Desire for Knowledge: The Orientalists and Their Adversaries
Journal name: Archives De Sciences Sociales Des Religions
Original article title: Robert Irwin, For Lust of Knowing. The Orientalists and their Enemies
The journal “Archives of Social Sciences of Religions” publishes advanced research on religion in French, English, and Spanish. It studies the sociology of religions and religious traditions or theologies. It is supported by the INSHS-CNRS (“Institut des Sciences Humaines et Sociales”)
This page presents a generated summary with additional references; See source (below) for actual content.
Subtitle: London, Allen Lane, 2006, 416 p.
Original source:
This page is merely a summary which is automatically generated hence you should visit the source to read the original article which includes the author, publication date, notes and references.
Eva-Maria von Kemnitz
Archives De Sciences Sociales Des Religions:
(Founded in 1956 and published quarterly”)
Full text available for: Robert Irwin, For Lust of Knowing. The Orientalists and their Enemies
Year: 2007 | Doi: 10.4000/assr.10863
Copyright (license): © Archives de sciences sociales des religions
Summary of article contents:
Introduction
Robert Irwin’s book For Lust of Knowing: The Orientalists and their Enemies examines the historical and contemporary discourse surrounding Orientalism. Published by Allen Lane in 2006, this comprehensive work spans 416 pages and provides an in-depth critique of the field of Oriental studies, particularly in the context of post-colonial perspectives that emerged after Edward Said's influential work, Orientalism (1978). Irwin argues that, contrary to the perception that Orientalism is dead or outdated, it remains a vital area of study deserving a nuanced understanding.
The Misconception of Orientalism's Demise
One of the central themes of Irwin's work is the argument against the misconception that Orientalism is no longer relevant or has been completely discredited. He highlights that despite the critiques initiated by Said, which positioned Orientalism as a tool of colonial power perpetuating negative stereotypes about Arab cultures and Islam, there is a renewed recognition of the importance of understanding the "Other." Irwin emphasizes that the globalization process and the need for intercultural dialogue have reinvigorated the study of Orientalism, suggesting that it is necessary to engage with diverse cultures to address global challenges.
The Evolution of Oriental Studies
Irwin also delves into the historical evolution of Oriental studies, emphasizing the role of significant academic institutions and scholars throughout different eras. He outlines how the field developed against a backdrop of sociocultural and political factors, marking the contributions of various centers of learning in Europe, such as the universities of Leiden, Cambridge, and Oxford. He draws attention to the critical influence of Eastern scholars who played essential roles in advancing knowledge about their own cultures, often in adversarial contexts. His detailed chronology showcases how Oriental studies have evolved and adapted, including an acknowledgment of earlier critiques and the shifts in academic perspectives.
Conclusion
In conclusion, Robert Irwin’s For Lust of Knowing provides a robust and well-documented reassessment of Orientalism, challenging the dominant narrative established by Said. Irwin posits that rather than being a benign relic or an overtly harmful intellectual enterprise, Orientalism has complex and varied histories and remains a dynamic field of inquiry. By engaging with the multifaceted nature of Oriental studies, Irwin ultimately calls for a reclamation and rehabilitation of Orientalism as a credible academic pursuit, essential for understanding cultural dynamics in our increasingly interconnected world.
FAQ section (important questions/answers):
What is the primary focus of Robert Irwin's book?
Robert Irwin's book, 'For Lust of Knowing,' examines the historical context of Orientalism, its development, criticisms, and defenders throughout history, as well as the influence of key figures and institutions in shaping this field of study.
How does the book relate to Edward Said's 'Orientalism'?
Irwin critiques Edward Said's 'Orientalism' for its flawed methodology, arguing that it misrepresents generations of scholars. He emphasizes the detrimental effects of Said’s arguments on the reputation of Orientalist studies and how they have inadvertently aided anti-Western sentiments.
What historical context does Irwin provide in his analysis?
Irwin places Orientalism within specific socio-cultural contexts, addressing the conditions of scholars who pursued these studies. He discusses the challenges they faced, including access to materials and societal skepticism regarding their interests in Eastern cultures.
