Exploring Alternative Authority Among Catholic Conservatives
Journal name: Archives De Sciences Sociales Des Religions
Original article title: Visions and Visionaries. The Search for Alternative Forms of Authority Among Catholic Conservatives / Visions et visionnaires. La recherche de formes alternatives d'autorité chez les conservateurs catholiques
The journal “Archives of Social Sciences of Religions” publishes advanced research on religion in French, English, and Spanish. It studies the sociology of religions and religious traditions or theologies. It is supported by the INSHS-CNRS (“Institut des Sciences Humaines et Sociales”)
This page presents a generated summary with additional references; See source (below) for actual content.
Original source:
This page is merely a summary which is automatically generated hence you should visit the source to read the original article which includes the author, publication date, notes and references.
Elizabeth Isichei
Archives De Sciences Sociales Des Religions:
(Founded in 1956 and published quarterly”)
Full text available for: Visions and Visionaries. The Search for Alternative Forms of Authority Among Catholic Conservatives / Visions et visionnaires. La recherche de formes alternatives d'autorité chez les conservateurs catholiques
Year: 1991
Copyright (license): © Archives de sciences sociales des religions
Summary of article contents:
Introduction
This paper explores the responses of conservative Catholics in New Zealand to the changes brought about by Vatican II. These groups encompass a spectrum of beliefs, from those who remain within mainstream Catholicism and form organizations like Catholics United for the Faith (CUF) to those who have aligned themselves with separatist movements, such as the followers of Archbishop Lefebvre or the Palmarians. The paradox they face lies in their desire to preserve the Catholicism of the past amidst the transformational changes introduced by ecclesiastical authority, resulting in various methods of coping with this identity crisis.
The Dilemma of Authority
At the core of the conservative Catholics' struggle is a profound dilemma regarding ecclesiastical authority. Historically, obedience to the Church's hierarchy was fundamental to Catholic identity, yet the same authority now enforces changes these conservatives oppose. Responding to this paradox involves divergent beliefs among these groups, with some maintaining that the papal seat is vacant, others aligning with an anti-pope, and some asserting loyalty to a reigning conservative pope while denouncing local bishops. This internal conflict drives many to seek alternative forms of authority through mystical experiences and visions, such as those reported at Fatima and La Salette.
The Influence of Visionary Experiences
Many conservative Catholics find solace and confirmation of their beliefs through celebrated visions. Events at Fatima, where children reported visions of hell, and La Salette, which foretold severe church corruption, have become pivotal in conservative and traditionalist spirituality. These visions serve to reinforce their concerns regarding the direction of the modern Church and validate their grievances against contemporary ecclesiastical leaders. Such apocalyptic messages resonate deeply within the conservative circles, elucidating their interpretation of perceived crises faced by the Church.
The Lefebvrist and Traditionalist Response
The followers of Archbishop Lefebvre, while they do not officially identify as such, represent a significant traditionalist faction grappling with their interpretation of authority and tradition. After Lefebvre was excommunicated for ordaining bishops without papal approval, his followers faced the reality of being in a state of schism yet continue to view themselves as defenders of a true but misguided church. They navigate their identification with tradition while opposing modern church leadership, often referencing prior saints like Athanasius as foundations for their claims. Their response to visionary experiences is mixed, as some adherents embrace them while others are more skeptical, showcasing a diverse internal landscape.
The Role and Impact of Alternative Groups
Other groups, such as the Palmarians, present more radical adaptations of conservative Catholicism. Proclaiming their leader as Pope Gregory XVII, Palmarians have developed distinctive doctrines and claims of exclusive validity within their sacramental practices. The movement thrives on visionary experiences and emphasizes eschatological warnings, further solidifying their identity as a remnant of true Catholicism amidst a perceived decline. This phenomenon illustrates how conservative groups utilize unique charismatic leadership and adopted visions to contend with mainstream church changes and articulate their own framework for authority and validation.
