Contemporary Religious Authorities in Twelver Shiism
Journal name: Archives De Sciences Sociales Des Religions
Original article title: Les Autorités religieuses dans le chiisme duodécimain contemporain
The journal “Archives of Social Sciences of Religions” publishes advanced research on religion in French, English, and Spanish. It studies the sociology of religions and religious traditions or theologies. It is supported by the INSHS-CNRS (“Institut des Sciences Humaines et Sociales”)
This page presents a generated summary with additional references; See source (below) for actual content.
Original source:
This page is merely a summary which is automatically generated hence you should visit the source to read the original article which includes the author, publication date, notes and references.
Sabrina Mervin
Archives De Sciences Sociales Des Religions:
(Founded in 1956 and published quarterly”)
Full text available for: Les Autorités religieuses dans le chiisme duodécimain contemporain
Year: 2004 | Doi: 10.4000/assr.1033
Copyright (license): © Archives de sciences sociales des religions
Summary of article contents:
Introduction
The article examines the role and authority of religious leaders in contemporary Twelver Shiism, focusing on how Shiite clerics (oulémas) have navigated political landscapes throughout history. It discusses significant moments that have shaped their authority, particularly the development and institutionalization of the marja‘iyya, an important concept in Shiite religious hierarchy. The text outlines the historical evolution of clerical authority, the independence of Shiite religious institutions from state control, and the emergence of new actors within this framework.
The Concept of Marja‘iyya
One key aspect discussed in the text is the concept of marja‘iyya, which refers to the institution of religious authority in Twelver Shiism where individuals known as marja‘ (plural: marja‘iyya) become sources of emulation for the faithful. This institution emerged as a response to the absence of leadership after the occultation of the twelfth imam. With the marja‘iyya, clerics gained the authority to make religious rulings and offer guidance, thus filling the vacuum left by the hidden imam. The marja‘iyya evolved over time, especially from the late 19th century, becoming a transnational and somewhat centralized authority. Its establishment allowed Shiite clerics to claim functions traditionally attributed to the imam, reinforcing their authority and influence within the community.
Historical Context of Clerical Authority
The text highlights the historical context in which Shiite clerics have operated, especially in relation to political power. Unlike Sunni scholars, who often legitimized existing political authorities, Shiite clerics have typically adopted a more contentious attitude. An illustrative event is the tobacco protest of 1891, where a fatwa against tobacco consumption successfully mobilized public dissent against the state, showcasing the effectiveness of clerical authority. This event, among others, has been a pivotal example in clerical narratives that demonstrate their capacity to challenge political power and engage in social activism, reinforcing their position in the Shiite community.
Role of Financial Independence
Another significant aspect of the marja‘iyya discussed in the text is the financial independence of Shiite clerics. This autonomy is critical for maintaining their distance from state influence and affirming their authority. Through the collection of religious taxes (khums and zakat) and managing their finances, the clerics can fund religious institutions, schools, and social services, thus establishing a comprehensive system of support for their communities. This financial independence has allowed the Shiite religious authority to thrive in various contexts, even amidst pressures from political regimes, and to engage actively in societal matters.
The Emergence of New Actors
The article also addresses the emergence of new religious actors within Shiite Islam, largely influenced by the Islamic Republic of Iran's initiatives in promoting religious education and sharing knowledge. This influx of new participants has led to changes in the landscape of Shiite authority, with individuals from non-traditional family backgrounds stepping into clerical roles. Universities and religious institutions now produce clerics with both religious and academic credentials, transforming traditional notions of authority. These developments signal a potential shift in the dynamics of Shiite clerical leadership and engagement with contemporary issues.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the exploration of authority within contemporary Twelver Shiism reveals a complex interplay of tradition, state interaction, and evolving social dynamics. The institution of marja‘iyya remains pivotal, providing religious leadership and guidance while navigating political challenges. The financial independence of clerics bolsters their position, allowing the continued relevance of the clergy in Shiite communities. Simultaneously, the introduction of new actors into the religious landscape promises to reshape the future of Shiite authority, suggesting a capacity for adaptation and reform within the tradition. The ongoing discussions around these concepts highlight the dynamic nature of Shiite religious leadership in an ever-changing world.