What contributions to Orientalism does Irwin highlight in his work?
The book highlights significant contributions from Orientalists across different countries, particularly mentioning England, France, and Russia. Irwin explores how these scholars developed their expertise and the interplay between geopolitical interests and scholarly pursuits.
Why is Irwin's book considered important for understanding Orientalism?
Irwin's scholarship offers a nuanced perspective on Orientalism, incorporating extensive documentation and contextual reflections. The book serves as a necessary rehabilitation of the field, providing richer insights for scholars and readers regarding its complexities and relevance.
Glossary definitions and references:
Theological and religious glossary list for “Desire for Knowledge: The Orientalists and Their Adversaries”. The list explains important keywords that occur in this and other scholarly articles. It is also linked to the glossary for understanding that concept in the context of History, Religion, Philosophy, Theology, Sociology etc.
1) Language:
The study of the Arabic language is essential in understanding Orientalism, as it opened access to texts, cultures, and civilizations that were analyzed by scholars. Mastery of the language became a pillar of knowledge in the field, critical for transmitting information and engaging in meaningful dialogue about the rich traditions of Arabic literature.
2) Knowledge:
The book emphasizes the importance of knowledge as a foundation for understanding the complexities of Orientalism and its evolution. Knowledge shapes the perception of different cultures and is vital in fostering intercultural dialogue, challenging stereotypes, and addressing critiques, particularly in the context of scholarly endeavors.
3) Book:
Robert Irwin’s book is a significant contribution to the study of Orientalism, offering a detailed critique of the tradition and its practitioners. It serves as a vital resource for researchers and students, presenting a rich narrative of the evolution and transmission of knowledge across different periods and cultures.
4) Religion:
Religion plays a crucial role in the discourse surrounding Orientalism, especially considering the historical context where Islam and Christianity often stood in opposition. The critique of Orientalism includes the examination of how religious perceptions influenced scholarly work and how these religious frameworks created obstacles in the quest for objective knowledge.
5) Arabic language:
The Arabic language is central to the study of Orientalism, as it is the primary means through which much of the knowledge and literature of the region is accessed. Understanding Arabic facilitates a deeper engagement with the cultural and historical texts critical to the evolution of Oriental studies.
6) Recognition:
Recognition of the contributions of Eastern scholars in the field of Oriental studies highlights the interconnectedness of cultures. It underscores the importance of acknowledging diverse voices and perspectives in the debate surrounding Orientalism, which has been populated by Western narratives lacking full recognition of their Eastern counterparts.
7) Critique:
The book presents a robust critique of Edward Said's perspective on Orientalism and its implications for understanding the relationship between the West and the East. This critique is essential for examining how the methodologies of Orientalism have been evaluated and the ways in which Orientalism has influenced perceptions across civilizations.
8) India:
India's historical significance in the development of Oriental studies is exemplified through its rich tradition of scholarship, especially during the British colonial period. The engagement with Indian culture and language provided a complex backdrop for Orientalism, illustrating the interrelationship between knowledge, power, and civilization.
9) Paris:
The Congress of Orientalists convened in Paris exemplifies an era of heightened interest in Oriental studies. The significance of such summits underscores the historical importance of academic gatherings in shaping the discourse and evolution of Orientalism, serving as a space for debate and exchange of knowledge.
10) Arabic literature:
Arabic literature is a critical component of Oriental studies, as it provides insights into the cultural, philosophical, and artistic expressions of Arab civilization. Exploring Arabic literature enriches the understanding of the languages and cultures that fuel the dialogue and critique surrounding Orientalism.
11) Roman Empire:
[see source text or glossary: Roman Empire]
12) Civilization:
The study of civilizations, particularly in the context of Orientalism, involves examining how cultural exchanges, power dynamics, and knowledge production contribute to the understanding of different societies. This examination is crucial for grappling with the legacies of past interactions between the East and the West.
13) Transmission:
The transmission of knowledge in Oriental studies is facilitated by academic institutions and networks built by scholars. This process of transmission is fundamental to preserving and advancing scholarly pursuits in understanding various cultures, including those related to the Arabic language and literature.