Conclusion
In conclusion, conservative Catholics in New Zealand embody a complex reaction to the ecclesiastical upheaval following Vatican II. The tension they experience regarding authority and identity prompts them to explore alternative avenues for maintaining their faith, often through visionary experiences and charismatic leadership. Despite their attempts to cling to a past version of Catholicism through various sect-like characteristics, they face the challenge of reconciling their beliefs with a dynamic and evolving Church landscape. Ultimately, these movements reflect broader global trends within Catholicism, revealing both the struggles and the resilience of those who hold fast to their convictions amid significant change.
FAQ section (important questions/answers):
What is the focus of Elizabeth Isichei's paper on Catholic conservatives?
Isichei's paper explores how New Zealand Catholic conservatives respond to changes following Vatican II, examining their search for alternative authority forms and their engagement with visionary experiences.
How do conservative Catholics manage the issue of authority within the Church?
They experience a dilemma because traditional obedience to church authority conflicts with the changes they criticize. Some assert loyalty to a conservative Pope, while others view the authority as vacated or corrupted.
What is the significance of visions in conservative Catholic spirituality?
Visions from figures like Fatima and La Salette play central roles in conservative spirituality, serving as validation for their beliefs and as sources of apocalyptic warning against perceived moral decay in the Church.
Who are the Lefebvrists, and what is their stance on Church authority?
The Lefebvrists are followers of Archbishop Lefebvre who consider themselves orthodox Catholics. They claim papal loyalty but assert that contemporary church leaders have strayed from tradition, thus facing a crisis over authority.
What is the nature of the Little Pebble movement?
The Little Pebble movement, led by William Kamm, claims prophetic visions and is characterized by traditional Catholic teachings. It promotes apocalyptic messages, emphasizes Marian devotion, and seeks connection with other conservative visionary groups.
How do the Palmarians differ from mainstream Catholicism?
Led by Clemente Dominguez, the Palmarians have declared themselves a 'true' Church with their own pope. They reject mainstream sacraments and authority, claiming new revelations that challenge traditional Catholic beliefs.
What challenges do these conservative movements face within the Catholic community?
Conservative movements often encounter marginalization and criticism from mainstream Catholics for their extremist views. Many experience a sense of persecution while opposing modern church policies and practices, causing internal turmoil.
Glossary definitions and references:
Theological and religious glossary list for “Exploring Alternative Authority Among Catholic Conservatives”. The list explains important keywords that occur in this and other scholarly articles. It is also linked to the glossary for understanding that concept in the context of History, Religion, Philosophy, Theology, Sociology etc.
1) Priest:
A priest is a religious leader in the Catholic faith responsible for conducting mass, administering sacraments, and providing spiritual guidance to parishioners. The role of the priest is central to Catholic worship and has been impacted by changes in doctrine since Vatican II.
2) Faith:
Faith refers to a strong belief in religious doctrines and teachings, particularly within the context of Catholicism. It serves as a guiding principle for many conservative Catholics seeking to uphold traditional teachings in the face of modern challenges.
3) Experience:
Experience in this context relates to personal encounters with religious phenomena, such as visions or miracles that reinforce one's faith. Visionary experiences are often used to authenticate beliefs among conservative groups.
4) Seer:
A seer is an individual who claims to receive divine revelations or visions. Seers often attract followers who believe these messages provide insight into spiritual truth and future events, particularly in relation to eschatology.
5) Literature:
Literature here encompasses the various writings and texts produced by conservative and traditionalist Catholic groups, which reflect their beliefs, interpretations, and responses to modernity. This body of work serves as a foundation for their beliefs.
6) Religion:
Religion is the organized system of beliefs, practices, and values centered around the worship of deities. The Catholic faith is explored in this text, particularly how conservative factions navigate changes within the church.