FAQ section (important questions/answers):
What major historical event highlighted the authority of Shiite clerics?
The 1891 Tobacco Protest in Iran demonstrated the influence of clerics, as Muhammad Hasan al-Shîrâzî's fatwa against tobacco consumption united people against the Shah's concession to foreign interests, restoring national solidarity and showcasing clerical power.
How did Shiite clerics claim authority in the absence of imams?
Following the major occultation of the twelfth imam in 941, Shiite clerics gradually articulated their authority as representatives of the imam, assuming powers through doctrinal developments that allowed them to guide spiritual and political matters.
What is the role of the marja‘iyya in Shiite Islam?
The marja‘iyya is an institutionalized authority in Shiite Islam, enabling clerics to provide religious guidance and interpretations for believers. It evolved to establish a direct relationship between the cleric and followers, with responsibilities extending to political matters.
What distinguishes the marja‘iyya from Sunni religious authority structures?
Unlike the Sunni hierarchy which has been more centralized under state control, the marja‘iyya remains relatively autonomous, built on financial independence and a decentralized network of clerics who gain recognition through scholarly achievements.
How have recent reforms influenced Shiite religious authority?
Recent educational reforms in Shiite seminaries have introduced secular subjects and structured curricula. This modernized approach faced resistance, reflecting a balance between maintaining traditional autonomy and adapting to contemporary educational needs.
What challenges does the marja‘iyya face today?
The marja‘iyya faces challenges of organization, legitimacy, and establishing a clear institutional framework. Debates regarding the relationship between religious and political authorities continue, especially in the wake of modernity and the influence of the Islamic Republic of Iran.
What impact did the Iranian Revolution have on clerical roles?
The Iranian Revolution enabled clerics like Khomeini to expand their powers significantly, merging spiritual and political leadership. This era shifted the perception and functioning of the marja‘iyya, emphasizing its role in governance alongside religious authority.
Glossary definitions and references:
Theological and religious glossary list for “Contemporary Religious Authorities in Twelver Shiism”. The list explains important keywords that occur in this and other scholarly articles. It is also linked to the glossary for understanding that concept in the context of History, Religion, Philosophy, Theology, Sociology etc.
1) Power:
In the context of Shi'ism, power was traditionally vested in the imams, with the ulama asserting their authority in the absence of the twelfth imam. The fatwa issued by religious leaders emphasized the spiritual power they held over believers, allowing them to influence societal norms and politics.
2) Shumni (Sumni, Sunni):
Sunni Islam has historically seen its religious leaders, or ulama, tend to legitimize established powers. In contrast, Shiite ulama have maintained a stance of reserve towards political authority, highlighting a significant doctrinal difference between the two branches of Islam.
3) Doctrine:
The development of Shiite doctrine particularly revolves around the authority of the marja‘ as a key figure in interpreting Islamic law. This evolution also saw debates concerning the role of clerics in relation to the imamate, shaping the political and spiritual landscape of contemporary Shi'ism.
4) Religion:
Religion serves as a foundational essence in Shi'ism, where the teachings of the imams and the authority of the ulama guide the spiritual life of believers. The interplay between religious authority and political engagement has marked Shiite history and ongoing practice.
5) Sah:
The Shah of Iran traditionally represented temporal power, often conflicting with the spiritual authority of the ulama. The tobacco protest against the Shah is an exemplification of how religious figures can mobilize popular protest against a ruler deemed illegitimate.
6) Revolution:
The Iranian Revolution illustrates the culmination of religious authority challenging state power. Under Khomeini, the revolution redefined the relationship between religion and state, with clerical figures playing a central role in mobilizing support for radically transforming governance.
7) Knowledge:
Knowledge in the context of Shi'ism is rooted in religious education and the pursuit of ijtihad, leading to a hierarchy of religious scholars. The popularization of religious knowledge in recent times has opened paths for new interpretations and discussions within the community.
8) Student:
Students in the hawza represent the next generation of religious scholars who are trained in both religious and secular disciplines. Their education reflects an organized approach to blending traditional Shiite knowledge with contemporary issues in society.
9) Exercise:
The exercise of ijtihad refers to the juristic effort undertaken by scholars to interpret Islamic law. It is a critical aspect of Shiite doctrine, allowing for the adaptation of religious practices to meet the needs of changing social realities.
