviewers for their suggestions in improving the quality of the paper Institutional Review Board Statement: Not applicable Informed Consent Statement: Not applicable Data Availability Statement: Not applicable Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest.

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Code, Start, Pump, Roller, Lane, Missing, Half]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 14 of 18 Appendix A In this research, the fire risk index system is composed of 69 factors based on the fire regulations in China and, considering the availability of information and the weight of each factor, is decided by experts with the AHP method. The factors are structured under three global factors: fire protection design, fire equipment and fire safety management; the specific description and weight of each factor under the global factor are shown in Tables A 1 – A 3 . There are four grades for each factor, namely A, B, C and D from high to low When calculating the risk index, A is converted into 100 points, B is 70 points, C is 40 points and D is 0 points as x i in Equation (1). The description of each grade is also specified. If the information of a factor is unknown, the default score is 60 points. The information missing factors in each case did not exceed half of the total number of indicators (35), ensuring the rationality of the results Table A 1. The description and weight of each factor under the global factor of fire protection design Objects Factors Weight Building layout 1 Building height 0.00435 Fire resistance rating 0.00435 Fire separation distance 0.00102 Fire lane setting 0.00168 Fire climbing site 0.00168 Fire elevator 0.00168 Fire lane occupation 0.00168 Fire compartment Equipment rooms 0.01468 Fire doors, roller shutter and firewalls 0.01957 Pipe shaft 0.01468 Design for evacuation Evacuation routes 0.00700 Staircase 0.02099 Emergency exit 0.02099 Emergency doors 0.02099 Shelter 0.00700 Decoration and insulation materials Combustion performance of the wall materials 0.01077 Combustion performance of the indoor decoration materials 0.01077 Installation type of decoration and insulation materials 0.00359 Electrical fire protection design Separation distance of wires 0.00345 Quality of electrical equipment and cables 0.01036 Fire protection for wire laying 0.01036 Fire prevention between electrical equipment and combustibles 0.00345 Exposure condition Relative humidity 0.00123 Wind speed 2 0.00368 1 Referring to Code for Fire Protection Design of Building (GB 50016-2014) for the requirement and classification of building height, fire resistance rating, fire separation distance and so on 2 Referring to Wind Scale (GB/T 28591-2012) for detailed description of wind scale Table A 2. The description and weight of each factor under the global factor of fire equipment Objects Factors Weight Fire water supply system Fire pump 0.02500 Stabilized pressure pump 0.02500 Water level in the fire water tank 0.02500 Fire hydrant system Fire hydrant components 0.01071 Fire hydrant start pump 0.03214 Fire hydrant pressure 0.03214

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Cont, Power, Duty, Year, Days, Room, Graphic, Past, Node]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 15 of 18 Table A 2. Cont Objects Factors Weight Automatic sprinkler system Sprinkler components 0.02250 Model and layout of nozzle 0.00750 End water-test equipment installation 0.02250 End water-test equipment pressure 0.02250 Fire alarm system Fire control center 0.00804 Model and layout of fire detectors 0.00804 Fire detector’s function 0.00804 Fire protection telephone 0.00804 Emergency broadcast 0.00804 Graphic display devices 0.00804 Linkage control of fire signal 0.00804 Linkage control of fire roller shutter 0.00261 Failure rate of fire detectors 0.00804 Electrical fire monitoring device 0.00804 Smoke management system Exhausting system function 0.00938 Model and layout of exhausting system 0.00313 Smoke prevention system function 0.00938 Model and layout of smoke prevention system 0.00313 Emergency power supply system Fire emergency power 0.01250 Terminal switching device 0.01250 Emergency lighting system and evacuation indicator system System components 0.00938 Model and layout of luminaires 0.00313 Model and layout of evacuation indicators 0.00313 Linkage control function 0.00938 Fire extinguishers Model of extinguishers 0.01500 Layout of extinguishers 0.00500 Validity period and pressure of extinguishers 0.00500 Table A 3. The description and weight of each factor under the global factor of fire safety management Objects Factors Weight Fire legality Fire legality of the building 0.02071 Fire safety management system Security policies and operating regulations 0.01280 Fire protection archives 0.02231 Responsibilities of the departments and personnel 0.02545 Implementation of fire safety management Fire safety training and education records within one year 0.01771 Fire inspections in the past 30 days 0.05312 On-duty status of the control room in the past 30 days 0.05312 On-duty status of the control room in the past 24 h 0.01771 Routine maintenance in the past 30 days 0.05312 Alarm review in the past 24 h 0.05312 Rectification of fire hazards in the past 7 days 0.05312 Plans and drill records within one year 0.01771 Appendix B There are a total of 66 nodes in the Bayesian network structure for fire risk assessment, which affect the possibilities of fire from ignition to spread and safety evacuation. Since there are so many nodes, to simplify the process of parameter setting and probability operation, most of the nodes are set to only two states. The name and states of each node related to each stage of the fire are shown in Tables A 4 – A 8 . If the state of a node is unknown, it is treated as being in a certain state with equal probability. The information missing nodes in the Bayesian network for each case did not exceed half of the total number of

