Vyavaharamala: a text on Indian jurisprudence
by P. V. Rajee | 2008 | 63,341 words
This essay is an English study on the Vyavaharamala: a text on Indian jurisprudence from the 16th century. It covers aspects of such as individual legal procedures and societal welfare, thus reflecting the judiciary principles of ancient ancient Indian society....
41. Kritanusaya prakarana (goods buying and selling)
If the person after buying goods and paying money remains their due to speculation and the person who sold the
222 objects says about needed justification it is called Critvanusaya29. If a person thinks that he does not need the objects bought by him he should return them without any damage or harm 30 • If the person who do not want the objects he bought returns after two days 1/30 th of the value will be taken from the buyer. If the objects are returned on the third day 1/15 will be lessned from the actual cost. If the transation is after three days, it is not possible to repay money. If a quarrel arises after two or three days, (ie in the case where the costemer faces loss) the problem should be solved by four persons through Vyavahara. Yajnavalkya says, there should not be speculation where the merchant himself tells the advantages and disadvantages of goods after minute expierimenting of his own. If there arises speculation 1/6 of the cost should be fined by merchant. Brihaspati says, the value of the goods should be determined by the advantages and disadvantage of the same. The goods brought 29 Voeramithrodaya: Vyavahara Prakasa: page: 338, Vyavahara Mayukha: page: 94 30 Vagra mithrodaya page: 340
223 after observing the same can not be returned back as there is no 31 justification for the same31. Vyasa says, leather, fuel, thread, cornes, liquir, clothes, lead, brass, silver, gold, ghee etc should be brought only after minute scruetiny. If it is bought there is no provisions for giving it back. Just like that fruits can be bought at once, when they seem to be good and there is no provision for returning the same. If some objects are bought due to desire, there is no need for returning the same. There is no cumpeltion over the merchant for taking back the objects sold after fixing its value and its sale. It means that goods once sold will not be taken back. The buyer may say to the seller that he may return them with in some fixed days. Regarding cornes and seeds it is ten days. Iron can be returned back at the date of purchase itself. Buffellow, horse etc should be returned back with in five days, gems and perls with in seven days, house maids with in one month or fifteen days, cow in three days. If the things are returned with in the above mentioned days, the seller should 31 Vira mithrodaya- Vyavaharaprakasa- page: 339
224 take them back. But if the things are minutely scrutinized there would not be any provision for taking the things back. Brihaspati says, if the goods are not scrutinized properly and soon after buying he finds damage, they can not be returned back. Otherwise, the seller must take it back and repay the money. Narada says, if the old clothes are purchased in reduction sale and the buyer after buying finds that he price for the same was a bit high, the goods would not be taken back and there will be no provisions for repayment by the seller32. If five to eight persons buy land or house jointly and a person among themselves gives it as alms, it should be accepted by other people. If the new cloth once used is returned after using and washing there will be change in its value. After each washing 1/8th, 1/3rd, 1/2nd or 5/8th of its value in accordance with the quality, can be reduced from its real value. The above mentioned case is used for clothes which are used.If due to 32 Vyavahara Mayukha Page: 95, ramithrodaya page: 341
225 dispute, the object bought is returned on the same day of the purchase, the amount which was given for the same can be got back. If the object is returned on the second day 1/30 th of the value and if on third day 1/15th of the value will have to be deducted from the real value and thus that amount can be repayed. If a dispute arises again, the value can be fixed by joining four or five people together in accordance with nature of the purchase. Brihaspati says, transactions in the case of jewels, elephant, horse, ass etc must be informed to the king. After that this can be sold by fixing the value of the same by a person who has good knowledge on the subject. Vyasa says, the money which is payed for an object to a person and from whom an object is bought on payment- is called price. By this manner that object will get both Samatva and Swamitva. If a land or animal etc are sold and the same objects are returned back it is called, Parivartana. If the property is bought equally, it is called
226 Vinimaya. If two different objects are bought equally, it is called Kraya. Both Parivartana and Vinimaya are equal to Kraya.