10) Education:
Education is integral to the formation of the Shiite religious elite, where institutions like hawza emphasize traditional learning alongside modern educational practices. This dual approach fosters a more knowledgeable and versatile clerical body capable of engaging with contemporary challenges.
11) Spiritual:
Spiritual authority in Shi'ism is intimately linked with the concept of the imamate and the role of the ulama. The spiritual guidance provided by these clerics shapes the moral and ethical framework of the community, influencing both personal and communal aspects of life.
12) Politics:
Politics in Shi'ism has seen a unique evolution, characterized by the tension between religious and state authority. The role of the marja‘ in political matters has remained a topic of debate, reflecting diverse interpretations of the relationship between the two realms.
13) Worldly:
Worldly affairs often distract from the spiritual focus of Islamic teachings; nonetheless, the Shiite ulama engage with these issues as they navigate the complex relationship between religious beliefs and socio-political realities in contemporary society.
14) Debate:
Debate among scholars regarding the role of the marja' and the engagement of clerics in politics marks an ongoing discussion in Shiite religious communities. These debates shape interpretations of Islamic authority and participation in governance.
15) King:
Kings, such as the Shah of Iran, often represented the political authority challenged by Shiite religious figures. The interactions between these rulers and the ulama have significantly influenced Iran's social and political history.
16) Pari:
[see source text or glossary: #Pari#]
17) Discussion:
Discussion among the ulama showcases the diverse opinions shaping Shiite jurisprudence. These discussions influence the community's education, political visions, and interpretations of Islamic law.
18) Foreigner:
Foreign interests have historically posed challenges for Iranian sovereignty, sparking religious and nationalistic movements. The ulama's response to foreign encroachments, notably in the tobacco protest, emphasized the intersection of religious and national concerns.
19) Lineage:
Lineage serves to legitimize the authority of many Shiite clerics, linking them to significant scholarly or prophetic ancestry. This connection enhances their standing within the religious community and their claims to authority as marja‘.
20) Wealth:
Wealth among the ulama often translates to their ability to exert influence and maintain independence from the state. Financial autonomy is crucial for the functioning of the marja‘iyya and the continuation of religious authority.
21) Family:
Family ties play a substantial role in the Shiite religious authority structure. Many clerics come from 'families of knowledge' where the generational transmission of scholarship reinforces their legitimacy and positions within the community.
22) Agent:
Agents historically served as intermediaries for the twelfth imam, as Shiite communities sought guidance during his occultation. This gap was filled by the ulama, who gradually assumed roles traditionally held by the imam.
23) Musha (Musa, Musá):
Musa al-Sadr, recognized for revitalizing the Shiite community in Lebanon, exemplifies the intersection between religious authority and social reform. His dual educational background signifies the merging of traditional and modern approaches to leadership.
24) Book:
[see source text or glossary: #Book#]
25) Gate:
The 'gate of ijtihad' is a pivotal concept in Shiite jurisprudence allowing for the re-interpretation of Islamic law. The opening of this gate contrasts with Sunni practices, where it has historically remained closed.
26) Four basic schools:
The four schools of Sunni Islam represent a more fixed and traditional approach to jurisprudence compared to the evolving doctrines in Shi'ism that allow for greater adaptability through ijtihad.
27) Transformation (Transform, Transforming):
Transformation within Shiite religious structures is ongoing, where debates about the role of marja‘ and the incorporation of modern education are reshaping the approach to religious authority.
28) Communication (Communicating, Communicate, Communicated):
Clerics have historically communicated their interpretations of Islamic law and guidance to the community, maintaining the connection and authority even in the absence of the imam.
29) Recognition:
Recognition from within the clerical hierarchy is essential for any emerging religious leader in Shi'ism. Such validation ensures their authority is accepted and legitimized by established marja‘.
30) Repression:
Repression under various regimes often led to renewed solidarity among Shi'ite clerics, who rallied against oppressive powers, defining their role as protectors of the community's religious and political rights.
31) Philosophy:
Philosophy and theology intersect within Shi'ism, influencing the development of doctrines and the rationalization of clerical authority through scholarly debates and reflections on the nature of divine guidance.
