Erling Skakke replied thus to the king's speech:
"It is my duty, sire, not to be silent; and I shall give my advice, since it is desired.
The resolution now adopted is contrary to my judgment; for I call it foolhardy to fight under these circumstances, although we have so many and such fine men.
Supposing we make an attack on them, and row up against this river-current; then one of the three men who are in each half room must be employed in rowing only, and another must be covering with the shield the man who rows; and what have we then to fight with but one third of our men?
It appears to me that they can be of little use in the battle who are sitting at their oars with their backs turned to the enemy.
Give me now some time for consideration, and I promise you that before three days are over I shall fall upon some plan by which we can come into battle with advantage."
It was evident from Erling's speech that he dissuaded from an attack; but, notwithstanding, it was urged by many who thought that Hakon would now, as before, take to the land.
"we cannot get hold of him; but now they have but few men, and we have their fate in our own hands."
Gregorius said but little; but thought that Erling rather dissuaded from an attack that Gregorius's advice should have no effect, than that he had any better advice to give.