14) Literature:
The literature generated from Oriental studies heavily influences the ongoing debate about representations of the 'Other.' Such literature often reflects the complexities of cultural exchanges, showcasing both the wealth of knowledge and the critiques inherent in historical narratives.
15) Reflection:
Reflection on the methods and practices of Orientalism is necessary to address the criticisms that have emerged in recent scholarship. Such reflection allows for a deeper understanding of both the obstacles and advancements within the field as it continues to evolve.
16) Science (Scientific):
The scientific approach to studying Orientalism and its various critiques illustrates the importance of rigorous methodologies in analyzing cultural knowledge. Scientific inquiry is fundamental in advancing the discourse surrounding the complexities of language, literature, and civilization.
17) Evolution:
The evolution of Oriental studies is marked by various phases, shifting from colonial interests to more nuanced understandings that prioritize intercultural dialogue. Understanding this evolution helps in comprehending the transformations within scholarly perspectives on Eastern cultures.
18) Dialogue:
The notion of intercultural dialogue is a recurring theme, highlighting the necessity of engaging with diverse cultures to foster mutual understanding. This dialogue is integral in challenging stereotypes and building connections across different civilizations.
19) Solitary (Solitude):
The solitary pursuits of early orientalists reveal the challenges faced by scholars who ventured into unfamiliar territories and cultures. Their experiences underscore the complexities of transmitting knowledge in a field often marked by skepticism and academic obstacles.
20) Obstacle:
The obstacles encountered in the study of Orientalism include linguistic barriers, historical prejudices, and the stigma attached to studying cultures viewed as 'Other.' These obstacles must be acknowledged to understand the difficulties in establishing a comprehensive discourse.
21) Hundred:
[see source text or glossary: Hundred]
22) Network:
The network of scholars and institutions devoted to Oriental studies plays a critical role in disseminating knowledge. These collaborative efforts foster a rich landscape for academic inquiry that spans multiple cultures and languages.
23) Lexicon:
The creation of lexicons, such as Golius's Lexicon for the Arabic language, exemplifies the scholarly efforts to codify and transmit knowledge within the context of Oriental studies. These resources significantly enhance the understanding of languages and the cultures they represent.
24) Branch (Branches):
Oriental studies constitute a distinct branch of knowledge that explores the languages, literatures, and cultures of Eastern societies. This branch has undergone significant changes, particularly in response to critiques and evolving academic discourses.
25) Wealth:
The wealth of documentation and scholarship concerning Orientalism reflects the richness of knowledge surrounding the complexities of Eastern cultures. This wealth underscores the importance of continued research and engagement in the field.
26) Persia:
The study of Persia's cultural and historical influences is fundamental in Oriental studies. Understanding Persia's contributions enhances the broader discourse surrounding knowledge transmission and interaction between East and West.
27) Debate:
The ongoing debate about the nature of Orientalism and its impacts highlights the contested nature of cultural knowledge. This debate is essential for critiquing existing narratives and shaping future research interests within the field.
28) Pillar:
[see source text or glossary: Pillar]
29) Egypt:
Egypt's role in Oriental studies is significant due to its historical and cultural contributions to the field. The examination of Egypt allows scholars to explore themes of power, knowledge, and the evolution of Orientalism over time.
30) Roman (Roma):
[see source text or glossary: Roman]
31) Power:
The interplay of power dynamics within Oriental studies impacts the understanding of cultural relationships and knowledge production. Analyzing this power is essential for critiquing the colonial legacies that have shaped the discourse.
32) Space:
[see source text or glossary: Space]
33) Anti (Amti):
The anti-Western sentiments that have emerged in reaction to the critiques of Orientalism reveal the complexities of cultural relationships. This highlights the need for a more nuanced understanding of how these sentiments influence scholarly discourse.
34) Nas (Nash):
Geoffrey P. Nash's contributions represent innovative approaches to contemporary issues in Oriental studies. His work underscores the importance of engaging with critical dialogues that enrich understanding beyond traditional narratives.
35) Face (Facing, Faced):
[see source text or glossary: Face]
36) Dead:
[see source text or glossary: Dead]