7) Woman (Women):
Women in this context refers to the involvement and roles of women within Catholic conservatism, particularly in groups like CUF and their responses to issues such as feminism and traditionalism.
8) Soul:
The soul represents the spiritual essence of a person, central to Catholic teachings and eschatology. The concept of the soul is often tied to the fear of damnation as described in visions from Fatima and similar revelations.
9) Wing:
[see source text or glossary: #Wing#]
10) Eschatology:
Eschatology is the theological study of end times and final events in human history as depicted in religious texts. For conservative Catholics, eschatological messages from seers often predict severe future tribulations and the need for repentance.
11) Commitment:
Commitment refers to the dedication of individuals to their faith and the conservative Catholic movements. This often involves participating in practices and communities that emphasize traditional beliefs and values.
12) Child (Children):
Child highlights the innocence associated with youthful seers, whose visions provide a lens for understanding divine messages. Their status often grants authority to the revelations they share.
13) Devotion (Devoted):
Devotion signifies a deep commitment to religious practices and beliefs, particularly towards figures like Mary. This strong emotional investment is common among conservative and traditionalist Catholics.
14) Identity:
Identity relates to how conservative Catholics perceive themselves in relation to their faith and the historical church. The search for a cohesive identity often leads to adherence to the traditional practices they cherish.
15) Heart:
[see source text or glossary: #Heart#]
16) Anti (Amti):
[see source text or glossary: #Anti#]
17) Cult:
Cult may refer to fringe movements that have deviated from mainstream Catholic beliefs. Many conservative groups express cult-like characteristics by holding strict interpretations of faith and often reject broader church authority.
18) Blue:
[see source text or glossary: #Blue#]
19) Multiplicity:
Multiplicity refers to the diverse array of visions and movements within conservative Catholicism. This variety can bolster followers' faith, as different sources enhance the authenticity of their beliefs.
20) Recognition:
[see source text or glossary: #Recognition#]
21) Discussion:
[see source text or glossary: #Discussion#]
22) Immediacy:
Immediacy in a religious context speaks to the direct encounter and experience with the divine. Many conservative Catholics emphasize the need for immediate responses to spiritual crises through visions and revelations.
23) Extreme:
Extreme denotes the fervent and uncompromising attitudes held by some members of conservative Catholic movements. Their positions often lead to radical actions in support of traditional beliefs.
24) Shrine:
A shrine is a place of worship and veneration, often associated with miraculous events or saints. Shrines draw individuals seeking spiritual experiences and reassurance of their faith.
25) Secret (Secrecy, Secretly):
The idea of a secret relates to hidden knowledge or messages, particularly from visions like Fatima, which are believed to contain undisclosed truths about the future that inform followers' beliefs.
26) Doubt:
Doubt describes the inner conflict some Catholics face regarding the changes in the church. Conservatives often interpret doubt as arising precisely from the changes they deplore since Vatican II.
27) Truth:
Truth in this context refers to the absolute beliefs held by conservative Catholics about their faith. Many derive a sense of certainty from the teachings and visions they follow.
28) Peace:
[see source text or glossary: #Peace#]
29) Food:
[see source text or glossary: #Food#]
30) Hell:
Hell signifies the ultimate place of damnation, a common theme in eschatological visions, such as those from Fatima. The fear of hell often motivates conservative Catholics to seek repentance and adherence to traditional practices.
31) Lead:
[see source text or glossary: #Lead#]
32) Hope:
Hope represents the positive expectation among conservatives that their faith and practices will lead to salvation and restoration of traditional Catholic values in the future.
33) Young girl:
Young girl refers to the seers of various visions, particularly the children at places like Fatima and Garabandal. Their youthful innocence is believed to be a conduit for divine messages.
34) Conversation:
[see source text or glossary: #Conversation#]
35) Alcoholism:
[see source text or glossary: #Alcoholism#]
36) Confession:
Confession is a sacrament in the Catholic faith where individuals confess their sins to a priest. Conservatives often highlight its importance in maintaining moral integrity and spiritual health.