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Play, Chemical, Station, Manual, Good, Lightning]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 16 of 18 nodes (33), ensuring the rationality of the results. There are many conditional probability tables because of the large number of nodes, and they are not shown in the text Table A 4. The name and states of the nodes related to ignition in Bayesian network Number Name States I 1 Open flame Yes; No I 2 Smoke Yes; No I 3 Play with fire Yes; No I 4 Arson Yes; No I 5 Operation with sparks Yes; No I 6 Human sources Yes; No I 7 Unsafe electricity consumption behavior Yes; No I 8 Standardization of electrical equipment and wires installation Yes; No I 9 Separation from combustibles Yes; No I 10 Electrical sources Yes; No I 11 Pyrophoric chemical Yes; No I 12 Dangerous substance Yes; No I 13 Lightning stroke Yes; No I 14 Environmental factor Yes; No I 15 Ignition sources Yes; No I 16 Security policies and operating regulations Yes; No I 17 Fire safety training and education Yes; No I 18 Rectification of fire hazards Yes; No I 19 Fire prevention management Yes; No Table A 5. The name and states of the nodes related to growth in Bayesian network Number Name States S 1 Ignition Yes; No G 1 Fire detector’s settings Yes; No G 2 Fire detector’s function Yes; No G 3 Fire alarm system Yes; No G 4 Configuration of extinguishers Yes; No G 5 Operation training of extinguishers Yes; No G 6 Responsibilities of the departments and personnel Yes; No G 7 Manual extinguishing Yes; No Table A 6. The name and states of the nodes related to development in Bayesian network Number Name States S 2 Growth Yes; No D 1 Vertical fire compartment Yes; No D 2 Horizontal fire compartment Yes; No D 3 Fire compartment Yes; No D 4 Standardization of decoration and insulation Materials Yes; No D 5 Fire resistance Good; Medium; Poor D 6 Structural fire protection Yes; No D 7 Fire control center Yes; No D 8 On-duty status Yes; No D 9 Fire control manager Yes; No D 10 Linkage control function Yes; No D 11 Fire control system Yes; No D 12 Automatic sprinkler system Yes; No D 13 Fire hydrant system Yes; No D 14 Distance to the fire station (Whether the arrival time is more than 5 min) Yes; No D 15 Clear fire lane Yes; No D 16 Fire brigade Yes; No