32) Reflection:
Reflection on the principles of Islamic law among Shiite scholars allows for an evolving understanding of religious practices, enhancing the relevance of Shi'ism in contemporary contexts.
33) Genealogy:
Genealogy is important in validating the claims of Shiite clerics to authority. Lineage not only establishes their familial connections to influential scholars but also connects them to the prophetic line.
34) Creation:
[see source text or glossary: #Creation#]
35) Branch (Branches):
A branch of religious authority often signifies the diverse interpretations and practices within the Shi'ite community that collectively contribute to the overall landscape of Twelver Shi'ism.
36) Quietism:
Quietism within Islamic traditions refers to the passive acceptance of political authority. In contrast, the Shi'ite movement has often reflected a more dynamic engagement with political issues, influenced by the role of the ulama.
37) Critique:
Critique of established doctrines and practices is essential in Shi'ism. Scholarly debates allow for the development of new interpretations that align with contemporary challenges faced by believers.
38) Freedom:
Freedom in Shiite thought often revolves around the moral and ethical autonomy of the community, especially concerning the questioning of political authority and the pursuit of justice.
39) Gesture:
Gesture in the context of religious leadership can include public declarations or actions taken by clerics, such as the fatwa against tobacco, which demonstrated their political influence and commitment to community welfare.
40) Prayer:
Prayer, particularly the Friday prayer, is a critical communal act in Islam, where its leadership has been increasingly assumed by the ulama to reinforce their authority in matters of both spirituality and community governance.
41) Turban:
The turban worn by Shiite clerics, particularly black for those of sayyid lineage, is a symbol of their authority and is indicative of their scholarly lineage and religious status.
42) Winter:
[see source text or glossary: #Winter#]
43) Pillar:
The concept of marja‘iyya serves as a pillar of spiritual and legal authority in Twelver Shi'ism, allowing scholars to guide their communities in matters of faith and practice.
44) Ayadi:
[see source text or glossary: #Ayadi#]
45) Ridha:
[see source text or glossary: #Ridha#]
46) Syria (Syrian):
Syria's historical context showcases how Shiite clerics, like Muhsin al-Amîn, engaged in national issues, promoting communal boycotts against foreign influences, reflecting the interconnectedness of religion, politics, and society.
47) Death:
The concept of death in Shi'ism is intricately linked to the belief in the return of the Mahdî, providing a framework for understanding the eschatological role of the imams and the ongoing importance of the ulama in guiding the community.
48) House:
The concept of the household is significant in determining the familial ties and lineage that grant legitimacy to clerics. These connections ensure the continuity of religious scholarship and authority within the community.
49) Earth:
The belief in a return from the occultation signifies the role of authority on earth that Shiite imams would assume, emphasizing the expected restoration of the rightful spiritual governance.
50) Black:
The black turban worn by sayyids symbolizes their lineage derived from the Prophet Muhammad, reinforcing their esteemed status within the Shiite clerical hierarchy.
51) Judge:
Judges within the Shiite context often reflect the authority of the marja‘, as they preside over legal disputes and uphold Islamic law, thereby linking spiritual and worldly governance.
52) Woman (Women):
Women played a notable role in the effects of the fatwa against tobacco and in the broader Shiite community by participating in boycotts that demonstrated their influence alongside clerical authority.
53) Smoke:
The act of smoking tobacco was seen as a significant social and political issue, particularly illustrated by the fatwa that generated mass mobilization against foreign control, demonstrating clerical power and the engagement of the laity.
54) Anger (Angry):
Anger toward foreign domination was pivotal in motivating a collective response among the Iranian clergy and populace, highlighting the capacity of religious authority to galvanize national sentiment.
55) Court:
The court of the Shah represented the apex of political power, yet it was subject to challenge from Shiite ulama who sought to assert their spiritual authority over worldly governance.
56) Lead:
The ability to lead in both religious and political domains has been a subject of ongoing debate within Shi'ism, especially concerning the extent to which ulama should engage with political matters.
57) Dead:
The historical context of dead religious leaders continues to influence Shiite thought, as their teachings and practices remain vital in guiding current scholarly interpretations.
58) Pir:
Engagement with peers in scholarly debate allows for the refinement of ideas within the Shiite community, fostering growth and adaptation in their religious practices.