37) Knowledge:
[see source text or glossary: #Knowledge#]
38) Dimension:
[see source text or glossary: #Dimension#]
39) Restrained (Restraint, Restraining):
[see source text or glossary: #Restraint#]
40) Confusion (Confused):
Confusion embodies the state of uncertainty experienced by some Catholics regarding doctrinal changes. This confusion often prompts a search for alternative authorities within their faith traditions.
41) Nakedness:
[see source text or glossary: #Nakedness#]
42) Marriage:
[see source text or glossary: #Marriage#]
43) Exercise:
[see source text or glossary: #Exercise#]
44) Mindless:
Mindless refers to a perceived lack of awareness among church leaders by conservative factions. They criticize bishops as being disconnected from the spiritual realities faced by faithful members.
45) Impurity:
Impurity highlights the moral concerns raised by certain conservative Catholics regarding societal issues, such as sexuality and behavior that contradict traditional teachings.
46) Euphoria:
Euphoria describes the joyful experience some conservative Catholics feel in their faith, particularly during collective worship or expressions of devotion, although it can follow by identity crises.
47) Disease:
[see source text or glossary: #Disease#]
48) Monster:
[see source text or glossary: #Monster#]
49) Feeling:
Feeling embodies the emotional aspects of faith, including both the joy of devotion and the fear of losing connection with God amid changing church doctrines.
50) Triumph:
[see source text or glossary: #Triumph#]
51) Worship:
Worship encapsulates the acts of reverence and adoration directed towards God in the Catholic tradition. It serves as an essential practice for expression of faith and community among believers.
52) Network:
[see source text or glossary: #Network#]
53) Foolish:
[see source text or glossary: #Foolish#]
54) Student:
Student, in this context, refers to the youth who are exploring their faith against the backdrop of traditional beliefs. They often express concern over the direction of the contemporary church.
55) Leaf (Leaves):
[see source text or glossary: #Leaves#]
56) Branch (Branches):
[see source text or glossary: #Branch#]
57) Family:
Family plays a significant role in the lives of conservative Catholics. The tensions that arise from varying beliefs within a family regarding faith can lead to conflict.
58) Prayer:
Prayer is the central practice of communication with God in the Catholic faith. It is crucial for individual and communal expression of devotion and is often emphasized in conservative circles.
59) Throne:
[see source text or glossary: #Throne#]
60) Stream:
[see source text or glossary: #Stream#]
61) Desire:
Desire reflects the longing for a return to traditional faith values among conservative Catholics, driven by a fear of modernity undermining their beliefs.
62) Future:
Future signifies the anticipated outcomes and events as predicted in eschatological beliefs. Conservatives cling to these predictions for guidance and security in their faith.
63) Mason:
[see source text or glossary: #Mason#]
64) India:
[see source text or glossary: #India#]
65) Kenya:
[see source text or glossary: #Kenya#]
66) Magic:
[see source text or glossary: #Magic#]
67) Death:
Death signifies the transition from life to the afterlife, a topic often reflected upon in Catholic teachings, especially concerning judgment and the fate of the soul.
68) House:
[see source text or glossary: #House#]
69) Earth:
Earth represents the physical realm where humans live and is contrasted with the spiritual realm. Many conservative Catholics believe current events on Earth connect to prophetic visions.
70) Dress:
[see source text or glossary: #Dress#]
71) Demon:
[see source text or glossary: #Demon#]
72) Thief:
[see source text or glossary: #Thief#]
73) Anger (Angry):
[see source text or glossary: #Anger#]
74) Pakan:
[see source text or glossary: #Pagan#]
75) Grim (Grm):
Grim refers to the bleak outlook on spirituality and morality that some conservative Catholics adopt, particularly when discussing the state of the church or society.
[Note: The above list is limited to 75. Total glossary definitions available: 81]