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Costa Rica, Eng, Wheeler, Gate, Brazil, Wade, Omar, Gales, Eksteen, Jeanneret, Beshir, Rica, Sci, Blackett, Gibson, Berlin, October, Arce, Germany, Centeno, Iii, Costa, Saf, Cooper, Nairobi, Plume, Zika, Charlesworth, Ngau, Cairns, Stevens]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 17 of 18 Table A 7. The name and states of the nodes related to spread in Bayesian network Number Name States S 3 Development Yes; No Sp 1 Fire separation Yes; No Sp 2 Wind speed (Whether the wind level is more than Level 4) Yes; No Table A 8. The name and states of the nodes related to safety evacuation in Bayesian network Number Name States S 3 Development Yes; No E 0 Safety evacuation Yes; No E 1 Evacuation drills Yes; No E 2 Responsibilities of the departments and personnel Yes; No E 3 Evacuation skills Yes; No E 4 Evacuation route Yes; No E 5 Staircase Yes; No E 6 Emergency exit Yes; No E 7 Evacuating gate Yes; No E 8 Shelter Yes; No E 9 Evacuation facilities Yes; No E 10 Emergency broadcast system Yes; No E 11 Emergency announcements Yes; No E 12 Smoke management system Yes; No E 13 Building height Yes; No E 14 Emergency power supply system Yes; No E 15 Emergency lighting system Yes; No E 16 Evacuation indicator system Yes; No E 17 Fire scene environment Yes; No E 18 Complexity of evacuation process Yes; No References 1 Abunyewah, M.; Gajendran, T.; Maund, K. Profiling Informal Settlements for Disaster Risks Procedia Eng 2018 , 212 , 238–245 [ CrossRef ] 2 Cicione, A.; Wade, C.; Spearpoint, M. A preliminary investigation to develop a semi-probabilistic model of informal settlement fire spread using B-RISK Fire Saf. J 2021 , 120 , 103115. [ CrossRef ] 3 Cicione, A.; Walls, R.; Stevens, S. An Experimental and Numerical Study on the Effects of Leakages and Ventilation Conditions on Informal Settlement Fire Dynamics Fire Technol 2022 , 58 , 217–250. [ CrossRef ] 4 Beshir, M.; Omar, K.; Centeno, F.R. Experimental and Numerical Study for the Effect of Horizontal Openings on the External Plume and Potential Fire Spread in Informal Settlements Appl. Sci 2021 , 11 , 2380. [ CrossRef ] 5 Arce, S.G.; Jeanneret, C.; Gales, J. Human behaviour in informal settlement fires in Costa Rica Saf. Sci 2021 , 142 , 105384 [ CrossRef ] 6 Ngau, P.M.; Boit, S.J. Community fire response in Nairobi’s informal settlements Environ. Urban 2020 , 32 , 615–630. [ CrossRef ] 7 Gibson, L.; Wheeler, O.; Cairns, R. Fire detection in informal settlements. In Proceedings of the Remote Sensing Technologies and Applications in Urban Environments III, Berlin, Germany, 9 October 2018; Volume 10793, p. 107930 R 8 Quiroz, N.F.; Walls, R.; Cicione, A. Developing a framework for fire investigations in informal settlements Fire Saf. J 2021 , 120 , 103046. [ CrossRef ] 9 Rush, D.; Bankoff, G.; Cooper-Knock, S.J. Fire risk reduction on the margins of an urbanizing world Disaster Prev. Manag. Int. J 2020 , 29 , 747–760. [ CrossRef ] 10 Quiroz, N.F.; Walls, R.; Cicione, A. Towards Understanding Fire Causes in Informal Settlements Based on Inhabitant Risk Perception Fire 2021 , 4 , 39. [ CrossRef ] 11 Walls, R.S.; Eksteen, R.; Kahanji, C. Appraisal of fire safety interventions and strategies for informal settlements in South Africa Disaster Prev. Manag 2019 , 28 , 343–358. [ CrossRef ] 12 Isabela, W.M.; Elinorata, C.M. Urban fire risk control: House design, upgrading and replanning J à mb á J. Disaster Risk Stud 2018 , 10 , a 522. [ CrossRef ] 13 Morrissey, J.; Taylor, A. Fire Risk in Informal Settlements: A South African Case Study Open House Int 2006 , 31 , 98–105. [ CrossRef ] 14 Charlesworth, S.M.; Kligerman, D.C.; Blackett, M. The Potential to Address Disease Vectors in Favelas in Brazil Using Sustainable Drainage Systems: Zika, Drainage and Greywater Management Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 2860. [ CrossRef ] [ PubMed ]

[Find the meaning and references behind the names: Liu, Press, George, Nepal, Valley, Yuan, Delivery, Donna, Zhao, Forman, Wang, Pieper, Woodward, Jiang, Huo, Htm, Panel, Hao, Gov, Loss, Reid, Wide, Jin, Bureau, Nicola, Zhuo, Central, Rock, Multi, Mokhele, Barnes, Sun, Zhu, Rep, Reg, Vitti, Fatal, Bezzi, Aryal, Govender, Mater, Place, Post, Murray, Ind, Zhou, Feng, Bev, Link, Peng, Chen, Luan, Saul, Jenkinson, Tang, Premier, Target, Gautam, Yan, Chi, James, Ice, Shi]

Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2022 , 19 , 15689 18 of 18 15 Murray, M.J. Fire and ice: Unnatural disasters and the disposable urban poor in post-apartheid Johannesburg Int. J. Urban Reg Res 2009 , 33 , 165–192. [ CrossRef ] 16 Mutyambizi, C.; Mokhele, T.; Ndinda, C. Access to and satisfaction with basic services in informal settlements: Results from a baseline assessment survey Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 2020 , 17 , 4400. [ CrossRef ] [ PubMed ] 17 Govender, T.; Barnes, J.M.; Pieper, C.H. The impact of densification by means of informal shacks in the backyards of low-cost houses on the environment and service delivery in Cape Town, South Africa Environ. Health Insights 2011 , 5 , S 7112. [ CrossRef ] 18 John, T.; Nicola, C.; James, H. Improved Methods for Fire Risk Assessment in Low-Income and Informal Settlements Int. J Environ. Res. Public Health 2017 , 14 , 139 19 Giambelli, M.; Vitti, A.; Bezzi, M. Towards a Decision Support System for environmental emergencies management in poor settlements in the Kathmandu Valley (Nepal) Int. J. Spat. Data Infrastruct. Res 2016 , 11 . [ CrossRef ] 20 Wu, J.S.; Zhou, R.; Xu, S.D. Probabilistic analysis of natural gas pipeline network accident based on Bayesian network J. Loss Prev Process Ind 2017 , 46 , 126–136. [ CrossRef ] 21 Hao, C.; George, V.H. The modeling of fire spread in buildings by Bayesian network Fire Saf. J 2009 , 44 , 901–908 22 Matellini, D.B.; Wall, A.D.; Jenkinson, I.D. Modelling dwelling fire development and occupancy escape using Bayesian network Reliab. Eng. Syst. Saf 2013 , 114 , 75–91. [ CrossRef ] 23 Hu, J.; Shu, X.M.; Shen, S.F. A method to improve the determination of ignition probability in buildings based on Bayesian network Fire Mater 2021 , 46 , 666–676. [ CrossRef ] 24 Central People’s Government of the People’s Republic of China. Available online: http://www.gov.cn/premier/2018-10/09 /content_5328911.htm (accessed on 18 October 2021) 25 Ministry of Public Security of the People’s Republic of China Fire Safety Requirement for the Place Combined with Habitation, Production, Storage and Business ; GA 703-2007; Ministry of Public Security of the People’s Republic of China: Beijing, China, 2007 26 FSB (Fire Service Bureau) China Fire Yearbook ; Yunnan Personnel Press: Kunming, China, 2012–2018 27 China News Weekly. There Have Been Over 6000 Fire Accidents This Year! Why Do Electric Bicycles Explode Frequently? Available online: https://www.baidu.com/link?url=bEv 9 SMswaGC 2 LZn 9 r 5 FJ 1 oTaKq 08 SX 0 nbphsVGKbG-R 3 dQHwKUJ 4 EeUYEBoOyKaBST 1 NVYClqfiqcSj 4 fV 4 UmZkyMCbknJqds 1 sDJvM 0 wu&wd=&eqid=f 809 e 7 e 7001 d 699 f 0000000361 ab 1 e 0 f (accessed on 4 November 2021) 28 Forman, E.H.; Saul, I.G. The analytical hierarchy process—An exposition Oper. Res 2001 , 49 , 469–487. [ CrossRef ] 29 Li, W.X. Fire risk assessment and factor analysis of buildings based on multi-target decision and fuzzy mathematical model J Intell. Fuzzy Syst 2019 , 37 , 6337–6348. [ CrossRef ] 30 Khatakho, R.; Gautam, D.; Aryal, K.R. Multi-Hazard Risk Assessment of Kathmandu Valley, Nepal Sustainability 2021 , 13 , 5369 [ CrossRef ] 31 Feng, L.J.; Chen, X.Y.; Ma, D.L. Risk Assessment and Prevention and Control Countermeasures of Urban Village Fire based on Improved Analytic Hierarchy Process Saf. Secur 2019 , 40 , 19–23. (In Chinese) 32 Peng, J.H.; Shi, S.L.; Liu, Y. Assessment, Prevention and Control of Fire Risk in Urban-Rural Joint Area Saf. Secur 2019 , 40 , 28–31 (In Chinese) 33 Tang, F.; Hu, L.H.; Huo, R. Urban village regional fire risk assessment model based on AHP Fire Sci. Technol 2010 , 29 , 533–537 (In Chinese) 34 Global Safety Tanzer Technology Co., Ltd. GSC FIRE MANAGER. Available online: http://www.gstanzer.com/ (accessed on 22 October 2021) 35 Shu, X.M.; Yan, J.; Hu, J. Risk assessment model for building fires based on a Bayesian network J. Tsinghua Univ 2020 , 60 , 321–327 (In Chinese) 36 Wang, Y.; Gibson, L.; Beshir, M. Determination of Critical Separation Distance Between Dwellings in Informal Settlements Fire Fire Technol 2021 , 57 , 987–1014. [ CrossRef ] 37 Shengzhuo Metal Material Co., Ltd. A Kind of Color Steel Plate. Available online: https://item.taobao.com/item.htm?spm=a 230 r.1.14.16.b 44 c 78 f 2 EdWdZI&id=45246434586&ns=1&abbucket=7#detail (accessed on 2 November 2021) 38 Chi, J.P.; Jin, J.; Luan, L.S. Study on correlation between fire traces and fire condition of rock wool color steel plates China Saf. Sci J 2019 , 29 , 45–50. (In Chinese) 39 Sun, Z.Q.; Jiang, Z.A.; Zhang, J.F. Fire risk analysis and preventive measures of the building with color steel plate Sichuan Build Sci 2012 , 38 , 66–68. (In Chinese) 40 Zhuo, P.; Wang, G.H.; Zhao, B. Combustion performance of colored steel composite sandwich panel building Fire Sci. Technol 2014 , 33 , 1105–1108. (In Chinese) 41 Yuan, M.; Zhu, M.R.; Li, X.Q. Full-scale experimental study of fire hazard of building with staircase leading to the top in the middle Fire Sci. Technol 2019 , 38 , 504–508. (In Chinese) 42 Hu, J.; Shu, X.M.; Xie, S.T. Socioeconomic determinants of urban fire risk: A city-wide analysis of 283 Chinese cities from 2013 to 2016 Fire Saf. J 2019 , 110 , e 102890. [ CrossRef ] 43 Donna, S. Income, housing and fire injuries: A census tract analysis Public Health Rep 2006 , 121 , 149–154 44 Duncanson, M.; Woodward, A.; Reid, P. Socioeconomic deprivation and fatal unintentional domestic fire incidents in New Zealand 1993–1998 Fire Saf. J 2002 , 37 , 165–179. [ CrossRef ]

Other Environmental Sciences Concepts:

[back to top]

Discover the significance of concepts within the article: ‘Fire Risk Assessments of Informal Settlements Based on Fire Risk Index and...’. Further sources in the context of Environmental Sciences might help you critically compare this page with similair documents:

China, Shelter, Staircase, Wind speed, Fire protection, Fire spread, Development, Combustible, Public health, Spread, Building material, Growth, Environmental factor, Building height, Risk assessment, Developing countries, Emergency management, Emergency exit, Quantitative Risk Assessment, Community organization, Fire safety, Evacuation, Safety management, Emergency risk management, Conditional probabilities, Conditional probability table, Fire Brigade, Arson, Semi-quantitative, Bayesian Network, Directed acyclic graph, Bayesian Network (BN), Ordinary buildings, Risk index, Informal settlement, Fire Alarm System, Automatic Sprinkler System, Environmental research, Water supply system, Combustible material, Fire prevention, Analytic hierarchy process, Illegal Construction, Building layout, Unsafe behavior, Fire resistance, Security policies, Sprinkler system, Electric bicycle, Safety evacuation, Emergency lighting, Evacuation facilities, Routine maintenance, Building Fires, Fire safety management, Fire management, Fire hazard, Fire extinguishers, Risk assessment method, Fire risk, Evacuation route, Fire accident, Risk index method, Fire risk assessment, Fire equipment, Extinguishers, Fire safety training, Emergency manager, Shantytowns, Fire Protection Design, Fire Evacuation, Ignition, Evacuation drill, Weather factor, Ignition sources, Combustion performance, Risk index system, Safe evacuation, Old Communities, Risk Index Value, Fire development, Fire compartment, Fire detector, Mixed-function buildings, Automatic sprinkler, Fire resistance rating, Operating regulations.